Cast
-
Eddie Redmayne
-
-
-
Jeremy Strong
-
Frank Langella
-
-
John Carroll Lynch
-
Mark Rylance
-
J.C. MacKenzie
-
Yahya Abdul-Mateen II
-
Alex Sharp
-
Kelvin Harrison Jr.
-
Max Adler
-
Ben Shenkman
-
Alice Kremelberg
-
Wayne Duvall
-
Noah Robbins
Synopsis
August 1968.
A bunch of people prepare to protest at the Democratic National Convention in Chicago. Anti-Vietnam War demonstrators Tom Hayden and Rennie Davis want to stage peaceful protests, emphasising the escalating deaths of young soldiers in the Vietnam War. Yippies Abbie Hoffman and Jerry Rubin are preparing to have a more direct, chaotic form of protest, believing the system has to be disrupted and thrown into chaos before real change can occur. Pacifist activist David Dellinger assures his wife and family that nothing is going to happen and he'll be back soon, while Black Panther party co-founder Bobby Seale gives his friends the same assurance.
September 24th 1969.
All six, along with John Froines and Lee Weiner, have been arrested and charged with attempting to incite a riot outside the Convention Centre as Attorney General John N. Mitchell, new in the post having been appointed by the the newly-elected President Richard Nixon, appoints Tom Foran and Richard Schultz as the prosecutors, insisting the eight defendants are violent rioters and telling the two lawyers that this could be career-defining for both of them, how much Nixon sees the case as a benchmark for his Presidential term and how much he wants the protestors found guilty, while the defendants are represented by civil rights attorneys William Kunstler and Leonard Weinglass, except Bobby Seale, who has his own representation.
The trial commences, and from the beginning Judge Julius Jennings Hoffman, no relation to Abbie Hoffman, shows a distinct and obvious bias towards the prosecution counsels. When Bobby Seale's attorney doesn't arrive he is given legal assistance by Fred Hampton, the chairman of the Illinois chapter of the Black Panther Party.
Abbie Hoffman openly provokes and riles the court and Judge Hoffman. Hearing unsubstantiated rumours of the Black Panther Party trying to influence the jury, Judge Hoffman begins to dismiss jurors arbitrarily, claiming they are sympathetic to the defendants and their causes, and when the accused and their lawyers raise objections to how the Judge is handling the case he charges them with multiple counts of contempt of court and extensive jail terms.
Statements are heard from a number of undercover police officers. Seeing Rennie Davis being tailed by two Police in an unmarked car, Hayden tried to delay them by letting the air out of their tyres, but was caught and later charged. Hearing Hayden was being held in jail, Abbie Hoffman quickly organised a protest to march on the Police station where Hayden was being held, but seeing the blockade erected around the building, tried to return to Lincoln Park, only to find that the Police had taken over most of the area and scuffles broke out, leading to what the officers insist was a riot as the protestors reclaimed the park. Kunstler emphasises that none of the defendants incited any violence, which was instigated by the Chicago Police.
News breaks that Fred Hampton, Seale's advisor, has been killed by the Chicago Police on a raid on an apartment where several Black Panthers were staying, Hampton and another man, Mark Clark, being shot dead and the four other occupants were being seriously wounded, amid complaints that Hampton was deliberately targeted and executed.
Seale insists on having his constitutional rights upheld, but the Judge orders him taken to another room, where the cops beat him, gag him and tie him to a chair, on which he is returned to the courtroom, showing obvious signs of being beaten up.
After several days of seeing Seale only allowed into the court bound and gagged, Richard Schultz, alarmed at the turn the trial has taken, suggests to the Judge that Seale's case should be declared a mistrial, and to his surprise Hoffman agrees but sentences him to four years in jail for contempt of court, Seale being taken away and leaving seven defendants.
Kunstler and Weinglass call Ramsey Clark, Attorney General during the riots, to the stand but Judge Hoffman refuses to let the jury hear his testimony, even though Clark testifies that it was the the Chicago police which were behind the violence, determined to break up any gatherings and have protesters arrested. When Dellinger protests and is restrained by the court officials he punches a bailiff and is violently subdued by the court officers.
