Film details

In the Cut  2003

Film still

Cast

Synopsis

Frannie Avery is an English teacher in New York, trying to teach her class of students the finer points of Virginia Woolf's To The Lighthouse. She is in her late thirties and is still trying to get over her ex, John Graham, who is training to be a doctor, and finds consolation with her half-sister, Pauline, who lives over a strip club, the Baby Doll, and who restricts herself to affairs with married men since its emotionally easier to leave them after the thrill has gone. Going for a drink with one of her students, Cornelius Webb, who seems to have an unhealthy interest in serial killers, Frannie goes to the bathroom and sees a man receiving oral sex from a woman in the corridor. As she tries to avert her gaze she notices the tattoo on the man's wrist, and knows that he has seen Frannie watching them. The next morning she is visited by a homicide detective, James Malloy, who asks her if she saw or heard anything suspicious the previous night, a young woman being found brutally murdered at the back of Frannie's apartment building Sensing a mutual attraction, Frannie agrees when Malloy asks her out. It being Frannie's birthday, Pauline gives her a charm bracelet, one of a pair, as a present. In a bar with Malloy she realises he has a tattoo on his wrist similar to the man she saw in the corridor, and he jokingly remarks it's the sign of a secret society he cannot talk about. She finds that the murder victim, Angela Sands, was the woman who was servicing the man in the bar. Attacked by a mugger, Malloy comes over to take her crime report and the two end up in bed together, Frannie being drawn to his intensity. After another female victim is found, Frannie is asked to go through books of mug shots in the Police station, after which Malloy takes her into the woods and shows her how to fire a gun, wanting Frannie to be able to protect herself. Going to visit Pauline, Frannie discovers her body, she having been murdered in the same savage manner as Angela Sands. Trying to cope after the Police take over the case, Frannie gets drunk in her apartment when she is visited unannounced by Cornelius, who makes a clumsy and forceful pass at her, Frannie having to fight him off before he leaves and she finds that Malloy has sent his partner, Detective Richard Rodriquez to keep watch on her apartment, worried the killer may stalk her next. Malloy comes to see her and Frannie handcuffs him to a heating pipe as part of a sex game, then she finds a piece of Pauline's own charm bracelet in the cop's jacket. She accuses Malloy of being the killer and leaves the apartment with his jacket containing the evidence. Detective Rodriquez is waiting outside and he gives her a lift, driving her to where he says she will be safe, a piece of coastline where he goes fishing. She tells him about Malloy but starts to feel that perhaps she is suspecting the wrong man.....

Production

Director
Jane Campion
Producer
Laurie Parker and Nicole Kidman
Art Director
Daniel Stein
Editor
Alexandre de Franceschi
Music
Hilmar Örn Hilmarsson
Screenplay
Jane Campion and Susanna Moore, based on the novel by Susanna Moore
Director of Photography
Dion Beebe

Review

Although making some major changes to the original novel by Susanna Moore, particularly the mordant ending, both director Jane Campion (The Piano / The Portrait of a Lady) and actress Meg Ryan make major changes to their perceived images, Campion moving away from the slow period pieces which have been her most successful films, and Ryan totally losing the ditsy girl-next-door image, making Frannie a withdrawn and almost timid woman, finding dark aspects within Malloy (a believably louche Mark Ruffalo) which ignite a dark and hidden side of her. Although the synopsis is that of a very conventional thriller, Campion and Moore know that the plot is almost secondary to the characterisation, and its no exaggeration to surmise that almost any male in the film, from the policemen, the surprisingly friendly guards at the strip club, to Frannie's volatile ex-lover, could be the killer, and much of their dialogue reflects a culture in which women are less than sex objects, almost being an incumberance between men and their urges. Campion makes New York into a very dank and grimy place indeed, with almost every character having a hidden side, or emotions they are afraid to acknowledge, aided by Dion Beebe's (Chicago) gritty photography. This is certainly a departure for both star and director and even if the identity of the killer is predictable, and heavily hinted at through various dialogue exchanges, it is a compelling and unsettling film which faces some uncomfortable aspects of human needs and wants.