Film details

The Stepfather  2009

Cast

  • Sela Ward
  • Penn Badgley
  • Amber Heard
  • Sherri Stringfield
  • Jon Tenney
  • Nancy Linehan Charles
  • Jason Wiles
  • Skyler Samuels
  • Braeden Lemasters
  • Tracey Costello
  • Marcius Harris

Synopsis

A house in suburban Oregon. Having massacred the family within, a man in his thirties is in the bathroom, changing his appearance before leaving. Later, and now calling himself David Harris, he meets Susan Harding, an attractive divorcee, in a supermarket, she falling for his rugged charm. Six months later and Harris now lives with Susan in the house she shares with two of her three children, Sean and Beth, the two youngest. Michael, her eldest, returns home from military college, and is cordial to David, who seem to be obsessed with the idea of the all-inclusive family, and Michael is unsure of him as a stepfather-to-be, telling his girlfriend Kelly that certain aspects of the man don't seem to fit, and he is wary of him, not truly trusting him. Having had David's resemblance to a wanted murderer shown on the TV programme America's Most Wanted pointed out to him by a busybody neighbour, Mrs. Cutter, Michael thinks no more about it, knowing the woman's reputation for nasty gossip, but is surprised when she is found dead. Having had the two youngest children for a custody visit, Sarah's ex, Jay, returns them, and almost gets into a fight with David, taking an instant dislike to him. Having arranged for David a job at a local real estate office, Susan's sister is surprised and angered when David drops out of the job when there seems to be a problem over the forms of ID he needs to register. Jay, having found inconsistencies in the story David has told about his past, comes to visit him, wanting to confront him alone and not in front of Susan. David turns on him and kills him. Alarmed by the seeming disappearance of his father, although David shows him text messages he has seemingly received from him, Michael searches David's closet for evidence, and discovers that the messages he has sent are fake, he having Jay's phone. When David finds that Susan's sister is checking up on his past, he uses the opportunity posed by a huge storm to drown her, but as he is doing so Michael discovers Jay's body stowed in the basement freezer. Susan arrives home to find David in a blind, unstoppable rage, having finally lost control of the persona he has been presenting since his last killing spree, and the time to wipe out another family and start anew has come round again...

Production

Director
Nelson McCormick
Producer
Greg Mooradian and Mark Morgan
Art Director
Tim Eckel
Editor
Eric L. Beason
Music
Charlie Clouser
Screenplay
J.S. Cardone, based on the screenplay of the 1987 ITC Entertainment film by Donald E. Westlake, based on a story by Donald E. Westlake, 'Carolyn Starin' (Carolyn Lefcourt) and Brian Garfield
Director of Photography
Patrick Cady

Review

A horror remake which seems even more needless than usual, not only because the first two films of the original three featured a truly chilling performance from Terry O'Quinn (TV's Lost) as the chameleon-like Jerry Blake, moving from family to family in search of the perfect home, and slaughtering them when they didn't live up to his exacting standards of perfection, but also because the director and writer are Nelson McCormick and J.S. Cardone, the team behind the extremely mild and mannered 2008 remake of Prom Night, turning out a movie, rated PG-13 in the US, which if not exactly suitable for Channel 5's afternoon slot could probably play early evening, so watered down and sanitised were the scares of the original, and apt, considering the almost totally TV-derived cast. The Stepfather largely undergoes the same treatment, with the truly shocking scenes of the original, where Blake walks through the house of a family he has just dispatched, changing his identity before leaving, being recreated in a far less impactful and alarming style, before 'David Harris' (Dylan Walsh - TV's Nip/Tuck) is romancing attractive divorcee Susan Harding, (Sela Ward from TV's House, giving the best performance in the film) and within a few months he has his feet, and other things beside, under her table, to the alarm of homecoming military cadet Michael Harding (Penn Badgley - TV's Gossip Girl, another indication of how the cast is largely TV derived) and the more time they spend together the more Michael starts to suspect that David has some skeletons in his cupboard. The trouble with Cardone's script is that it switches the switches the emphasis the Michael detection of David's past, Michael being a new character replacing Jill Schoelen's character in the first, and by doing so it becomes more a question of when he will be exposed rather than, as in the first, when the central character will crack and decide once again that another family is imperfect, not living up to his expectations, and has to be wiped out, not too strong a phrase considering the depth and finality of his mania in the first film, taking away a lot of the tension where the audience has already seen just how savage and bestial Blake has been. Sadly Cardone also doesn't even grant the audience the benefit of their own imaginations, adding a slow and emphatic Police voice-over detailing several instances of families being killed by a mystery man and family member who has subsequently vanished and is being hunted for, the first film leaving Jerry Blake's past entirely nebulous, and making him all the more frightening for it. The new version also totally strips the idea of both the black comedy which director Joe Roth handled so well, and the very dark satire on the idea of the perfect and idyllic family, with Jerry Blake mere seeing his murder fests as a very final form of divorce. Dylan Baker is acceptable as David, although unlike O'Quinn in the first two films, a fatherly character so wholesome he could have appeared on the front of a knitting pattern, it is pretty clear that David has 'issues' from the start, and the cast is certainly capable, with the professionalism a career in mainstream career provides, tube refugees including Sherri Stringfield (TV's E.R.) and Jon Tenney (TV's The Closer), but also emphasises that McCormick and Cardone are essentially remaking notable 80's horror pics as TV movies. (1992's Stepfather III featured Robert Wightman taking over from O'Quinn in a failed attempt to keep the franchise going).