Film details

Charlie Bartlett  2007

Still unavailable

Cast

  • Robert Downey Jr
  • Hope Davis
  • Kat Dennings
  • Tyler Hilton
  • Mark Rendell
  • Dylan Taylor
  • Megan Park
  • Jake Epstein
  • Jonathan Malen
  • Derek McGrath
  • Stephen Young

Synopsis

Charlie Bartlett, a pupil at an exclusive private school, is expelled after being discovered selling fake IDs, causing his mother, wealthy socialite Marilyn, who has largely raised him on her own, to send him to a local state school to finish his last few terms, an idea which shocks the manipulative Charlie, whose quick-thinking and eye for the main chance made his years in such an inward-looking establishment very profitable. He soon finds that he does not fit in at his new school, and is repeatedly beaten up by Murphy Bivens, the local bully. Realising her son is becoming clinically depressed, Marilyn sends him to her psychiatrist, who puts him on strong anti-depressants, but Charlie soon realises there is a market in these powerful mood-altering narcotics. Managing to have his doses increased, he sets himself up as an unofficial school psychiatrist in the boy's bathroom, employing Murphy as bodyguard and enforcer, and doles out both spurious advice and the requisite psychotropic drugs, for the appropriate fee. Principle Nathan Gardner, a jaded and embittered alcoholic, soon discovers what Charlie is doing, as does Gardener's emo daughter, Susan, who soon starts dating him. Becoming more and more involved with the workings of the school and the students, he becomes involved in their campaign to have what they see as the intrusive CCTV system taken out of the common room, but Charlie is suspended when one of his 'patients', Kip Crombwell, takes an overdose of the pills Charlie has 'prescribed'. He manages to use his powers of persuasion to have Gardner stage a play which Kip wrote, saying it will be good for his recovery. When the students try to force a showdown over the CCTV, the situation escalates until both Charlie and Gardner are literally at each other's throats, resulting in both of them being suspended. The school prepares to present Kip's play, in which Susan has the female lead, and Charlie goes to Gardner's house, hoping to persuade him to attend, but finds him completely drunk and, worse, armed, waving a pistol around, which Charlie takes to be a direct threat against himself instead of the drunken Gardner's idea of a joke, ending up falling into the swimming pool, having knocked himself unconscious in his efforts to get away. Gardner saves his life, and when they have both recovered they agree to go to the school to see Susan's performance. The pair are still on edge, for a number of reasons, but is this perhaps the first steps back on the road to recovery for the both of them, or just another crazy interlude in their self-destructive lives.....

Production

Director
Jon Poll
Producer
David Permut, Barron Kidd, Jay Roach and Sidney Kimmel
Art Director
Joshu DeCartier
Editor
Alan Baumgarten
Music
Christophe Beck
Screenplay
Gustin Nash
Director of Photography
Paul Sarossy

Review

The first significant feature directed by editor and producer Jon Poll, Charlie Bartlett comes from a very distinct sub-genre of American indie cinema, in which a rebellious individual, usual in high school or college, takes on the system, discovering loopholes or ways he can exploit the establishment, usually coming up against the Dean or Principle and eventually conquering, or at least getting out with some sort of honour or the Dean's daughter, a plot concoction which has been used in such surprisingly aberrant studio pictures as Ferris Bueller's Day Off to Wes Anderson's Rushmore. The title character is played by Anton Yelchin (the Star Trek remake / Terminator Salvation) as an exuberant Duracell bunny of a shyster / entrepreneur, who quickly sees the potential in offering a psychiatry service to the pupils of the state school to which he has been transferred, the exclusive college not particularly appreciating him turning out quality fake IDs using school equipment, and there are some nice touches in the script by Gustin Nash, his first produced piece of work, in that it is the first solution to which his harassed constantly in-therapy mother (Hope Davis - The Matador / Genova) turns when Charlie is expelled, there being nothing that cannot be cured by the right drugs and sedatives. Surprisingly conventional, in that there is really nothing here which the late John Hughes hadn't already exploited, a little more acutely, in films such as The Breakfast Club, Yelchin is alternately engaging and infuriating, rarely being 'off', which gives the audience the terrible fear that he could grow up to be Robin Williams, but the film is very much redeemed and given a welcome shift of direction, by the presence of the pre-Iron Man Robert Downey Jr as the Principle, Nathan Gardner, whose alcohol abuse is given additional weight by the casting of Downey Jr, who brings a lot of weary believability to the character, he being a good man brought down by the prison of the responsibilities of the job, and finding temporary solace in the bottle. Interestingly in the same year Downey played the character of reporter Paul Avery in David Fincher's Zodiac, a very different film but similar characters, both men, decent and dedicated in their fields, being driven to drink by what they see as failure. Downey balances Yelchin, whose character it should be remembered is basically selling dangerous drugs to vulnerable school pupils, and the overdose of one of his customers only becomes another way of building up to the finale, which offers opportunities to have fun at the expense of pretentious high school drama productions, but which are largely missed by director Poll. Charlie is largely tolerated by all he meets, even if some of his behaviour, shameless though it often is, often becomes more threatening, and also to himself, than actually funny, and Charlie Bartlett seems to be uncertain as to which direction to take, whether to go with Charlie's all-out manic physicality or Gardner's creeping melancholy, eventually settling for a slightly unsatisfying too-pat wrap-up, but the eventual double-act of Downey and Yelchin make this watchable and entertaining, even if it becomes clear by the end that debutante Nash has really written himself into a corner.