Film details

I've Loved You So Long  2008

Il Y A Longtemps Que Je T'Aime
Film still

Cast

  • Serge Hazanavicius
  • Laurent Grevill
  • Frederic Pierrot
  • Claire Johnston
  • Catherine Hosmalin
  • Jean-Claude Arnaud
  • Olivier Cruveiller
  • Lise Segur
  • Mouss Zouheyri
  • Souad Mouchrik

Synopsis

Having spent fifteen years in prison, Juliette, a former doctor, is released to live in the French town of Nancy with Lea, her younger sister, Juliette having been imprisoned for the murder of her six-year-old son. Lea manages to cope with her own career as a literature professor and look after her family, but her husband Luc is uncomfortable about Juliette staying with them, since they have two adopted daughters. Having originally been told by her parents that Juliette had actually died, only eventually being told the truth by Lea, Luc is surprised that his wife is so eager to see her sister again. He realises that there is a very strong bond between them, and that Lea actually idolises and looks up to her older sibling, despite her crimes. When Juliette finally arrives she is quiet and furtive, although Lea is keen for her to talk about her experiences over her jail term. Luc is amazed at what he sees as Lea's unconditional love towards Juliette, and slowly Juliette starts to tell the real story of what happened fifteen years previously, and which she did not tell in her court statement. She reveals what no one else knew, that her son had been diagnosed with an incurable disease, and that she saw killing him as the only way to stop what would be a short life filled with pain and suffering. With Lea's encouragement, and the help of Captain Faure, her probation officer, and a dedicated social worker, she slowly starts to forgive herself for what she did, realising that she has paid the price for her actions. Liked by Lea's daughters and feeling she once again has a place in society once more, as well as finding herself being romanced by Michel, a co-worker of Lea, Juliette starts to put the painful past behind her.

Production

Director
Philippe Claudel
Producer
Yves Marmion
Art Director
Emmanuelle Cuillery
Editor
Virginie Bruant
Music
Jean-Louis Aubert
Screenplay
Philippe Claudel
Director of Photography
Jérôme Alméras

Review

Very much a showcase for two very different performers, Kristen Scott-Thomas (The Horse Whisperer / Easy Virtue) and Elsa Zylberstein (Three Blind Mice / Metroland), I've Loved You So Long, the directorial debut of writer Philippe Claudel is actually encapsulated by the title, and is essentially the story of one sister's devotion to her older sibling, just released from prison after fifteen years. Her crime was murder, the victim being her six-year-old son, and yet Juliette (Scott-Thomas), is still idolised by her younger sister, Lea (Zylberstein), to the point of having her stay with her, her husband Luc (Serge Hazanavicius) and their two adopted daughters, when she is released. At points the audience is put into the same position as Luc, wondering just how and why Lea can accept her sister back into the family fold so eagerly, but in trying to discover the truth about the killing, which Juliette has never denied, Lea is also trying to find peace for herself, accepting her sister and her past deeds rather then rejecting her. The central performances nearly overpower everything else in the film, Scott-Thomas looking haggard and haunted as Juliette, and certainly not as glamourous on screen than as in most of her other roles, while Zylberstein's Lea is equally vulnerable, but just not willing to show any sign of weakness. Claudel has a habit of underlining some of the film's intentions a little too obviously, but also has some subtle touches, such as showing Juliette being far more releaxed in solo pursuits such as piano playing or reading than having to deal with others, and when the final revelations are made it seems cathartic for all involved, even though it reveals a major plot loophole, although the director cannot resist an overly happy and optimistic ending which even includes an unlikely romantic interest for Juliette. Fine performances from all the main characters hide the deficiencies in the script, and the ending is a little too neat, considering the gravity of what has gone before, but overall effect is impressive, and lasting.