Film details

Tully  2017

Cast

  • Mackenzie Davis
  • Mark Duplass
  • Emily Haine
  • Elaine Tan
  • Colleen Wheeler
  • Maddie Dixon-Porter
  • Asher Miles Fallica
  • Lia Frankland
  • Joshua Pak
  • Bella Star Choy

Synopsis

Marlo, married to husband Drew and caring for elder son Jonah, who is struggling with some yet to be fully diagnosed special needs, and eight-year-old daughter Sarah, is poised to give birth for the third time and welcome a new life into their cluttered home, but it is obvious that this is a very unplanned pregnancy. Both being working parents, their lives are devoted to their children, even as Marlo starts to believe she won''t be able to cope with another child, and worry that the new arrival won''t have a bedroom of their own.

Her wealthy brother Craig becomes increasingly concerned that Marlo is struggling with the impending new arrival, and fears for her health. He offers to pay for a 'night nanny', a woman who will arrive who will take care of the baby after dark, roughly between roughly 10:30 pm until 6:30 am, allowing his sister and Drew to get a good night's sleep. Marlo is skeptical, but after the birth of their daughter, and the pair suddenly being once more in a draining circle of broken sleep and exhausting night feeds, Marlo calls the night nanny and 26-year-old Tully arrives at the front door the following night.

Confident and energetic, she immediately takes charge, taking over night duties and letting Marlo and Drew get back into their routines without any disturbances. Marlo takes care of the family during the day, having to deal with everything from Sarah's seeming jealousy of the new arrival, and Jonah being turned down from a private school by a supercilious Principle who won''t actually state the reasons why they won''t accept him, and Marlo starts to see just how indispensable Tully has become, the young woman being gentle, kind, and able to cope with the stress of caring for a baby, Marlo realising that she was, once, almost exactly the same. In the hours they have together, before Marlo goes to bed and in the mornings after she wakes, Marlo wonders how she is going to deal with life once Tully isn''t there anymore, and also what is going to happen to Tully herself…

Production

Director
Jason Reitman
Producer
Diablo Cody, A.J. Dix, Helen Estabrook, Aaron L. Gilbert, Beth Kono, Mason Novick, Jason Reitman and Charlize Theron
Art Director
Craig Humphries and Maki Takenouchi
Editor
Stefan Grube
Music
Rob Simonsen
Screenplay
Diablo Cody
Director of Photography
Eric Steelberg

Review

Tully, not the most informative or enticing of titles, marks the third collaboration between writer Diablo Cody and director Jason Reitman, following 2007''s acclaimed Juno, which is perhaps not ageing quite as well as it should, and the viciously sharp and penetrating Young Adult (''11), both smart and accurately observed comedies with a deceptively hard edge, even if the fact that all the way through Juno, a tale of unexpected teenage pregnancy, the word ''abortion'' isn''t so much as mentioned, ever mind considered, still seems like a ludicrous capitulation.

After Young Adult, the first time the pair worked with lead Charlize Theron, Reitman made the pair of Labor Day (''13) and Men, Women And Children (''14), truly overwrought and under-thought relationship dramas which would have finished the careers of many other directors, and with good reason, while Cody's only producer theatrical feature was the good natured but underwhelming Ricki And The Flash (''15) before a sojourn into TV. (Reitman was one of the producers of Cody's Jennifer's Body in '2009, with Karyn Kusama directing).

With Tully being in the position of almost being a comeback for both of them, it's gratifying to see the reviews the film is getting, praising the performances, particularly from Theron as the exhausted, fretful Marlo, and Ron Livingston (The Conjuring / TV''s Boardwalk Empire) as her decent, supportive husband Drew, the direction and script, Cody and Reitman making a surprisingly effective combination, and seeming to rein in each other's otherwise obvious excesses. Primarily known for more 'edgy' scenarios, as well as giving a final polish to the very effective Evil Dead remake in 2013, Cody's script reflects on something closer to most people's experiences, the endless, soul-destroying realities of parenthood, and the sheer damage it wreaks on the body, mind and soul. Theron's' Marlo, a role for which she put on a considerable amount of weight, loves the two children she has, and the one she is (unexpectedly) expecting, along with the fact that her son has special needs, but the thought of having to face that entire routine again, the sleepless nights and constant stress, is a real fear, and Cody brings in the interesting angle that Marlo almost starts to feel worthless within herself, feeling herself transformed into some sort of brood mare rather than a valuable wife and mother. The 'gift' from her wealthy brother Craig (director, writer and actor Mark Duplass), entertainingly slightly aloof but also caring about his sister, organises for her a 'night nurse', a woman who will literally come to their home and take care of the newborn during the night. Marlo is initially reluctant, seeing it as another example of her personal failure, and oddly, in terms of time span, this could be a continuation of Juno, had Ellen Page's character married and had another child. When Marlo finally gives in and phones the number, a literal Florence Nightingale appears in the form of 26-year-old Tully (Mackenzie Davis - The Martian / TV''s Halt And Catch Fire), and not only do Marlo and Drew get undisturbed nights, but Marlo gets to marvel at how calm and caring Tully is, and filled with the optimism and compassion she seems to have misplaced along the way.

Several critics noted how the film worked simply because Marlo's life has no massive disasters or traumas, just the arrival of an unexpected third child, years after the couple's other two children, and the anxiety this causes, Entertainment Weekly saying "'Cody, who until now has been a writer more comfortable trafficking in hipster quips and toying with easy archetypes, has written a story with real characters grappling with real issues in a way that doesn''t feel like a pose or in airquotes here"', and The Guardian noted "'It''s a marvellous movie about the lies we tell ourselves to stay sane and the reasons why we might need to tell the truth"'. The focus of many reviews were the performances, The AV Club saying '"Though Davis makes Tully convincing both as a human being and as a mysterious godsend, it''s Theron whose work is absolutely vital to Tully''s success"', and The Playlist observing '"Reitman is often at his best when he can join forces with an exceptional actor, and Theron once again helps with the heavy lifting". IndieWire noted '"Theron and Davis are dynamite together, the actresses playing off each other like two sides of the same coin"'.

With several noting it fits between the outright comedy of Juno and the emotional viciousness of Young Adult, Tully would seem to make a fascinating if often unsettling trilogy, and perhaps a little too incisive to be a completely comfortable evening's watch.