Film details

I'm Not There  2007

Film still

Cast

Synopsis

With the Vietnam war still a raw and vivid memory, actor Robbie Clark tries to keep his marriage to Claire, a talented painter, together, not wanting to admit that their relationship is probably doomed. Robbie played protest singer and troubadour Jack Rollins in a bio-pic of the singer back in the mid 60s, when Rollins was at the height of his fame, but remembers that he was a singer who was known to be a chameleon, not only in his music but also in life, Robbie perhaps just being another of his identities. He emerged, aged eleven, as Woody, who claimed despite his age to be well established in the world of radical politics and to have a reputation as a rock n'roll singer. Becoming Jack Rollins, he is known as a protest singer of powerful, relevant songs, and will eventually find God, becoming known as Pastor John a decade later. In 1965 and 66, at the height of his fame and now known as Jude Quinn, he becomes internationally famous, but his press conferences are often a confusing muddle of asides and barely intelligible remarks, caused by both drugs and the strain of becoming so meteorically famous and having a punishing tour and recording schedule. His adoption of the electric guitar over an acoustic at a gig makes front page news. Transmogrifying into Arthur Rimbaud, a poetry-loving aesthete, he again teases the media, claiming that a press conference is in fact a Police interrogation. He is seen in the later years of his life as a recluse simply known as Billy, living in a small town called Riddle, with some saying has died and been replaced by an imposter, and others hearing he has become a evangelical born-again Christian.

Production

Director
Todd Haynes
Producer
Catherine Vachon, James D. Stern, John Sloss, John Wells and John Goldwyn
Art Director
Judy Becker
Editor
Jay Rabinowitz
Music
Bob Dylan
Screenplay
Todd Haynes and Oren Moverman
Director of Photography
Edward Lachman

Review

Somewhere in the middle of the sprawling morass which is Todd Haynes' I'm Not There, amid the various actors playing Bob Dylan, or rather 'Bob Dylan', some sort of essence of the man which changes form and substances as time passes, one realises that much as Dylan has done through the decades, this 'Dylan' changes according to the times which, as he so foretold, were a'changing. From the Greenwich Village coffee shop folkie to the iconic 1966 tour where he produced the electric guitar and caused the famous cry of 'Judas!' from one particularly disgruntled sandal-wearing member of the audience, Dylan has frequently re-invented himself, through various styles of music, shifts in career, flirtations with acting and novel writing (Tarantula), changes in his religious beliefs and now hosting the very well regarded Radio Theme Hour. The first change came with the name, Bob Dylan being snappier than Robert Zimmermann. Haynes, a director who often gives the impression of being like a child who wants to play with everything in the toybox at once, shows these transformations by having each one played by a different actor in a different setting, and gleefully tampering with the details, Cate Blanchett's award-winning portrayal, as 'Jude Quinn' reflecting his most famous Newport Festival / Highway 61 Revisited period in one of the film's black and white portions. What Haynes doesn't deal with is the music, indeed only Christian Bale's 'Jack Rollins' actually sings, and can be seen as a veiled affectionate jibe at the man himself, that the music, for whatever Bob Dylan has become, is purely secondary. Haynes wants to throw everything at the viewer, cram in as much Dylan trivia as he can, slipping lines from the songs into the script, and making sure that broad winks are given to the aficionados to let them know he knows his man. The narrative is tenuous as best, only the vaguest thread connecting each of the six incarnations to the other, and some will just be driven to utter distraction by Haynes' refusal to keep to any conventional structure or progression. One can see the idea Haynes is playing with, since Dylan has made a regular feature of leaving perceived roles behind when they became too immediately identifiably with him, doing much the same with wives and partners, frequently surprising fans and detractors alike, but Haynes' handling of a man who refuses to be labelled can become wearing in its' determination to wrong foot the viewer at every juncture. I'm Not There is a film which will give Dylan obsessives, of whom there are a surprising number, grist for their mills for the next century or so. Those not so captivated by Dylan may truly wonder just what is going on, and just why.