Film details
Defiance 2008
Still unavailable
Cast
-
-
Liev Schrieber
-
-
Tomas Arana
-
Alexa Davalos
-
George MacKay
-
Mark Feuerstein
-
Mark Margolis
-
Jacek Koman
-
Mia Wasikowska
-
Allan Corduner
-
Sam Spruell
Synopsis
1941, and as the invading Nazis enter the province of Byelorussia, the four Bielski brothers, Tuvia, Zus, Aron and Asoel retreat into the forest after their parents are killed by local Nazi collaborators. They are determined not to be captured, and to try to sabotage the Nazis at every opportunity, eventually being joined by other Jews who want to form a resistance movement. As winter gets nearer and food supplies run short, Tuvia takes command of the growing band, securing food supplies and a pistol from a local farmer, Konstanty 'Koscik' Kozlowski, but when he hears that one of their number, Bernicki, is actually a Nazi sympathiser who killed his own parents, Tuvia shoots him dead in front of the gathered others. Naming themselves the Bielski Brigade, they attack German convoys and secure weapons, and as the reputation grows so do their number. After Asoel goes missing after a brush with the Germans, Tuvia finds Koscik hanged by the Nazis, Asoel being found hiding in a cellar along with two women, Bella and her daughter, Cheya. Joining the expanding group, Bella finds herself attracted to Zus, while Cheya and Asoel also become close. After encountering Russian partisans in the forest, led by the determined Viktor Panchenko, there is increased tension between Tuvia and Zus over the leadership of the brigade, which eventually becomes physical, the pair fighting in the middle of the settlement. Beaten and humiliated, Zus and some of his allies leave the Brigade in order to join Panchenko's men. On hearing that Jews in the ghetto of Novogrudok are being shipped to concentration camps, Tuvia manages to penetrate into the ghetto and persuade some of the occupants to escape with him and join their movement, one of them being a young woman, Lilka Ticktin. Winter arrives along with an outbreak of typhus in the settlement, and when Tuvia pleads with Panchenko for medicine he is rejected, forcing some of the Brigade to launch an attack on a Police post where they know medicines and drugs are kept, Zus joining them on the successful sortie. Tuvia falls seriously ill but is nursed back to health by Lilka, becoming lovers in the process. But as the camp and its' population has grown, so has the German's awareness of their actions and their location, and they plan a full-scale attack on the Brigade settlement, backed up with tanks and heavy artillery.
Production
- Director
- Edward Zwick
- Producer
- Edward Zwick, Pieter Jan Brugge
- Art Director
- Don Weil
- Editor
- Steven Rosenbaum
- Music
- James Newton Howard
- Screenplay
- Clayton Frohman and Edward Zwick, based on the book Defiance: The Bielski Partisans by Nechama Tec
- Director of Photography
- Eduardo Serra
Review
Based on one of the most remarkable true stories of the Second World War, Defiance, although having a rather artificial heroic last-gasp ending which rather detracts from the more stoic true elements of the tale, now seems slightly uncomfortable with its' message that after the War the Jews would be victims no longer but de facto aggressors, something the Palestinians know all too well. Another heavily dramatic tale from director Edward Zwick whose films, including Glory, Legends Of The Fall and Blood Diamond, are usually solid and impressive but can be a little humourless, the film has echoes of Glory, which focused on a largely ignored aspect of the American Civil War, here telling the story, based on the book by Nechama Tec, of the three brothers who were involved in one of the most remarkable acts of heroism After the Nazis invaded what is now Belarussia, four Jewish brothers, Tuvia Bielski (Daniel Craig - Casino Royale), Zus (Liev Schrieber - The Omen remake), Asoel (Jamie Bell - Billy Elliott) and Aron (George MacKay - The Thief Lord) escaped and made their way deep into the thick Belarussian forest, eventually being joined by other Jews and potential resistance fighters, attacking the Nazis in cross-country raids on convoys and establishing what essentially became not so much a refuge as a fully-functioning village for similar escapees, giving them shelter and medical care. Indeed when the Germans eventually withdrew in 1944, as the Reich began to crumble, there were over 1200 Jews in the settlement, which also boasted its' own school, clinic, synagogue and even a theatre. Although not really being the emotional epic it obviously is intended to be, and a slightly crimped budget is shown in scenes where the attacks and battles are not actually as well-staged as they should be, Zwick showing how well he can handle such scenes in Glory, It otherwise hits all of Zwick's favourite topics such as bravery, loyalty and honour, and also has a welcome screen return for the very underrated Tomas Arana (Gladiator / L.A. Confidential) as well as Alexa Davalos (The Chronicles Of Riddick / The Mist) as the surprisingly young woman Craig's Tuvia falls in love with. Defiance tells a remarkable tale well, but never quite seizes the emotions in the way one suspects it was designed to do, and the finale. almost coming off as a dramatic rescue in a Saturday morning serial, does the story no favours at all.