Film details

My Sister's Keeper  2009

Cast

Synopsis

Anna Fitzgerald is the eleven-year-old sister of Kate, who is older than her, but Kate has leukaemia, and Anna was born with the direct intention of providing blood transfusions for her sister. Her parents, Sara and Brian, are also keen that Anna provide a kidney for transplant when Kate's own kidneys show signs of failing. Realising that she is little more than a donor for her sister rather then a person in her own right, and that Kate's illness dominates everything in the family, to the point of her brother Jesse's severe dyslexia being barely dealt with, she goes to controversial and high profile lawyer Campbell Alexander, wanting him to take her case for wanting 'medical emancipation' from her parents, and not allowing them to use her purely for transfusions to keep Kate alive. Anna's announcement that she is bringing her parents to court throws Brian and Sara into shock, and they try to persuade Anna to drop the case, insisting that Kate's condition is worsening rapidly. Kate has in the meanwhile become close to Taylor Ambrose, a young boy in a similar condition as herself, having met in the hospital where she was for treatment, and she feels happy for the first time in years, but also realises how damaging to her family her condition is, forcing her parents and Anna apart. The case finally reaches the courtroom, but Kate's condition has deteriorated yet further. As the case proceeds they are interrupted by a furious outburst from Jesse, who tells the judge and everybody in the room that Kate has told him that she wants to die, and that Anna's court case is essentially a delaying tactic in order to help her achieve her wish without having the kidney transplant which would extend her life, if only by a few months. Sara is crushed by this revelation, and cannot cope with the realisation that, although she only wanted the best for her daughter, she was only prolonging her agony, but Kate knows the sacrifices she has made, and helps her come to terms with the tragically inevitable.

Production

Director
Nick Cassavetes
Producer
Stephen Furst, Scott Goldman, Mark Johnson and Chuck Pacheco
Art Director
Jon Hutman
Editor
Jim Flynn and Alan Helm
Music
Aaron Zigman
Screenplay
Nick Cassavetes and Jeremy Leven, based on the novel by Jodi Picoult
Director of Photography
Caleb Deschanel

Review

The films being directed by Nick Cassavetes are worlds apart from the gritty, often largely improvised dramas made by his late father John, Cassavettes Junior often lurching into sentimentality in films such as She's So Lovely and The Notebook, with even his Denzel Washington thriller John Q being driven by the subplot of a man being unable to pay for the heart transplant his young son needs through being sold an inadequate health insurance policy. My Sister's Keeper very much fits into that template, being based on a bestseller by Jodi Picoult, but crucially altering the plot in the plot in the final stages, changes which may make the film rather more dramatically effective, is still remarkably manipulative, but which has enraged some fans of the book who prefer the original, more dramatically contrived conclusion. The story revolves around Anne Fitzgerald (Abigail Breslin - Little Miss Sunshine) who takes her parents to court wanting 'medical emancipation' from them on the grounds that she is basically being used to keep her other sister Kate (Sofia Vassilieva - TV's Medium) alive, Kate suffering from severe leukaemia, Anne regularly having blood and plasma taken for transference to her sibling. Her parents, Sara and Brian (Cameron Diaz and Jason Patric) need Anne essentially in order to keep their other child alive, and are now wanting her to donate a kidney since Kate's have started to fail, and a very messy and emotionally fraught court case looms. Cassavettes is an effective director of these sorts of things, and to his credit the film doesn't actually become the TV movie slushfest this initially suggests, largely through the performances of Patric and particularly Diaz as the parents, ruthlessly determined that Kate should live at all costs, and largely negligent toward their other children, regarding Anne as little more than an organ bank and also refusing to deal with the problems of their dyslexic son Jesse (Evan Ellingson), whose condition they have largely ignored. Cassavettes also has to be praised for his skill in handling the child performers, with both Breslin and Vassilieva making their screen characters far less twee and sweetly simpering than the print versions, and the film also isn't squeamish about showing the ravages caused by and treatments necessitated by cancer in children. Diaz received some very good reviews for her role, a mother driven to do what many would find utterly unacceptable in order to save her child, but although some plot twists and developments are unexpected, Cassavettes is largely strapped in a 'disease-of-the-week' formula, which makes the ending, although unexpected in some aspects, sadly inescapable. If the director has largely avoided ladling on the syrup, there is still a taste of artificial sweetener here under the drama and decent performances.