Film details
A Secret 2007
Un secret
Still unavailable
Cast
-
-
Patrick Bruel
-
-
Julie Depardieu
-
-
Nathalie Boutefeu
-
Yves Verhoven
-
Yves Jacques
-
Sam Garbarski
-
Sam Garbarski
-
Orlando Nicoletti
-
Robert Plagnol
Synopsis
Set in the near present of 1985, François, a psychologist receives a call from his mother. His elderly father has gone missing and she is worried. This event sets François to thinking about his parents past and unearths the shocking truth about his parents' lives during the Nazi occupation. During his childhood shy sickly François, had an almost idyllic view of his parents. He always felt inadequate around his athletic parents: his mother Tania, the beautiful champion swimmer, and his father Maxime, a muscular gymnast. Aware of his parents disappointment, especially his father's resentment of his lack of physical prowess, he creates an imaginary brother who's everything he's not -- fearless and athletic. Louise their next-door neighbour drops hints - during conversations when she soothes him in Yiddish and assures him that her massages and vitamins will build him up - that his family aren't quite what they seem. His father has always been at pains to try and erase his Jewish background and the events of WWII. François pulls the long-hidden truth out of Louise. He once had a half-brother, and his parents came together amid terrible tragedy and guilt. His father was engaged to another woman, Hannah, and at their wedding he meets Tania, to whom he is attracted and the attraction is reciprocated. Tania is already married to Robert, Hannah's brother. Nonetheless, life goes on more or less as planned and Maxime and Hannah have a child called Simon. Then the Nazis invade France. They seek refuge outside the occupied zone with Maxime leading the way closely followed by Hannah, Simon and Louise and a few weeks later Tania minus her husband Robert who has been captured and killed. Hannah, unable to come to terms with her husbands lack of acknowledgment of his Jewish heritage and suspected love affair, gives herself away to Nazi soldiers resulting in her and Simon's arrest and deportation. In the wake of their disappearance Maxime and Tania begin an affair and François is conceived. It is not until 1985 that Tania and Maxime learn of Hannah and Simon's fate when François informs them that they died in Auschwitz.
Production
- Director
- Claude Miller
- Producer
- Yves Marmion
- Editor
- Veronique Lange
- Music
- Zbigniew Preisner
- Screenplay
- Claude Miller, based on the novel by Philippe Grimbert
- Director of Photography
- Gérard de Battista
Review
'A Secret' is based on Philippe Grimbert's fact-inspired novel, "Un secret". Director Claude Miller (The Accompanist) focuses on a close knit Jewish family torn asunder during WWII. He manages to make his point about the cruelties of institutionalised genocide without the use of heart wrenching images of cattle trucks or concentration camps. The film opens in 1985 and an adult François (Mathieu Amalric), a psychologist, receives a call from his mother. His elderly father has gone missing and she is worried. This event sets François to thinking about his parents past and unearths the shocking truth about his parents' lives during the Nazi occupation. Miller has broken with tradition and has filmed the near present in monochrome while using resplendent colour for the war years. He also uses low camera angles to give the audience a chance to view the world from François perspective. Miller also cleverly limits the amount of documentary footage of WWII, just enough to narrate the flashback sequences. He focuses on the intricacies of relationships and the consequences to be faced during wartime. Starting with the attraction between Maxime (Patrick Bruel) and married Tania (Cecile de France) on his wedding day to Hannah (Ludivine Sagnier). Nonetheless, life goes on more or less as planned and Maxime and Hannah have a child called Simon (Orlando Nicoletti). How the combination of Maxime turning his back on his Jewish background and Hannah's belief that he is having an affair with Tania, leads to Hannah's effective suicide when she gives herself and her son's whereabouts away resulting in their arrest by the Nazis. How in the wake of their disappearance Maxime and Tania begin an affair and François is conceived. In 1955 shy sickly François (Valentin Vigourt), always feels inadequate around his athletic parents, Tania (Cecile de France) and Maxime (Patrick Bruel). Aware of his father's resentment of his lack of physical prowess he creates an imaginary brother who's everything he's not -- fearless and athletic. His neighbour, Louise (Julie Depardieu), tells Francois the long-hidden truth of Maxime's first wife and son. 'A Secret' is a tragic story of human dimensions rather than industrial scale and all the more powerful for that.