Film details

The Soloist  2009

Cast

Synopsis

Steve Lopez, a columnist for The Los Angeles Times, is facing a difficult time, trying to recover from his messy and painful divorce, recuperating from a motorbike accident, and worried that he may be involved in the wave of redundancies which are being implemented at the paper. Walking from the office he encounters a homeless man, playing a broken violin, picking out tunes on the two unbroken strings. The man is jabbering and twitching, but is obviously both intelligent and musically gifted, and Steve starts to wonder how someone like him could end up obviously derelict and homeless. They talk, Steve finding the man's name is Nathaniel Ayres, and he claims to have studied the cello at the prestigious Juilliard School in New York City. Lopez investigates his claims about attending the famous school of drama and music, and verifying them, starts to think that Ayres could be a good subject for a human interest column. Tracking him down he starts to try to find out more about him, even though it is obviously that the musician has mental problems, and Lopez writes a series of articles about him. There is an immediate response to the articles, many readers offering money and help, and one sending in the gift of a cello, which Lopez dutiful passes on to Ayres, on the condition he keeps it where Lopez has arranged for it to be stored and to stop it being stolen, Ayres telling him he has been mugged and assaulted over fourteen times. He uses it to play Beethoven as he was taught years earlier, and tells Lopez that it was always difficult to concentrate on the music where there were so many voices fighting for supremacy in one's head, Lopez discovering that his mental illness was already well established when he was a child. Determined to help him, Lopez tries to get him on anti-psychotic medication and also to have him move into the apartment Lopez has managed to arrange through a local community centre, but Ayres seems to refuses all offers of aid, obviously plagued by the voices in his head and an unquiet mind. Realising that music seems to be more important then anything else in his world, Lopez manages to get him into a rehearsal of the Los Angeles Philharmonic Orchestra, which will allow him to play in front of an audience, although he concedes it is not a regular paying audience, but Ayres starts to panic as the appointed date gets closer, and Steve Lopez starts to realise that, for all his good intentions, his struggles may have been all for nothing.

Production

Director
Joe Wright
Producer
Gary Foster and Russ Krasnoff
Art Director
Suzan Wexler
Editor
Paul Tothill
Music
Dario Marianelli
Screenplay
Susannah Grant, based on the book The Soloist: A Lost Dream, An Unlikely Friendship And The Redemptive Power Of Music by Steve Lopez
Director of Photography
Seamus McGarvey

Review

It's almost a rule of thumb that anybody involved with classical music in the movies is going to have some misfortune become them, evidence the unfortunate happenings in the likes of The Piano, Shine, The Piano Teacher, The Page Turner, The Pianist and of course The Phantom Of The Opera. The Soloist, adapted, liberally one has to say, from Steve Lopez's book about his dealings with disturbed street musician Nathaniel Ayres initially seems to be a typically slushy piece of Hollywood syrup dealing with one man's almost saintly efforts to help a homeless musician, who of course plays like a concert virtuoso, and in the course of the story the reporter is also helping himself, showing what a good guy he really is. What in other hands could be excruciatingly sentimental is given some far more interesting aspects under the directorial hand of Joe Wright (Atonement), as well as giving Robert Downey Jr a chance to reaffirm his return to the Hollywood A-list after Iron Man, and also for Jamie Foxx to return to playing a gifted musical genius, as he did in the Oscar-winning Ray. Dealing with a true story, Downey plays Steve Lopez, a journalist for the Los Angeles Times who meets and becomes friendly with Nathaniel Ayers (Foxx), a homeless and schizophrenic musical genius. Ayers is lucid and affable when on his medication, obviously supremely talented, and harbours an ambition to play at the Walt Disney Concert Hall (and only in LA would such a place exist). Lopez decides to help him all he can in trying to fulfil this aim, but also comes to find that a severe streak of self-destruction runs through Ayres, he often being unable to distinguish between those who want to help him and those who only wish him harm. Whereas the story should essentially focus on Ayres and his inner turmoil, and when he says it is hard to concentrate on the music with so many other voices in your head it is a very effective and slightly chilling comment, Wright's handling of the script by Susannah Grant also focuses on Lopez and his plight, as there are large numbers of layoffs at his paper, and in the background we see a gradually depleted newsroom, and in one scene one can see an employee literally clearing his desk and being escorted out of the building as Lopez argues his case for writing about Ayres, adding a cynical edge by him realising that perhaps it is inspirational and upbeat human interest stories rather than actual news which may keep him on the paper. Comparisons to the Oscar-winning Shine, the tale of severly disturbed pianist David Helfgott, are inevitable, but Wright gives the story some necessary grit, even if some of the details, such as Lopez in the film being divorced when in actuality he was, and apparently still is, happily married, have obviously been changed in the name of dramatic licence. Interestingly Foxx has now returned to films after the very indifferent r'n'b career he embarked on after winning the Oscar, and in a film so strangely similar to Ray as well, also playing a character which would seem to tick all the boxes for Oscar nomination, regrettably slipping at times into Forrest Gump on the fiddle. One can imagine just how sticky and glutinous this could have been in the hands of a more conventional, or perhaps more mainstream American director, but Wright handles it very well, and also settles on a realistic, relatively downbeat ending, which gives the tale all the more strength.