Film details

Heartbeat Detector  2007

La Question Humane : The Human Question
Film still

Cast

  • Michael Lonsdale
  • Jean-Pierre Kalfon
  • Edith Scob
  • Lou Castel
  • Valerie Doeville
  • Laetitia Spigarelli
  • Delphine Chuillot
  • Nicolas Maury
  • Remy Carpentier
  • Patrick Zocco
  • Erwan Ribard

Synopsis

Simon Kessler is a psychologist, working for the German multinational petrochemical giants SC Farb in their Paris office. Karl Rose, the German head of the company, asks him to confidentially compile a report on Mathias Just, the CEO of the French arm of the company, who has started to exhibit strange and bizarre behaviour, acting unpredictably and being suspected of drinking in the office. Finding that Just once played in a string quartet within the company, he uses this as excuse to see him, playing him a recording of the quartet playing, which causes Just to break down in tears. Going to a rave party that night with colleagues, Kessler acts aggressively, causing his workmates to abandon him. Talking to Lucy, Just's wife, she tells him that her husband is on the verge of suicide, believing himself to be the victim of a plot organised by his superiors in the company. Kessler is summoned to Just's office, and is accused of being Rose's spy. Just explains that he believes Rose wants him ousted because Just has devastating evidence against him, that he was a child of the Nazi Lebensborn plan, an early form of genetic engineering in which only pure Aryan babies were allowed to be born, and that Rose now funds a semi-underground neo-Nazi organisation. Kessler is stunned by this, and realises he has been duped by Rose. Hurt, and disgusted with himself for accepting such an obvious ploy to undermine Just, Kessler refuses to diagnose him as ill or unfit for his post, scuppering Roses plan. Visited by Justs secretary, Kessler is confused and alarmed to hear that during the war Justs father collaborated with the SS, and later hears that Just has attempted suicide, and is now confined to a clinic. Kessler visits him, and is given evidence of Justs fathers culpability in the form of a package of anonymous letters which seem to corroborate the accusations of collaboration. When Kessler also starts to receive anonymous letters accusing Just's father of his wartime deeds, he manages to track them back to Arie Neumann, a former SC Farb employee. Kessler finds himself realising that nothing he knows is perhaps entirely true, and that events are coloured by those who recount them, but the pasts of both Rose and Just are tangled and tainted, and there is little he can do.

Production

Director
Nicolas Klotz
Producer
Sophie Dulac and Michel Zana
Art Director
Antoine Platteau
Editor
Rose-Marie Lausson
Music
Syd Matters
Screenplay
Elisabeth Perceval, based on an original story by Francois Emmanuel
Director of Photography
Josee Deshaies

Review

The third film made by the collaboration of director Nicolas Klotz and screenwriter Elisabeth Perceval, after 2001s Parla and 2004's La Blessure, the pair turn to the novel La Question Humaine by Francois Emmanuel for their source material, turning the dense and complex novel into an equally challenging piece of drama, featuring an excellent cast in a story which puts forward such questions as the culpability of the past having an effect on the present, and how much one is beholden to employers, or others, who clearly have another agenda for which they are using you. Simon Kessler (Mathieu Amalric - A Christmas Tale / Quantum Of Solace) finds himself in a dilemma when given an assignment by his boss, Karl Rose (French veteran Jean-Pierre Kalfon - The Valley / Finally Sunday), essentially to spy on another executive, Mathias Just (the equally venerable Michel Lonsdale - Enigma / Ronin), but discovers that each of the people he is involved with have secrets, some more serious than others, and that culpability exists on many levels, causing him to eventually question his own motives in doing what he does. Some of the parallels between Nazi ideology and the practises of modern business are rather tortuous, such as one character interlinking genuine Nazi documents with excerpts from a genuine business training manual, and the naming of the corporation as SG Farb is an obvious and oddly tasteless correlation with the genuine IG Farben, the chemical company employed by the Nazis to produce the Zyklon-B gas which killed so many in the death camps. Klotz gets terrific performances from his cast, with Amalric showing the remarkable range which has brought him to roles as varied as a sufferer from "locked-in syndrome" in The Diving Bell And The Butterfly to a memorably cold Bond villain, while Kalfon is suitably chilling as Rose and Lonsdale a poignant but tortured victim as Just. Small but important roles also come from veterans Edith Scob (Eyes Without A Face) and Lou Castel (A Bullet For The General / The American Friend). Some of the subtleties in the interpretation of certain phrases, which have a bearing on how the past is here viewed, may be lost in the subtitles, and the new English title is perplexing, but the performances are impressive, and add gravity to an already complex and involving character study.