Film details

Stephanie Daley  2006

Still unavailable

Cast

Synopsis

Lydia Crane, a forensic pathologist, is called into the case of Stephanie Daley, a sixteen year old accused of murdering her premature infant, having concealed her pregnancy from her strict Christian family and friends. There is an element of doubt about the death, with the possibility that the young girl miscarried, and that the child was delivered dead at twenty-four weeks. The authorities want Crane to discover more about Stephanie's feelings before the birth, and just why she went to such lengths to cover her pregnancy. She claims not to have known she was pregnant, Crane feels an empathy with the girl, having just discovered she herself is expecting, and having a history of miscarriages. As the two women discuss what has happened, the doctor starts to understand just what was going through the girl's mind as the delivery date loomed, but as she does so, the more her down doubts and fears start to form in her mind.

Production

Director
Hilary Brougher
Producer
Sean Costello, Doug Dey, Lynette Howell, Samora Koffler and Jen Roskind
Art Director
Inbal Weinberg
Editor
Keith Reamer
Music
David Mansfield
Screenplay
Hilary Brougher
Director of Photography
David Rush Morrison

Review

A very serious and weighty drama, winning awards at film festivals including Locarno and Milan, and a screenwriting prize at the Sundance Festival, Stephanie Daley, written and directed by Hilary Brougher (The Sticky Fingers Of Time), establishes a provocative situation, touching on a number of very sensitive points revolving around parenthood, responsibility and personal anguish, and then almost refuses to deal with them, the dialogues between the two women alternating between different points of view and opinions, never making definitive statements. The casting is impressive, with Tilda Swinton (Oscar-winner for Michael Clayton) ideally chosen as the slightly withdrawn scientist, facing another personal challenge as she discovers she is pregnant once more, but has not so far managed to carry a child full term, and Amber Tamblyn (TV's Joan Of Arcadia) as the title character, who some would say was a cold-blooded murderer and others a young girl forced by her repressive Christian family to take the course of action forced upon her, and claiming she did not actually know she was pregnant. Certain important details, such as the state of the foetus and injuries inflicted on both mother and child are deliberately kept clipped and brief, the audience having to work hard to determine exactly the circumstances of what happened, the script still leaving a large number of issues unsettled by the end of the film. Good support comes from Timothy Hutton (The Falcon And The Snowman) and Melissa Leo (TV's Homicide: Life On The Street), but Brougher's handling of the script leaves too much unexplained.