Film details
The Eye 2008
Still unavailable
Cast
-
Jessica Alba
-
-
-
Rede Serbedzija
-
-
Chloe Moretz
-
Tamlyn Tomita
-
Obba Babatunde
-
Fernanda Romero
-
Brett A. Haworth
-
Danny Mora
-
Kisha Sierra
Synopsis
Blind since an accident when she was five, Sydney Wells has been sightless for fifteen years, but has managed to become a violinist in a Los Angeles orchestra. Finally succumbing to years of pressure from her older sister Helen, Sydney finally agrees to a double cornea transplant. At first her sight is fuzzy and blurred, and she is confused when she sees a strange, threatening figure seemingly taking away the old lady in the hospital bed next to her, in the middle of the night. Sydney is surprised to hear the next morning that her neighbour died in the night. On leaving, Sydney says goodbye to Kisha, a young cancer sufferer, and has a photo taken with her. Sydney starts to be plagued with horrific visions, such as a blazing warehouse, burning people and her apartment changing from the rooms she recognises to a totally different home. After she witnesses a road accident, she sees the young woman who has been killed walking in the street, then accompanied by one of the dark shrieking figures she saw in the hospital, leading the crash victim away. Consultations with Dr. Paul Faulkner, an ocular specialist who helps those who have undergone transplants to cope with their new sense, do not calm Sydney's growing fears, which include a young boy in the corridors of her apartment block, who she later finds committed suicide. Wrecking her apartment, shattering all the lights and blocking up the windows, Sydney does not want to see what her new eyes are showing her, and gets a terrifying realisation when she finally sees the photograph of herself taken in the hospital - the woman in the photo is not who she sees in the mirror. Dr. Faulkner realises that she is on the edge of a breakdown and agrees to find out who donated the corneas. Finding they came from a young Mexican woman Ana Martinez, Sydney and Paul drive down to the small Mexican town where she died, only to find that her mother was badly burned in the factory fire which claimed five lives and which Ana had foreseen, making the other villagers claim she was a witch and forcing her to suicide. Mrs. Martinez has a heart attack and Paul drives her to hospital, leaving Sydney in the house alone, where she meets the apparition of Ana, about to commit suicide, and makes peace with her, telling Ana her prophecies were true, and people only died because they were ignored and it was not her fault. Paul returns, telling her Mrs. Martinez died in the hospital. The pair drive back, being stopped at the Mexican / US border due to the Police trying to stop a fugitive on the American side, their car being halted behind a long line of traffic including a Winnebago, a tourist bus and a fuel tanker, but when Sydney sees the ghostly apparitions emerging once more, entering the vehicles on the road, she realises another disaster is about to happen, with enormous loss of life, and must do all she can to prevent it....
Production
- Director
- David Moreau and Xavier Palud
- Producer
- Don Granger, Michelle Manning and Paula Wagner
- Art Director
- Naython Vane
- Editor
- Patrick Lussier
- Music
- Marco Beltrami
- Screenplay
- Sebastian Gutierrez, based on the original screenplay of the 2002 film The Eye / Gin Gwai by Jo Jo Yuet-Chun Hui, Oxide Pang and Danny Pang
- Director of Photography
- Jeffrey Jur
Review
The plundering of Asian genre pictures goes on with this remaking of the Pang Brothers' superbly effective The Eye / Gin Gwai, this time at the hands of French directors David Moreau and Xavier Palud, who made the superbly disturbing Them / Ils, but where the director duo's previous film made great use of the rundown central location and added a truly claustrophobia edge, this US remake at times seems more interested in interior design than delivering on the premise, moving the central character from a perfectly normal apartment in the original Thai version into one of the swankiest blocks and classiest digs on LA's Wiltshire Avenue. Unfortunately any other subtlety in the Pang brothers film is totally dispensed with, by adding a violent pre-credits sequence, very much tipping off the audience as to one of the main twists, to changing the silent, shadowy 'escorts' of the dead into howling, snarling CGI creations. In fact most of the most effective moments of the first film have been deliberately coarsened, with burning ghouls reaching out of flames for Sydney (an adequate Jessica Alba - Sin City), and even when the scares are repeated almost exactly shot for shot and edit for edit, such as her encounter in a lift with a floating apparition, or the brilliant, pivotal twist when Sydney sees the all-important photograph taken in the hospital, they come across as completely flat, giving the inescapable feeling that Moreau and Palud seemingly have no real feel or aptitude for the material. The new scenes in the script by Sebastian Gutierrez (Snakes On A Plane) such as Sydney imagining a burnt-out Chinese restaurant to be real, before being discovered in the wreckage, are even more illogical than the plot twists of the first. Perhaps the worst alteration is at the fiery climax, which certainly seems far smaller in scale than as delivered by the Pangs, and shifts the emphasis totally, making triumphant and upbeat what was originally sad and tragic, with the events which led to donor's death repeating themselves, in that the heroine is not believed. The directors have some interesting names in the cast, including Alessandro Nivolla (Goal!), as the ocular specialist who seems unfamiliar with such scientific equipment as a comb and razor, indie favourite Parker Posey (Sleep With Me / Clockwatchers), Rede Serbedzija (M:I - 2) and Rachel Ticotin (Total Recall), and performances are pretty good, considering how much time is given over to the over-done CGI, but as with so many US remakes of Asian originals, The Eye doesn't cry out to be seen.