Film details

Disney's A Christmas Carol  2009

Disney's A Christmas Carol 3D / A Christmas Carol 3D / A Christmas Carol

Cast

Synopsis

1843, and businessman and miser Ebenezer Scrooge jealously guards every penny and makes no pretence at anything else, proud of his meanness which means he refuses to heat his office on a freezing Christmas Eve, causing his clerk, Bob Cratchit, to shiver with cold as he works. He makes it plain to one and all that he hates Christmas and everything which goes with it. Finally letting Cratchit return to his family, Scrooge returns to his cold, dark house and retires to bed, refusing to indulge in any sort of celebration, but in the night he is terrified by the apparition of his late business partner, Jacob Marley, who also was mean and miserly in life, now damned to spend eternity in chains to symbolise his guilt and bitterness, and seems to want to save his old partner from a similar fate. Over the course of the night Scrooge is visited by three spirits, each there to teach him a valuable lesson. The Ghost of Christmas Past takes him back to his childhood and youth, when he was happy, and shows him how he was kind and happy with his family and friends, before he became cold and heartless, loving money above all others. The Ghost of Christmas Present takes him to see Bob Cratchit and his family preparing for Christmas, happy and determined to have a happy time despite the niggardly sum Scrooge pays him, and although Bob's wife complains, Bob refuses to condemn Scrooge, instead saying he is a good and fair employer. Scrooge sees Bob's son, Tiny Tim, a young crippled boy, who stoically faces his plight with good humour. Taken into the future by the Ghost of Christmas Yet To Come, Scrooge is shown the Cratchits in tears, mourning the death of Tiny Tim, while others in the streets are celebrating the death of another, a despised, hater old miser who was detested by everybody. Taken by the Ghost to the graveyard, he sees the name on the miser's gravestone, and realises it is himself. The Ghost throws him into an open coffin, which Scrooge plunges through into the depths of the Earth, screaming as he does so that he will change and celebrate Christmas and be a better person. He wakes in his own bed, shocked and stunned, but knows what he has to do, racing out of bed to order a huge turkey for the Cratchits, running through the streets to spread joy and happiness, being warm and joyous towards all he meets, going to the house of the surprised Cratchits and promising to make good on all the impositions he has put upon the family over the years and to hike his wages, determined to change his ways forever. Bob Cratchit tells of how Ebenezer Scrooge changed completely, becoming a second father to Tim, and became loved as the merriest and happiest man in the city.

Production

Director
Robert Zemeckis
Producer
Jack Rapke, Steve Starkey and Robert Zemeckis
Art Director
Marc Gabbana and Mike Stassi
Editor
Jeremiah O'Driscoll
Music
Alan Silvestri
Screenplay
Robert Zemeckis, based on the novel by Charles Dickens
Director of Photography
Robert Presley

Review

Yet another version of the timeless Charles Dickens classic, estimated to be at least the twenty-fifth such on both the big screen and TV, trust Robert Zemekis to tamper with the presentation if not the actual story itself, making it in the bizarre motion-capture system which made The Polar Express, and to a lesser extent 2007's Beowulf, so occasionally unnerving. Although Zemekis and his technicians assure all and sundry that the facial expressions have been improved, not making some of the characters, especially the children, so spookily unsettling in certain shots, it still remains for all the often superb visuals that it only takes just one misplaced fabricated facial expression, or oddly unrealistic bodily or limb movement to ruin the artifice completely and remind the audience that what they are watching is animation, despite the presence of such as Jim Carrey (playing eight different roles, all the Ghosts and Scrooge at five different stages of his life) Gary Oldman (playing three, including, oddly, Tiny Tim), Cary Elwes (four) and Robin Wright Penn (two). One has to say that largely all that remains of the actual 'performance' is the voice, since under the layers and layers of rendering, texturing and animation, it could, frankly, be virtually anybody since the images captured in the computers can be manipulated to an infinite degree. Sadly given the fidelity to which Zemekis applies to the story, it is a real shame that it wasn't made in a more conventional manner, perhaps with actual actors on screen, since, despite adding a few extraneous 3D effects for the theatrical and IMAX screenings, the screenplay is certainly one of the more fidelous versions, reminding audiences, after such productions as a musical, Scrooge (1970), a modern-day comedy, Scrooged (1988), and the delightful Muppet Christmas Carol, that the tale is a ghost story, and a scary one too, so much so that despite the PG certificate, this really is unsuitable for the younger ones, the very slow tense build-up to the first meeting with the ghost of Jacob Marley being more fitting for an all-out horror pic, as is Marley having his jaw come off, which really does push the PG rating. The story is a familiar one, how the miserly Scrooge, played by Carrey, vocally at least, with real malicious relish, is shown the error of his way over the night of Christmas Eve by being visited by three ghosts, showing him the past, present and future, but it has been made so often and revived simply because it is a rattling good story and, like so many of Dickens' works, a critique of the times, in which employers ruthlessly exploited their workers, employment law being nonexistent and if you wouldn't work all the hours of daylight for a pittance, there was always somebody else who would, the levels of poverty in Dickens' time being truly shocking and which galvanised him to write such impassioned pieces of work. Zemekis also adds the two frightening monstrous children, Ignorance and Want, which most other versions omit. He obviously respects the story, and obviously a quite huge budget has been expended on this, which has talent to spare on both sides of the nonexistent camera, the motion-capture process not even using such an antiquated piece of technology, which only makes one wish he had made it in the 'traditional' manner, but most audiences will enjoy it, visually distracting though some of the digital glitches are, but this decidedly ghoulish spin on the tale really isn't for the infants.