Film details

Doubt  2008

Film still

Cast

Synopsis

1964, the Bronx, and at the St. Nicholas Catholic School Sister Aloysius Beauvier, the school's strict and hardline traditionalist principle, listens to a sermon delivered by Father Brendan Flynn, the subject of the sermon being 'doubt' in all aspects of life, leading Sister Aloysius to question his motives, seeing the sermon as provocative. Serving on the altar is Donald Miller, the first black student the school has admitted, and who seems to have become Father Flynn's protege. Sister James, a young noviciate nun, goes to Sister Aloysius and airs her suspicions that Father Flynn has been giving Donald inappropriately 'special attention' and that when Donald returned after a meeting with the Father he had alcohol on his breath. Sister Aloysius decides that this only confirms her suspicions, that Father Flynn has been sexually abusing Donald, and decides to expose him, making it a personal mission to find the irrefutable proof she needs. With Sister James now feeling uncomfortable that Sister Aloysius is using her suspicions to launch an investigation into Father Flynn, the principle confronts him over the affair with Donald having been drinking, Flynn responding by saying that he had caught the boy drinking communion wine and is furious at being accused of impropriety. Sister Aloysius brings Donald's mother to the school to tell her of her fears over what has been happening to her son, but it soon becomes clear that Mrs. Miller is reluctant to have Donald move schools again, provoking the anger of her violent husband, and would rather that her son is at least settled, even if he is being abused by a priest. Discovering that she is waging a one-woman campaign against him, and determined to put his side of the story, Father Flynn confronts Sister Aloysius. Unruffled, she tells him that she has been making inquiries into his past, and that when she called one particular Sister in one of his former parishes she found out about his past improprieties and accusations made against him. Flynn is faced with a dilemma, and asks to make one final sermon to his parishioners, in which he will tell them that it is time he moved on, but Sister Aloysius is keeping something from him, something which is giving her doubts about herself....

Production

Director
John Patrick Shanley
Producer
Scott Rudin and Mark Roybal
Art Director
Peter Rogness
Editor
Dylan Tichenor
Music
Howard Shore
Screenplay
John Patrick Shanley, based on his own stage play
Director of Photography
Roger Deakins

Review

It has been eighteen years since playwright John Patrick Shanley directed his last film, the Tom Hanks comedy Joe Versus The Volcano, which was also his cinematic debut, and there are those who would claim that's not nearly long enough, but Shanley returns to the screen with a rather more sober and serious offering, an adaptation of his own very successful and lauded Pulitzer Prize-winning stage play. The setting is a Catholic School in the Bronx in 1964, and a nun, Sister Aloysius Beauvier, is approached by another of her order, Sister James (Amy Adams - Junebug / Enchanted) with accusations that a parish priest, Father Brendan Flynn (Philip Seymour Hoffman - The Savages / Capote) has been molesting a young student, incidentally the only African-American pupil at the school. Sister Aloysius confronts him, yet finds his self-confident veneer and swagger hard to penetrate, but slowly she starts to chip away at the man and his alibis and excuses, eventually pitting her version of faith with his, and what it means to them, both spiritually and physically. A very hard-hitting piece of work on stage, Doubt was essentially a two hander on stage, with other peripheral characters adding salient lines and asides, but mostly focused on the nun and the priest. Here Shanley, adapting his own work, opens the play out cleverly, adding the central character of Sister James, who first airs her suspicions, which is the catalyst for Sister Aloysuis' virtual witch hunt. Shanley also makes them interestingly polarised, with Streep's Sister being almost a caricature of an iron-jawed nun, who only in the later stages reveals her own doubts and insecurities, while Hoffman is brilliant casting as the charming, avuncular yet strangely sinister priest. Doubt is the title and it refers to aspects of both central characters as well. Viola Davis is memorable in a small role as Donald's mother, who is actually more comfortable with the idea of what may be happening to her son in closed cloisters than having to face the domestic consequences of what could happen if it is revealed and her son has to once more chance schools. A powerful drama, and one which remains credible with an awkward compromise solution being reached, this is the prefect showcase for the talents of Hoffman and Streep, which predictably landed her fifteenth Oscar nomination, in a year which has also saw her smashing box-office records in the film version of Mamma Mia. That's what you have to call versatile.