Film details

The Truth About Love  2004

Film still

Cast

  • Dougray Scott
  • Jimi Mistry
  • Branka Katic
  • Kate Miles
  • Karl Howman
  • Emma Noble
  • Simon Webbe
  • David Christian
  • Frances Valaydon-Pillay
  • Thomas S.W. Boyd
  • Eddie Cooper

Synopsis

Archie, a Bristol lawyer, sends an anonymous Valentine's Day card to Alice, the wife of his law partner and best friend, Sam. After being bet by her man-eating sister Felicity, Alice does the same to Sam, and sends him an unsigned card. When the card arrives Alice is horrified that rather than show it to her, Sam jealously conceals it from her, not even remarking on it. Alarmed at her husband's seemingly devious nature, she sends him an anonymous text message, and puts on a different voice when he responds, finding that he is surprisingly eager to be intimate, even over the phone, with a stranger, and she does not know that he also has a lover, an Eastern European woman called Katya. Wanting to find out how far Sam will go with this 'stranger', Alice arranges to meet him, as 'Anonymous', in an empty flat owned by Archie, who believes she is having an affair behind Sam's back. Once at the flat Alice insists Sam blindfolds himself, but the jealous Katya has followed him. Alice leaves before anything can happen, upset at Sam's eagerness, but is confronted by Katya, who reveals their affair. Shocked, Alice tells Archie of Sam's infidelity and they kiss, but Alice still wants to try to save her marriage, so arranges another anonymous assignation with Sam and, blindfolded, they have great sex together, after which he tells her that his wife is useless compared to her. Alice leaves and proceeds to destroy his designer wardrobe and carefully collected wine cellar. Sam and Archie's law partnership wins a major case through Archie's diligent work, but Sam claims all the credit for himself, and returns home to find the damage Alice has inflicted. Katya arrives as he stands amid the destruction, and tells him that Alice is in fact his anonymous partner. Alice decides their marriage is over and removes her wedding ring, visiting Archie in order to tell him she still wants to be friends with him, but Archie has a confession to make, about the anonymous Valentine's Day card she received.....

Production

Director
John Hay
Producer
Tracey Adam
Art Director
Penny Harvey
Editor
David Martin
Music
Debbie Wiseman
Screenplay
William Johnston and Peter Bloore, and Rik Carmichael and John Hay, based on an original story by Peter Bloore
Director of Photography
Graham Frake

Review

Shot in London back in 2004, The Truth About Love brings together a certainly varied cast in a romantic comedy which is contrived, and is based on a very old and repeatedly used set-up. The delectable Jennifer Love Hewitt (I Know What You Did Last Summer / Heartbreakers) plays Alice, a young woman married seemingly happily to Sam (Jimi Mistry - The Idol), and who decides to test his fidelity be sending him an anonymous Valentine's card. To her horror he hides the card and does not tell her about it, leading her to test him further by sending anonymous texts, which he responds to flirtatiously, she not knowing that her husband does actually have a secret lover. Discovering this she decides on a campaign of revenge, which involves getting involved with his business partner and best friend Archie (Dougray Scott - M:I - 2 / To Kill A King), but at the last moment decides to instead try to save her marriage, a plan which goes wrong when she discovers that Sam is far more interested in this anonymous seducer than his genuine wife. The balance of sympathy is probably tilted by the fact that the duplicitous Sam actually has an extra-marital lover in the form of Katya (Branka Katic), which does rather tip the scales in the favour of the surprisingly trusting Alice. Directed by John Hay (There's Only One Jimmy Grimble), one of the problems is that the characters go through such dramatic and total personality shifts, with Hewitt's Alice becoming an avenging harpy, in a situation which is pretty much of her own making, Mistry's Sam being revealed suddenly as a callous philandering adulterer, and Scott's Archie, in many ways the most interesting, being the obvious good guy but a character who is out of the picture for long stretches as Alice tries increasingly strange and slightly disturbing attempts to salvage her marriage. Even Katya transforms from a successful businessman's mistress to a spurned lover in the course of a reel. Awkwardly scripted but with a good teaming in Hewitt and Scott, who one just knows are going to get together come the fade-out, by whatever means necessary, as if to emphasise the film's British roots, it even has a role for Karl Howman (TV's Brush Strokes).