As the case grinds on, Kunstler goes to the defendants, saying he has been given a tape which seems to have very incriminating material involving Tom Hayden…
Production
- Director
- Aaron Sorkin
- Producer
- Marc Platt, Matt Jackson, Stuart M. Besser and Tyler Thompson
- Art Director
- Nick Francone (supervisor)
- Editor
- Adam Baumgarten
- Music
- Daniel Pemberton
- Screenplay
- Aaron Sorkin
- Director of Photography
- Phedon Papamichael
Review
One can understand how a film including such British talent as Oscar-winners Eddie Redmayne and Mark Rylance, and Sacha Baron Cohen (Borat / Brüno), in a remarkably strong cast which also features Joseph Gordon-Levitt (The Dark Knight Rises / Looper), Jeremy Strong (The Big Short / The Gentleman), Frank Langella (who ironically also played Richard Nixon in Frost/Nixon, he being behind the decision to prosecute the Chicago defendants whereas his predecessor, Lyndon B. Johnson, declined), Michael Keaton (the Batman who took on Spider-Man) and John Carroll Lynch (Fargo / Zodiac), would be a draw to a certain section of the UK audience, but the film also demands a reasonable knowledge of the political situation at the time, the contentious 1968 Democratic National Convention in Chicago, and real-life characters such as Abbie Hoffman, Allan Ginsberg, Jerry Rubin and Bobby Seale, not to mention the fact that the actual trial of the anti-war protesters for conspiring to cause riots at the Convention degenerated into what many observers described as an embarrassing farce, Rubin and Hoffman seeing it as a chance to grandstand and make anti-war speeches, and with the hardline Judge Julius Hoffman (Langella), already a largely genuinely despised character among the judiciary and legal professions, almost dispensing with the rule of law within his courthouse, arbitrarily firing jurors, denying defence motions, dishing out serious contempt charges as if they were parking tickets and refusing to allow the defence to summon vital witnesses in what was one of the most genuinely shocking judicial debacles this side of the Stalinist show trials.
To show just how extraordinarily deranged this trial was, what seems to be a plot invention too far, the beating and gagging of Bobby Seale, having him dragged into court tied to a chair, is one of the most shaming images in US justice, and having to be captured by court artists since cameras were barred from the courtroom.
Sorkin takes a limited amount of dramatic licence, rearranging some timelines and simplifying some of the murkier court machinations, but also maintains a surprisingly even-handed approach to the characters, prosecutors Foran (J.C. MacKenzie) and Schultz (Gordon-Levitt), appointed by the new Nixon administration, being as appalled by the events in the courtroom as defence lawyers Kunstler (Rylance) and Weinglass (Ben Shenkman), and former Attorney General Ramsey Clark (an impressive Keaton), sums up, in only two scenes, just how derailed, corrupt and basically entirely illegal this prosecution and the court case actually is and what it could mean for the future. No such equanimity is shown to Judge Hoffman, seen to be entirely biased from the very beginning and ready to do anything to put the defendants behind bars for as long as possible, by means legal or otherwise, in a memorable turn from the always watchable Langella, and Hoffman's barely believable behaviour throughout the proceedings played a major part in the eventual appeals.
Although American reviewers largely connected with the film, those outside the US were not so impressed, The Guardian saying Sorkin '… can also become fantastically ponderous, bloated with finger-waggingly self-important liberal patriotism. Sadly, that is the tone with this exasperatingly dull, dramatically inert and faintly misjudged re-creation of the 'Chicago Seven' trial in the US, which Sorkin has written and directed'.
The events of the trial have been presented on screen before, most notably in the actual footage being captured in Haskell Wexler's Medium Cool ('69), starring Robert Forster, actually shot during the Democratic Convention, Wexler and his crew finding themselves in the middle of the confrontations, and as fiction in several adaptations, including the 1987 HBO production Conspiracy: The Trial Of The Chicago Eight, written and directed by Jeremy Paul Kagan and starring Brian Benben as Tom Hayden and Michael Lembeck as Abbie Hoffman, with the actual defence attorneys Kunstler and Weinglass acting as consultants, the production eventually winning the 1988 CableACE Award for Best Dramatic Special. Fourteen years later in 2011, writer / director Pinchas Perry produced The Chicago 8, with the always impressive Philip Baker Hall as a frighteningly vindictive and ruthless Judge Hoffman.