Film details
P.S. I Love You 2007
Still unavailable
Cast
-
-
-
-
Harry Connick Jr.
-
-
-
Jeffrey Dean Morgan
-
James Marsters
-
Dean Winters
-
Nellie McKay
-
Anne Kent
-
Sherie Rene Scott
Synopsis
Holly Kennedy, living in New York and married to Gerry, a rough-hewn but romantic Irishman, enjoys a lively relationship with him, and is devastated when, shortly after being diagnosed with a brain tumour, Gerry dies. Three weeks after his funeral is Holly's thirtieth birthday, and she is surprised when a cake is delivered, decorated with the phrase 'Happy Birthday, love Gerry'. Also in the box is a dictaphone, and upon it a message from Gerry, recorded before he died. He tells Holly that he has prepared a number of letters for her, to help her get over losing him and to get on with her own life. They will arrive when she needs them, and she should go along with what they advise. The tape ends with him telling her to go out with her friends Denise and Sharon. She does, and meets Daniel, a charming barman with what he claims is a 'syndrome' which means that he always speaks his mind, with little concern for the feelings of others. She leaves her job as a real estate agent, looking for something more fulfiling, and a letter arrives telling her to try karaoke once more, even though her previous attempts were a disaster when she fell off stage and had to be taken to hospital. Another letter arrives stating that Gerry had booked a holiday in Ireland for her, and Denise and Sharon join her. Meeting a musician, William, Holly ends up sleeping with him, and is alarmed when it is revealed that he knew Gerry when he was alive. Holly also uses the trip to go to visit his parents, Rose and Martin. When another letter reminds her of when they met, she remembers being a student in Ireland, and meeting him for the first time while rambling in the countryside. Finally finding a job which makes her happy, designing shoes, her mother Patricia gives her the final letter, also revealing that she worked with Gerry on his plan with the letters and related events. She hesitates over opening it, and it reveals Gerry's final, and most heartfelt piece of advice for the women he loved so much.
Production
- Director
- Richard LaGravenese
- Producer
- Wendy Finerman, Broderick Johnson, Andrew A. Kosove and Molly Smith
- Art Director
- Doug Huszti and Suzy Cullen
- Editor
- David Moritz
- Music
- John Powell
- Screenplay
- Richard LaGravenese and Stephen Rogers, based on the novel by Cecelia Ahern
- Director of Photography
- Terry Stacey
Review
Unashamedly manipulative and sentimental, not to mentioning having a lot of resemblance to the Michael Keaton / Nicole Kidman pic My Life, another wallow in pure drip-filtered sentimentality, the film version of Cecilia Ahern's P.S. I Love You moves the location from Ireland to New York, transforming the central couple into Oscar-winner Hilary Swank and Gerard Butler (300 / The Phantom Of The Opera), playing Holly and Gerry Kennedy, whose seemingly happy marriage is somewhat truncated when Gerry dies, leaving Holly widowed. But he hasn't left her completely bereft, leaving ten letters, with messages to be used at certain points when she needs them and to help her through the pain of what has happened. What threatens to be a saccharine overload is directed with relative levity by Richard LaGravenese, a respected screenwriter with such films as The Fisher King, The Horse Whisperer and The Bridges of Madison Country to his credit, and working again with Swank again after the well intentioned but dull Freedom Writers. As with all rom-coms since Ghost which have dealt with death, Holly is constantly being urged from beyond the grave to get on with her life and find love once more, and sticks to the well-worn conventions, although a trip to Ireland seems more to be a sop to readers of the original novel than a viable plot move, and one can quibble at some of the casting, since Lisa Kudrow (TV's Friends) and Gina Gershon (Bound), playing Holly's friends Denise and Sharon, are supposed to have just turned thirty, an extension of disbelief which may be beyond the patience of some viewers. Equally questionable casting is Butler, a Scottish actor who is obviously having trouble with the accent, given the verbal world tour he goes on in some scenes, and as if to ensure his 'Irishness' he often quotes a string of Irish blarney which comes across as irritatingly corny, and the script at least accepts that at times their marriage wasn't exactly idyllic, inevitable as Butler's Gerry sometimes comes across as boorish and annoyingly childishly. LaGravenese knows how to push the formula buttons, and Swank makes for both a convincingly happy wife and bereft grieving widow, inevitably accepting the advice the letters bring and starting her life over again, this is the sort of thing which should come with a health warning for those who find this sort of manipulative, sticky narrative harmful - i.e. 90% of the male population.