Film details

Elegy  2007

Film still

Cast

Synopsis

New York college professor David Kepesh is struggling to cope with his advancing age, which he realises has not stopped his admiring eye for young women. He becomes captivated with one of his new intake of students, Cuban ex-pat Consuela Castillo, many years his junior. At an end-of-term party he makes his advances and is surprised to find them reciprocated, although his close friend George O'Hearn, a dissipated, womanising poet, advises him to just keep the relationship superficial, and not to get deeply involved with her for both their sakes. It is a state of emotional detachment David is used to, having a long-distance lover called Carolyn, who occasionally arrives for purely physical weekends. He also has a difficult relationship with his son, Kenny, the child of a long abandoned and regretted marriage. David begins a relationship with Consuela but finds himself out of his depth, mesmerised by her beauty and regarding her as some sort of exquisite creation rather than a real woman. He tries to break up with her but cannot, mesmerised by her but also unwilling to make any sort of long-term commitment. When Carolyn discovers he is also seeing another woman she is furious, and decides to finish with him. Invited to a graduation party being thrown by her family, David lets Consuela down by not attending through a mixture of embarrassment and not wanting to show how deeply he feels for her, and this enrages her, causing her to end their relationship. He is thrown into despair, but his friend George, wanting to take his mind off the situation, asks him to introduce him on stage when he makes a speaking appearance in the next few day. David accepts, glad of the distraction, but George is struck down by a stroke and dies. Time passes, with David still feeling the loss of his best friend and the most beautiful woman he has ever known, knowing that neither can be replaced, but then comes a very unexpected, and upsetting, phone call.

Production

Director
Isabel Coixet
Producer
Andre Lamal, Gary Lucchesi and Tom Rosenberg
Art Director
Helen Jarvis
Editor
Ann E. Duddleston
Music
Various
Screenplay
Nicholas Meyer, based on the novel The Dying Animal by Philip Roth
Director of Photography
Jean-Claude Larrieu

Review

Suddenly finding his works in favour again, both with critics and filmmakers, another Philip Roth novel comes to the screen, and as with much of his later work it deals with a recurring theme, the effect of an unexpected new relationship on the life of an older man as he realises that his life is definitely in its' final quarter or so, and the devastating effect this can have on all involved. Ben Kingsley plays the central character, and Roth manque, David Kepesh, a college Professor and respected cultural critic, whose ordered life is disrupted to a disastrous degree by one of his students, Consuela Castillo (Penelope Cruz, who one would have thought was perhaps little old for the part). He becomes completely obsessed with her, joy and jealously filling him as he realises that other men want her as well, and starts to understand that for all his intelligence and experience of life, he is unable to do anything about the emotions he is experiencing. With much of his work of the last two decades being often thinly veiled autobiography, with Roth's character being cast as the wronged or tormented innocent victim, it is perhaps sobering to bring to mind what some of the women in Roth's life, including ex-wife Claire Bloom, have said about the man in the past, and his allegedly cruel and ruthless treatment of them, and then see how the written accounts vary quite radically from what the reality may be. The first American production by the excellent Spanish director Isabel Coixet (My Life Without Me), this is intelligent and sincere, but really far too kind to the Kepesh character, the idea that he could be involved with someone as glamourous and seductive as Cruz being thinly-veiled wish-fulfilment. The ending of the film is also softened from Roth's original, depleting the impact and self-awareness of the written work. Quibbles aside, this is perfect material for the very capable Coixet, and the admirable cast is extremely diverse, including Patricia Clarkson (Lars And The Real Girl), Peter Sarsgaard (Shattered Glass), singer / actress Deborah Harry (Union City) and a surprisingly restrained Dennis Hopper (Easy Rider), showing perhaps how seriously he will take a part in an intelligent drama rather than the straight-to-DVD pot-boilers with which he is now too often associated.