Film details

The Band's Visit  2007

Bilur Ha-tizmoret / La Visite De La Fanfare
Film still

Cast

  • Saleh Bakri
  • Ronit Elkabetz
  • Sasson Gabai
  • Uri Gavriel
  • Imad Jabarin
  • Ahouva Keren
  • Rinat Matatov
  • Rubi Moskovitz
  • Khalifa Natour
  • Hilla Surjon Fischer
  • Eyad Sheedy
  • Tarak Kopty

Synopsis

The members of the Alexandria Ceremonial Police Band, led by the jaded but resourceful Tawfiq, are invited into Israel in the mid-1990s in order to play at the opening of an Arab cultural centre. A mistake in spelling and pronunciation means the band are marooned in the small town of Bietha Tikva instead of Petach Tikva where the cultural centre is. Without money or a way of getting out of the town, the band accept an invitation from Dina, a cafe owner, to spend the night there. Tawfiq realises that Hawid, one of their number, has a reputation with the ladies, so he and Hawid stay in Dina's apartment rather than letting Hawid possibly get himself into trouble, while the other six musicians stay with one of Dina's colleagues, Itzik and his family. Tawfiq feels initially uneasy with Dina's generosity and extrovert nature, but when Dina takes Tawfiq for a walk around the beautiful town under the moonlight he finds himself becoming more understanding towards him. Hawid takes the opportunity to go for a night on the town with Papi, the initially shy cafe assistant. Simon, the band's second in command, finds he has much in common with Itzik. He feels for the man, whose stern and unwelcoming wife is furious at him for inviting the Egyptians into their home and disrupting her birthday. Itzik tells Simon that he too wanted to be a musician, and has gone so far as nearly finishing a symphony, but now realises his ambitions will never be fulfiled. Tawfiq finally opens up to Dina, telling him his greatest secret - that his unyielding and disciplinarian ways led to his only son's suicide. The band realise they have all made both confessions and discoveries this night, but there is still the matter of getting to Petach Tikva.

Production

Director
Eran Kolirin
Producer
Ehud Bleiberg, Koby Gal-Raday, Guy Jacoel, Eylon Ratzkovsky and Yossi Uzrad
Art Director
Eitan Levi
Editor
Arik Lahav Leibovitch
Music
Habib Shehadeh Hanna
Screenplay
Eran Kolirin
Director of Photography
Shai Goldman

Review

A very brave production from Israeli writer and director Eran Kolirin, and one that met with objections while in production, The Band's Visit is a comedy / drama revolving around what should be a relatively unimportant event, the visit of a police band to a foreign country to play at the opening of an arts centre. Of course the situation isn't nearly as simple as that, since the band is Egyptian and the country they are visiting is Israel, where an Arab arts centre is to be opened. For all its' genuine good intentions, the film found itself prevented from spreading it's message of tolerance and goodwill when the American Academy refused it to be the Israeli entry for Best Foreign Language Film in 2008, since more than fifty percent of the dialogue is actually in English rather than Arabic or Hebrew, a plot device the director admitted alleviated the need for the various speakers needing to be translated, and this despite the film winning awards at festival all around the world. Kolirin largely avoids politics, the two countries having theoretically been at peace with each other since the 1979 accord, but there is an acknowledgment of mutual mistrust as, led by the world-weary (and who can blame him) band leader Tawfiq (Sasson Gabai), he knows he is very much leading his musicians into potentially hostile territory, but things get worse as the band soon get lost and have to do the unthinkable and actually ask for assistance. Kolirin's film has been called everything from brave and sympathetic to naive depending on the prejudices of the particular critic involved, but the film's whole plot cleverly revolves over a simple misunderstanding, the town's name being misheard and misunderstood, and by the end both the band and the townspeople know a little more about each other and have made, if not lifelong friends, then real and genuine contact over the divide. The Band's Visit admirably avoids cloying sentimentality by treating the situation as pragmatically as possible, and many of the characters are themselves flawed, Dina (Ronit Elkabetz) harbouring a secret he could never have told anyone in his own town, but he can talk to and unburden himself to a relative stranger. Featuring a terrific performance from the very fine Sasson Gabai, the film is a light fable with real warmth at its' heart. A pity the Academy cannot see beyond its' own petty regulations to acknowledge it.