Film details

The Women  2008

Film still

Cast

Synopsis

While having a manicure, Sylvie Fowler, a New York magazine editor, hears that Stephen Haines, the wealthy husband of her close friend Mary, is having an affair with Crystal Allen, an ambitious gold-digger who works at Saks department store behind the perfume counter. Sylvie tells their friend Edie Cohen, but swears her to secrecy, Edie only telling another friend, Alex Fisher, a lesbian novelist. When Mary discovers the affair she is crushed, not only by the infidelity but by the fact her three closest friends knew of the liaison but did not tell her, completing her humiliation. Sylvie and Mary are out buying lingerie when they find themselves next to Crystal, Sylvie urging Mary to confront her there and then. Mary launches into her, but Crystal shamelessly faces her, and refuses to either apologise or end the affair. When she returns home she confronts Stephen and tells him she wants a divorce. With Sylvie under pressure to increase the magazine's circulation figures, she is blackmailed by Bailey Smith, the gossip columnist, into revealing everything about the Haines infidelity scandal, which is soon all over the magazine. Sylvie is forced to confess to Mary her complicity in exposing the affair, destroying their friendship. Sylvie becomes friendly with Molly, one of Mary's friends who is now avoiding her since she seems to be in the depths of despair. Inspired by a woman known as The Countess, a tough no-nonsense Hollywood agent who she met while on a yoga retreat, Mary decides she has to make her own mark on New York society, and decides to launch her own clothing line, her mother providing the finance. Having resigned from her job in shame at betraying her friend, Sylvie and Mary make up. Coming up with a plan to get revenge on Crystal, they tell their manicurist that Mary and Stephen are meeting in secret, he essentially cheating on Crystal with his own wife. Mary's first collection is unveiled, to acclaim, and a note arrives from Stephen, seeking a reconciliation, but Mary knows she can now live her life on her own terms.

Production

Director
Diane English
Producer
Diane English, Mick Jagger, Bill Johnson and Veronica Pearman
Art Director
Marco Ventenilla
Editor
Tia Nolan
Music
Mark Isham
Screenplay
Diane English, based on the 1939 screenplay by Anita Loos and Jane Murfin, based on the stage play by Clare Boothe Luce
Director of Photography
Anastas Michos

Review

The directing debut of TV writer Diane English (Murphy Brown), she certainly sets herself a task, a remake of George Cukor's 1939 classic The Women, originally written by Anita Loos and Jane Murfin, adapted from a very successful stage play by Claire Boothe Luce, and a classic piece of sharp, intelligent and waspish entertainment. Unfortunately with the attitudes of today, what was borderline scandalous in 1939 really does not play very well nearly seven decades later, even with a truly powerful all female cast. Focusing on high society women whose idea of a busy day is a spending spree in Saks or Bloomingdales, Meg Ryan (When Harry Met Sally) is the central character, Mary Haines, a woman in a happy and secure marriage to Steven, until she finds he has been putting his custom the way of shop girl Crystal Allen (Eva Mendez - We Own The Night). She soon has her friends rallying round to try to, if not win Stephen back, then certainly to derail Crystal, but unlike the quite biting comedy of the first version, this is surprisingly sentimental, with several overly emotional speeches delivered deadpan about the struggles of being a wife, where the only benefits here seem to be unlimited spending sprees on designer togs, and the upmarket department store Saks is ruthlessly plugged repeatedly, the several critics who dubbed it Saks And The City being spot-on. The quite amazing distaff cast includes Carrie Fisher (theStar Wars trilogy), Candice Bergen (from English's Murphy Brown), Joanna Gleason (Wedding Daze), Jada Pinkett Smith (Matrix: Reloaded), Cloris Leachman (Young Frankenstein) Debi Mazar (TV's Entourage), Debra Messing (TV's Will And Grace), Lynn Whitfield (Eve's Bayou), and Bette Midler (Ruthless People), but focusing on Mary and her problems means that some of these, particularly Cloris Leachman and Annette Bening get the short straw when it comes to screen time and decent lines. There is an uncomfortable undercurrent that Mary is so opposed to Crystal not only because she is not of her social standing, working behind the counter of a store rather than spending thousands over the counter, and she just sees her a Latina gold-digger, but its' also unintentionally amusing in that there are so many bitchy cracks about various characters having plastic surgery when its' obvious that some of the cast are no stranger to the scalpel and Botox. Fans of the stars get to see them in a showcase tailored for them, and any male presence is almost incidental, but this is so far away from the spirit and intentions of the original piece as to be a totally different entity altogether.