Film details

Dan in Real Life  2007

Film still

Cast

Synopsis

Dan Burns, a journalist in an American small town, writes the weekly agony column, entitled Dan In Real Life, for his local paper. Although giving people advice on their emotional problems he is hampered with issues of his own and is still grieving for the wife who died four years earlier, and tries to compensate by focusing on his three daughters, Jane, Cara and Lilly, trying to protect them from every aspect of the modern world, from fast cars to boyfriends, being particularly firm on keeping Lilly, the youngest, protected from almost everything in the modern world. Taking his daughters to an annual family get-together with his parents, Poppy and Nana, Dan is stunned when, in a local bookshop, he meets the beautiful and friendly Marie, and feels they are attracted to one another. Returning home he is struck to find Marie already there, since she is the girlfriend of his younger brother, Mitch. Determined not to show his true feelings he behaves rudely towards her, trying to project an image of disinterest, which alarms his family when they witness this uncharacteristic behaviour. Thinking he needs a new woman in his life they set him up with Ruthie Draper, a local girl, on a blind date, but despite this going well Dan and Marie find themselves falling for each other. Marie tells Mitch that she wants to split up with him and leaves the house. She and Dan meet later and kiss, unfortunately being discovered by the whole family who have left the house for a walk. Nana and Poppy, not to mention Mitch and Dan's daughters, are shocked at what they see as his betrayal of his brother and his underhandedness. Dan realises that the people he cares about most feel he has lied to them, with Lilly feeling the most hurt of all, and he realises that he has to somehow make it clear to his family that he loves not only them, but also Marie.

Production

Director
Peter Hedges
Producer
Brad Epstein and Jonathan Shestack
Art Director
Mark E. Garner
Editor
Sarah Flack
Music
Sondre Lerche
Screenplay
Pierce Gardner and Peter Hedges
Director of Photography
Lawrence Sher

Review

The title is clumsy, referring to the name of central character Dan Burns' weekly advice column, with Dan essentially being another variation on Steve Carell's trademark loser character, but one has to wonder just how a man who has so many problems in his own life is entrusted with the job of giving advice to others. Directed and co-written by Peter Hedges, the movie is a romantic comedy which although having a couple of darker touches, such as Dan's reluctance to accept the death of his wife, exists in a purely filmic world where coincidences of the most extraordinary kind are introduced in order to propel the plot, and utterly illogical actions from various characters serve the same purpose. Seeming to have survived the fallout from the major flop Evan Almighty, Carell's title character is a forty-something widower who once more, much to his surprise, immediately falls in love after meeting the vibrant Marie (Juliette Binoche - Cache / The English Patient) in a bookshop, after believing he would never fall in love again. The wrinkle is that she is already the girlfriend of his much younger brother Mitch (Dane Cook - Good Luck Chuck / Employee Of The Month). Although the scene could be set for a bittersweet and genuinely affecting tale, Hedges prefers to go completely the other way, fitting the film into a cosy and warm rom-com slot where the locations are impossibly evocative and highly reminiscent of On Golden Pond, there are sage parents, (although creepily named Poppy and Nana), played by veterans John Mahoney and Dianne Weist, oddly non-bratty and understanding daughters and an inevitability that everything will work out fine, and although Mitch is bound to lose Marie to his brother, rest assured that a convenient twist will make sure he finds someone else almost immediately. Even when Dan decides to treat Marie abominably in order to hide his feelings for her, the family are understanding, worrying that he's acting out of character rather than Mitch laying in with the knuckle omelettes. Slick, professional and played expertly, Dan In Real Life is about as far as one can get from real life without being set on another planet, but for those who can take the warm and cuddly strictures of this sort of thing in their stride, there's a certain pleasure to see the formula so expertly executed.