Film details

Closing The Ring  2007

Film still

Cast

Synopsis

1991, and Ethel Ann Roberts, a newly-widowed Michigan resident, alarms her daughter Marie and friend Jack by seeming to be indifferent to the death of her husband Chuck, and not showing the expected remorse, but in private Ethel is drinking heavily, and mourns alone in the house built back in 1941 by Teddy, the one man she truly loved. Teddy Gordon, Chuck Harris and Jack Etty all joined the US Air Force together and Chuck and Jack were at Teddy and Ethel's wedding before they were shipped over to Europe. Knowing the danger of what they were becoming involved with, Teddy asked both his friends that should anything happen to him, would one of them marry Ethel to take care of her. Jack appeared reluctant, although this was actually a lie, but Chuck agreed. Their agreement was to unfortunately become necessary when Teddy's plane, a B-17 bomber, crashed and ploughed into the hills outside Belfast. In the same hills, in 1991, the remains of the plane are unearthed by Michael Quinlan, a middle-aged man who saw the crash as a young boy and who was convinced the wreckage was still buried, being helped by Jimmy Reilly, a young man who discovers a gold ring in the soil. An inscription on the inside reads 'Ethel and Teddy'. Caught up with the IRA and their cross-border raids, Jimmy is forced to flee the country, and travels to Michigan, having managed to track down the original owner of the ring. Once there he finds Ethel is cold and resentful, but changes when he presents her with the ring which was lost decades before. She shows him a false wall in her house, behind which are photographs and souvenirs of Teddy, Chuck and Jack helped her with boarding it up after he was declared dead. Marie discovers that for years her mother actually loved the memory of Teddy rather than Chuck, her father, and feels terribly resentful. Even with the ring, the revelation of the man she truly loved, and the sham marriage she endured for years, Ethel says she wants to see the crash site and returns to Belfast with Jimmy, but Jimmy is still a marked man in a dangerous city, and violence and more senseless death are imminent.

Production

Director
Richard Attenborough
Producer
Jo Gilbert and Richard Attenborough
Art Director
Tom McCullagh
Editor
Lesley Walker
Music
Jeff Danna
Screenplay
Peter Woodward
Director of Photography
Roger Pratt

Review

A project Sir Richard Attenborough has long cherished, having previously been announced for production a couple of times before being delayed, re-scheduled and recast, Closing The Ring eventually proves to be an almost steadfastly old-fashioned romantic drama which has a couple of surprisingly hard edges amid the more slushy elements. Setting the story in two time periods and splitting the action between Belfast and Michigan, the story begins with Ethel (Shirley MacLaine in full Medusa mode) burying her husband, and she doesn't look too upset about it. Marie (Neve Campbell), her daughter, accuses her of being callous, and Ethel's day improves when an old friend Jack (Christopher Plummer) arrives. Meanwhile in Northern Ireland two men, the older Quinlan (the excellent Pete Postlethwaite) and his protegee Jimmy (Martin McCann) are looking on the hillsides of the Black Mountains for where a B-17 bomber crashed during the war, which alarms the local IRA because where they are searching is their unofficial burial ground. The unearthing of the plane brings the two story strands together, but even though one tale is wrapped up, the untidy construction allows for more death, this time at the hands of the IRA killers, into the tale to show the futility of violence and the sad circularity of life. Attenborough is obviously as sincere as ever, and even the shrewish Ethel (played as a younger woman by Mischa Barton of TV's The O.C.) is revealed to be a woman to whom life has delivered some painful blows, and Postlethwaite's Quinlan too is suffering from the rippling effects of the bomber crashing. The problems with Peter Woodward's screenplay is that the juxtaposition of the events and revelations of lost loves and repressed memories are piled incident upon incident, and the viewer has to be deeply involved in order to keep pace with the various admissions and confessions. The director is a skillful filmmaker, and handles the themes of love and loss delicately, but Closing The Ring seems to be a little too melodramatic for its' own good, with the material, despite the twists and turns, not exactly holding any surprises.