Film details

Evening  2007

Film still

Cast

Synopsis

The elderly Ann Lord lies in her deathbed, her pain alleviated by both morphine and the presence of her two daughters, Constance, who is happily married and with daughters of her own, and Nina, who is single but considering finally settling down with her boyfriend. The drugs take Ann into reminiscences of fifty years previously, when she went to Newport, New England, for the high society wedding of her best friend, Lila Wittenborn. Ann, who has ambitions to become a singer, is worried that Lila is marrying the wrong man, who is respectable but dull and studious. Lila is secretly in love with Harris Arden, a young man who is a friend of the family, and when Ann is introduced to him she immediately falls for him also. Lila's brother Buddy is struggling with his conflicted feelings for both Ann, who he has secretly hankered for, and his feelings towards the handsome Arden. Buddy gets drunk at the wedding, revealing his long-held love for Ann. She rejects his overtures and he wanders off drunkenly into the night, eventually to be struck by a hit-and-run driver and dying in the road. Not knowing what has happened, Ann and Harris have a night of secret passion in the estate summer house, only to hear the news of Buddy's death the next morning. They part, never to meet again. Nina hears her mother repeatedly muttering the name of Harris Arden, and in a moment of lucidity says that she should have stayed with him, which alarms both daughters who wonder who this mystery man is, but it is the arrival of someone from the past who finally explains the truth of the story, and the consequences which one has to carry for the rest of their life...

Production

Director
Lajos Koltai
Producer
Jeff Sharp
Art Director
Jordan Jacobs
Editor
Allyson C. Johnson
Music
Jan A.P. Kaczmarek
Screenplay
Susan Minot and Michael Cunningham, based on the novel by Susan Minot
Director of Photography
Gyula Pados

Review

One has to look at the casting and structure of Evening and suspect one is going to see The Hours 2, especially considering that the author of The Hours, Michael Cunningham, is co-writer on the screenplay, taken from the novel by Susan Minot, although Lajos Koltai's film, his second feature, refuses to unleash the emotional punch of The Hours, instead settling for a sedate and extremely sentimental family drama. Running two parallel stories, the plot is essentially the reminiscences of Ann Lord (Vanessa Redgrave) on her deathbed, where her daughters, the married Constance (Natasha Richardson), and the single, unsettled Nina (Toni Collette), hold vigil. Ann calls out for Harris Arden, the only man she ever truly loved, which intrigues the women, who have never heard of him before. As Ann's condition deteriorates she thinks back to her life fifty years previously where, as a young woman (Claire Danes - Terminator 3) she arrives in Newport for the wedding of her closest friend, and where she meets the young Harris Arden (Patrick Wilson), who will change the course of her life, and indirectly that of her daughters also. Considering the overriding theme is that of the bond between mothers and daughters, there's some amusement to be had in seeing actresses with their real-life offspring, Natasha Richardson being the daughter of Vanessa Redgrave, while Mamie Gummer is frighteningly physically similar to her mother, Meryl Streep, but this concentration on the female characters and their inter-relations comes at the expense of the male parts, and both Patrick Wilson as Arden and Hugh Dancy as the unfortunate Buddy are underdeveloped and at times virtually cyphers. Oddly the film bears striking parallels with Christine Comenici's Italian romantic drama Follow Your Heart, in which a grandmother's diaries affect the life of her granddaughter after she realises the parallels in her own life, but Evening has little of the real tear-jerking impact of Comenici's genuinely affecting drama. Fans of the female stars will be delighted at such a tailored showcase for them, but as well intentioned as it is, and sometimes painfully sincere and serious, Evening at times seems to stretch well into the night.