Film details

The Taking of Pelham 123  2009

The Taking Of Pelham One Two Three / The Taking of Pelham 1-2-3

Cast

Synopsis

Aboard a New York subway train, the Pelham 123, an armed man, Ryder, with his accomplices Ramos, Bakshin and Emri, hijack the train after shooting dead the onboard Police officer. The gang uncouple the rear carriages, holding eighteen hostages in the front railway car along with the motorman / driver, Jerry Pollard. Walter Garber, a controller in the Metropolitan Transport Authority contacts the train to enquire as to the hold-up and is told by Ryder to deliver a ransom of $10 million within one hour or he and his gang will start killing the hostages. The MTA contact the Mayor, who agrees to pay the ransom, knowing that the killing of any hostages will be a PR disaster for him. The NYPD bring in a trained negotiator, Lieutenant Camonetti, but Ryder insists on talking only to Garber. When his superior ignores this and sends Garber home, wanting contact to be left to the professionals, Ryder shoots the driver and insists on Garber being brought back. He is reluctant, but the two men start to form an uneasy relationship over the phone line, the MTA man insisting that he is just an ordinary guy caught up in the situation, while Ryder tells him he believes him to be much more than that, and converses on various diverse topics, making the NYPD worry as to his mental stability. The Police send snipers into the tunnel in order to stop the gang escaping, but one of them accidentally lets off a shot which hits and kills Ramos, Ryder shooting and killing a hostage in retaliation. Using the clues he has given them, Garber and Camonetti manage to work out Ryder's real identity, he actually being Dennis Ford, a disgraced Wall Street trader, arrested and imprisoned for major stock embezzlement. The money arrives, after a severe pile-up of Police cars on their way to the delivery point, but Ryder makes another demand - that Gerber is the man who walks down the tunnel and delivers it to the isolated railway car, insisting he wants to put a face to the voice he has been talking to. Gerber is hesitant but agrees, and takes the money to Ryder and the surviving members of his gang, but isn't ready for what the crazed extortionist does next....

Production

Director
Tony Scott
Producer
Todd Black, Jason Blumenthal, Tony Scott and Steve Tisch
Art Director
David Swayze
Editor
Chris Lebenzon
Music
Harry Gregson-Williams
Screenplay
David Koepp, based on the 1974 screenplay by Peter Stone from the novel by John Godey
Director of Photography
Tobias A. Schliessler

Review

It has to be said that of all the non-blockbuster Seventies films which are nevertheless appreciated by a lot of people, 1974's The Taking Of Pelham One Two Three, directed by Joseph Sargent, is one which is extremely popular, and probably doesn't need a remake, even though this is actually the third version of the tale, having also been remade as a TV movie in 1998 starring Edward J. Olmos (TV's Battlestar Galactica). In the ever-busy hands of Tony Scott (Top Gun / Crimson Tide / Domino), some of the iconic elements of the John Godey original, such as the villains addressing each other by colour-coded names such as Mr. Green and Mr. Blue (shamelessly purloined by Quentin Tarantino for Reservoir Dogs), have been dropped, and, as with his brother Ridley seemingly being joined at the hip to Russell Crowe, Tony Scott once again casts Denzel Washington, this time in the role of the NY Transit, now MTA, operative, a variation on the role so memorably and laconically originally played by Walter Matthau. Although the producers insist it isn't a remake, this seems a purely spurious statement, since the plot, which is both terrifically simple and deliciously complex, is retained virtually in its' entirety, as a team of robbers hijack a New York subway train, stranding it in a tunnel and holding the passengers hostage, demanding a massive ransom, in this case $10 million as opposed to the original $1 million, but then that's inflation for you, and it actually leads to one of the more ingenuous aspects of this flashy update in the sheer logistics and handling of ten million dollars, even in high denomination bills, Scott interestingly does not particularly expand the length of the piece, coming in within two minutes of the 1973 version, but crams it to the gunnels with his familiar camera tricks, split-screens, whip-pans, and cluttered, busy screens, helped by his editing rhythms which rarely give any particularly interesting shot a chance to breathe. There are also major changes to the two main characters, Washington's Gerber being demoted to the post he now holds through suspicions of taking bribes while working for the Metropolitan Transport Authority, while instead of Robert Shaw's cold and grave Mr. Blue, Travolta's Ryder almost never stops talking, spinning off on freeform tangents, but which also allow the authorities to actually work out who he is. Although Travolta's performance initially seems undisciplined and barely directed, it soon becomes clear that Scott is almost handling this as a two-hander, the constant conversation between the two being essential, and soon veering from just conversation to more serious topics, such as Gerber's culpability in a bribery case. Scott's cast has some strong names, including Luis Guzman (Boogie Nights), John Turturro (Barton Fink), and James Gandolfini (TV's The Sopranos) as The Mayor, interesting played far more seriously in this version than as the buffoonish character in the first film, which is surely a sign of the post 9-11 times, and an acknowledgement of what the city has been through, but Scott still retains his love of car chases and smashes, here shown in a well executed drive across the city in an effort to get the money to the station, inevitably ending in a pile-up and crushed metal galore. Although essentially the same story, this is very much Tony Scott's spin on the tale, a concept which will put off as many as it attracts, but under the layers and layers of gloss and camera tricks a very strong thriller remains, despite the tampering with the details of the plot, and while it may never earn the following of the first version, this upgrade and update is still worth the ticket.