Film details

Private Property  2006

Nue Propriete
Still unavailable

Cast

  • Jeremie Reiner
  • Yannick Reiner
  • Kris Cuppens
  • Patrick Deschamps
  • Raphaelle Lubansu
  • Sabine Riche
  • Dirk Tuypens
  • Phillippe Constant
  • Catherine Salee
  • Delphine Bibet

Synopsis

Pascale, a divorced woman, still lives in the family house on the outskirts of a Belgium city she shared with her husband, Luc, who still contributes to the upkeep of the house and to supplement Pascale's low wages from her job. The house, under Belgian law, is hers to live in but not to sell, Luc having already bequeathed it to his sons upon his death. She lives with her two twin sons, both in their twenties. Thierry is a student who resents the amount of work he is given by his college, while Francois stays at home all day, seemingly not interested in finding a job. Both young men seem inordinately needy and reliant on their mother. She has begun a relationship with one of her neighbours, a Flemish chef called Jan, but when she tells her sons of the relationship they become resentful, not wanting their bond with their mother to change, and fearing for what the future may hold if they are forced to leave the house should Jan move in. To try to win them round Jan cooks a delicious gourmet meal for them, hoping it will act as a welcome introduction to the brothers, but both Thierry and Francois make it clear that they resent both him and his feelings for their mother. The evening is painful and damaging, the pair making little effort to hide their dislike of Jan, and he tells Pascale she will have to deal with them before their involvement can go any further. Wanting the twins to have to try to fend for themselves, she leaves to stay with a girlfriend for a few days. Initially confused by their new freedom, Thierry brings a girlfriend, Anne, to the house for the first time, but Francois, both angered by the invasion of what he sees as their private space, and jealous of his brother being involved with a girl, becomes tense. After Anne leaves the pair argue, a small flaring of frustration turning into a vicious scuffle, which has devastating consequences for all of them.

Production

Director
Joachim Lafosse
Producer
Joseph Rouschop
Art Director
Anna Falguere
Editor
Sophie Vercruysse
Music
Gustav Mahler
Screenplay
Joachim Lafosse and Francois Pirot
Director of Photography
Hichame Alaouié

Review

Isabelle Huppert has long been established as one of the stalwarts of French cinema, for the simple reason that she is a very fine actress and brave enough to take roles in films as diverse as the harrowing The Piano Teacher and Ma Mere as well as lighter fare such as 8 Women. Private Property puts her firmly in the middle of another intense family drama, she playing Pascale, a divorced woman who lives in the family house she once shared with her ex-husband with her two grown-up twin sons, played by real-life twin brothers Jeremie and Yannick Renier. A close family, the proximity of the three is obviously stifling, combined with the resentments which simmer under the family roof, the brothers being aggressive towards each other and constantly having sniping arguments. Pascale wants to move on in her life, introducing her new boyfriend Jan to them, but nothing seems to change and the atmosphere becomes unpleasant, forcing Pascale to take action after an excruciating dinner scene, director and co-writer Joachim Lafosse perfectly judging the conflicting emotions so that the audience is put in the awkward situation of seeing, at least partially, the potential viewpoints of all four characters involved. One feels sorry for the patient and obviously well-meaning Jan (Kris Cuppens), but also understands the fears of the twins, emotionally stunted and fearing that what they have grown up with, both the house and their one attentive parent, is about to be taken away from them. Its' a role perfectly suited to Huppert, who can turn icy at the drop of a hat, and the tolerant Pascale, finally forced into making serious and potentially emotionally damaging decisions is tailored for her, Lafosse's technique of holding on long, almost silent takes perfectly showing the inertia and cocoon of routine and safety in the house, which actually exposes how damaging it actually is. Difficult to watch in parts, even if the ending does bring around a resolution, Private Property is a sometimes painful experience, but is also a testimony to Huppert's impressive talent.