Film details

The Man from London  2007

A Londoni Ferfi / L'Homme Des Londres / Der Mann Aus London
Film still

Cast

  • Miroslav Krobot
  • Ági Szirtes
  • Janos Derzsi
  • Erika Bok
  • Gyula Pauer
  • Istvan Lenart
  • Kati Lozar
  • Oszkar Gati Voice
  • Erzsobet Kutvolgyi Voice

Synopsis

Maloin, a man working in the signal box in the railway depot in a small French coastal town, is looking out on the harbour one evening when he sees two men, Brown and Teddy, liaise with each other. The pair argue, resulting in Brown pushing Teddy into the sea then running away rapidly. Maloin goes to the edge of the sea wall, and hauls the briefcase the men were seemingly arguing over, out of the water with a boathook, being unable to save Teddy. Opening the case after returning home, Maloin finds it is full of British banknotes. Visiting his daughter, Henriette, at the butcher's where she works, he is surprised to see her washing the floor, but is told by his wife, Camelia, that she is looking for a new job and will be leaving her current one soon. In the signal box that evening, Maloin sees Brown walking around the harbour below, seemingly looking for the briefcase. In the local cafe, Maloin is visited by Inspector Morrison, a friend, who tells him that another friend of theirs, Mitchell, has had his safe cracked and emptied, and that a man called Brown is the main suspect. He adds that should the money be returned, hinting that he knows Maloin has the cash, then Morrison will give him a substantial reward with no questions asked. Maloin tells Henriette to leave her job immediately, feeling she is being exploited by the butcher, infuriating the butcher's wife. He buys his daughter a fur stole, which enrages Camelia, who demands he return it. From the signal box that evening Maloin watches as Inspector Morrison and a Gendarme find Teddy's body and bring it to shore. Morrison asks Maloin what he saw on the night of the incident, and if he witnessed the murder. He claims not to have seen anything, but realises that Morrison is not convinced. Maloin is worried that he may be implicated in the murder, which he had nothing to do with, though having the money in his possession, but then a phone call from Henriette makes him believe that someone else believes he has the briefcase, and is trying to find it...

Production

Director
Béla Tarr
Producer
Humbert Balsan, Christophe Hahnheiser, Christoph Meyer-Weil, Paul Saadoun, Gabor Teni and Joachim Van Vietinghoff
Art Director
Peter Brill
Editor
Agnes Hranitsky
Music
Mihaly Vig
Screenplay
László Krasznahorkai and Béla Tarr, based on the novel by Georges Simenon
Director of Photography
Fred Keleman

Review

Coming in at a mere 132 minutes, The Man From London, a loose adaptation of the Georges Simenon novel, almost counts as a short from acclaimed Hungarian director Béla Tarr, whose Satantango, described by some as a cinematic masterpiece, rolls in at a gruelling seven and a half hours. But as to be expected from a Tarr film, this is not just a simple big screen version of the one of the prolific author's pot-boilers, but very much bears all the director's hallmarks, such as stark black and white photography matching equally stripped production values, shot in his favoured very tight 1:66 ratio. The title refers to a man called Brown, seen getting off a ferry with another man by Maloin (Miroslav Krobot), the switchman at a coastal railway station. The two men argue in the shadows and one ends up dead in the water as the other flees, leaving Maloin take the briefcase the body is left clutching. Taking the case home he finds it is filled with a vast amount of money, and believes no one knows that he has it, but it soon becomes apparently that he is very much the main suspect in the theft of the cash and has to make a difficult moral and practical decision. Although this may seem as if Tarr is making an attempt to break into the more accessible end of the art house field, he decides to make it even more uncommercial, with the film being largely silent, with Maloin and his wife Camilia (Tilda Swinton), originally having their few lines read in voiceover, in Hungarian, by two other performers, Oszkar Gati and Erzsobet Kutvolgyi, but Tarr has also produced a version in which the original actors supply their own voices but in what seems to be deliberately sloppy and out-of-sync readings, perhaps as a reminder to the audience of the artifice of the piece or perhaps as a reaction in being forced to produce such an alternate version. One has to also accommodate the fact that production of the film was interrupted several times, shooting having begun in early 2005 and then being suspended due to the suicide of one of the producers, veteran Humbert Balsan, only the first of several such hiatus in filming. Interestingly the original story has already been filmed twice, as L'Homme De Londres in 1943 and as a British version, Temptation Harbour, in 1947, but rest assured Tarr's version has absolutely nothing in common with these two simple crowd-pleasers. Béla Tarr's fans will obviously be the core audience, and if the film, by the director's choices, fails to have any crossover potential it only proves that Tarr is not interested in compromising his style and technique in order to win over any converts.