Film details

Copying Beethoven  2006

Film still

Cast

  • Matthew Goode
  • Joe Anderson
  • Bill Stewart
  • Ralph Riach
  • Phyllida Law
  • Matyelok Gibbs
  • Viktoria Diken
  • Karl Johnson
  • Gyorgy Mendel
  • Gabor Bohus
  • Angus Barrett

Synopsis

Arriving in Vienna in 1824, Anna Holtz, a musical composition student, begins her job in Schlemmer's publishing house as a music manuscript copyist. After a manuscript by composer Ludwig Van Beethoven is completed, Anna is sent to his house to deliver it, only to be rebuffed by Beethoven because she is a woman and he does not believe women make good copyists, but after he sees her correct a small imperfection on one of the pages he accepts her and gives her the post of being his personal copyist. She starts work on his latest work, the Ninth Symphony, which is soon to be premiered, and as they work Beethoven tells her his theories of God, man and their relationship to music. Karl, his wastrel nephew who Beethoven still hopes will becomes a recital pianist, occasionally visits to borrow or steal money from his uncle, who forgives his many faults. Martin Bauer, a successful architect who is also courting Anna, is given the chance to design a bridge to span the Danube. On the night of the premiere of the Ninth Symphony, Beethoven finally admits that his increasing deafness will be a hindrance to him conducting the orchestra, so orders Anna to hide herself in the woodwind section and help him by keeping time from within the orchestra ranks. They work perfectly together and the performance is hailed as a huge triumph. Beethoven returns to work immediately on his next work, Grosse Fuge, with Anna as his copyist, a warm bond now between them, which gives her the confidence to show him one of her own compositions. He is scornful of it, claiming that no woman can write music, and she leaves, furious and humiliated. Realising what he has done, Beethoven searches for her and, finally tacking her down, pleades with her to return to him. Martin brings his model of his proposed bridge design to Beethoven's apartments for his approval, but is shocked when the maestro, appaled at its' conventionality and sterility, shatters it with his walking stick. Angered, Martin forbids Anna from working with the composer again, placing her in a difficult situation as the pressure on him following up his triumphant Ninth Symphony increases...

Production

Director
Agnieszka Holland
Producer
Sidney Kimmel, Michael Taylor, Stephen J. Rivele and Christopher Wilkinson
Art Director
Paul Ghirardani and Lorand Javor
Editor
Alex Mackie
Music
Ludwig Von Beethoven
Screenplay
Stephen J. Rivele and Christopher Wilkinson
Director of Photography
Ashley Rowe

Review

Ludwig Van Beethoven seems to be a regular subject for film biography, with Gary Oldman recently taking the role in Immortal Beauty, and here Ed Harris (Pollock / Apollo 13) takes the part, wearing a prosthetic nose and brow which oddly makes him look at times like a long-haired Tommy Lee Jones, which is really quite an unsettling effect. Although dealing with genuine events in the composer's life, director Agnieszka Holland (Europa, Europa / To Kill A Priest) and scriptwriters Stephen J. Rivele and Christopher Wilkinson largely invent the plot from scratch, inventing events in Beethoven's life as well as the character of Anna Holtz (Diane Kruger - Troy), acting as both love interest and plot propellant, whereas in reality only male copyists were ever used and women were generally excluded from the music world although. The film concentrates on Beethoven's struggles with what many believe to be his greatest work, the Ninth Symphony, and the agonies he went through to complete it before the deadline of its' first performance, as well as his insecurites caused by his encroaching deafness. Anna becomes his copyist, at the time the only way to make multiple copies of musical pieces, but is a frustrated composer herself, gender strictures of the time ensuring she could never have her pieces evaluated, less yet performed. She of course learns from the composer, as well as taking the brunt of his anger and insults, and he too starts to soften when he realises her talents. Copying Beethoven looks superb in both period details and the set-pieces, the first performance of the Ninth Symphony being beautifully mounted and edited and staged, even if the idea of Anna co-conducting from the middle of the orchestra is absurd, and Harris continues his portrayals of tortured artists begun with Jackson Pollock in 2000, The problems of trying to visually capture the creative process, even for someone as well known as Beethoven, is always a difficult task on film, and his often violent outbursts occasionally come across as mean-spirited tantrums, but Harris gives a very committed performance under Holland's sensitive direction, and even if the story is utterly fictional, Copying Beethoven is a respectful and sincere homage to the man who made some of the most stirring and affecting music ever written, even if no woman ever had a hand in it.