Film details

Dinner for Schmucks  2010

Dinner For Idiots / Dinner for Dorks

Cast

  • Steve Carell
  • Paul Rudd
  • Zach Galifianakis
  • Jermaine Pennant
  • Andrea Savage
  • David Walliams
  • Lucy Punch
  • Octavia Spencer
  • Stephanie Szostak
  • P.J. Byrne

Synopsis

Tim Conrad, a financial analyst at a major Los Angeles corporation, finds himself being taken seriously by his boss after suggesting a new client to be bright into their company, and finds himself being invited to take part in a regular dinner in which the candidates have to bring with them a complete idiot as a guest, the winner being the one with the most moronic dinner guest. Tim is a little worried at this organised ritual humiliation, and his girlfriend Julie, an art curator, is appalled by the idea. After a mild car accident brings him into contact with Barry, an IRS investigator and part-time taxidermist who seems to be the perfect moron, and thus the ideal guest, he realises he has to take part, lying to Julie about his intentions. As he tries to get to know Barry, in order to take him to the dinner, Tim also starts to suspect that Julie may be having an affair with Kieran, an artist, Left alone, Barry gets into Tim's e-mail account, and accepts an offer from Darla, Tim's unbalanced ex-girlfriend, to visit. Julie arrives at Tim's apartment to find Barry there, and Barry sends her away, infuriating Julie. Believing Julie may be in Kieran's house, Tim goes there with Barry, but once they arrive, with Julie nowhere to be seen, Tim confesses his fears to Kieran, relieved that his suspicions have not been proved. Returning to his apartment, Tim is shocked when Darla arrives, and hides as she proceeds to wreck his flat. Taking Tim to his workplace in order to try to find the address of Kieran's ranch, where Tim believes Julie may have gone, Barry's introduction of Tim to his boss, Thurman, results in Thurman ordering a through audit of Tim's tax returns. Taking the firm's potential new client, Mueller, a Swiss billionaire, to lunch, Barry arrives with Darla, pretending to be Julie, Barry thinking this will make a good impression with the wealthy industrialist, Darla forcing Tim to propose to her or she will ruin the deal with the Swiss businessman, just as Julie arrives at the restaurant, causing the meal to end in disaster. Tim and Barry go to Kieran's ranch, and when Tim believes he is alone with Kieran he tells him what a total loser and colossal pain Barry is, not knowing he is being overheard by the subject of his rant. The night of the dinner arrives, with Barry having prepared something special, a diorama of stuffed and costumed dead mice, making everybody believe that, despite strong opposition, Tim has the winner, but Tim conscience is starting to plague him, and he decides he has to explain the promise of the meal to those innocents involved, knowing the damage it could do to his career.

Production

Director
Jay Roach
Producer
Laurie MacDonald and Walter F. Parkes
Art Director
Christopher Burian-Mohr and Lauren E. Polizzi
Editor
Alan Baumgarten
Music
Theodore Shapiro
Screenplay
David Guion and Michael Handelman (uncredited - and Ken Daurio, Andy Borowitz, Cinco Paul and Jon Vitti), based on the screenplay of the 1998 film Le Diner De Cons by Francis
Director of Photography
Jim Denault

Review

A project which has been around for very nearly a decade, Dinner For Schmucks, the somewhat bowlderised English language title of Francois Veber's subtle 1998 comedy Le Diner De Cons, a massive hit throughout Europe, has had most major comedy names attached to it over the years, everybody from Jim Carrey to Ben Stiller and Sacha Baron Cohen, but now hits the screen with Paul Rudd, who has obviously left his stage career, in the likes of the works of Neil LaBute, far behind, as the central character, Tim Conrad, a rising executive who participates in his bosses' competition, to try to find the most boring, idiotic and cretinous dinner guest, the event being known as the 'Dinner for idiots', as the participants all try to outdo each other with the calibre of guest, vying to bring the most unbearable character possible. With others having brought various losers and weirdos, Tim believes he has hit the mother lode with his discovery of Barry (Steve Carell - Get Smart), an IRS tax employee, who is remarkably dull and also utterly fascinating in his bizarre hobbies and generally oddball, hidebound lifestyle. Tim starts to befriend him, thinking he has the prize in the bag, but Barry causes havoc, setting off a chain reaction of disasters. With a very varied cast of comedy talent, in the loosest possible sense, from the brilliant Jermaine Pennant (TV's Flight Of The Conchords) to flavour-of-the-month Zach Galifianakis (The Hangover), and a small Hollywood role for Little Britain's David Walliams, as a bizarrely uptight Swiss businessman, who is naturally unravelled by an encounter with Barry, the fact that the pic is being helmed by Jay Roach (the Austin Powers / Meet The Parents series), shows the broad approach the producers are taking, and the rumours of the project going through more than two dozen rewrites in the years of development and production limbo would seem to be borne out by the fact that really very little of Veber's neat, stylish and acutely sharp comedy of manners and embarrassment remains, instead dumped in favour of a sprawling, rambling comedy which adds mostly new characters, including Pennant's excellently observed Kieran, an exasperatingly pretentious artist, and Galifianakis' shouty tax inspector Thurman, a small role which one suspects was largely to get his name in the billing, and interestingly the corporate idea is an American one, the French version just being a band of like-minded, mean-spirited friends, the corporate connections obviously acting as some sort of vindication in this version, for Tim's behaviour, wherein the original the equivalent character, played by Thierry Lhermitte, was pretty much the architect of his own destruction, and deserving it. In the remake the central character is largely coerced into participating, and is of course a good guy at heart, and a love story running through the middle of the script like letters through rock is also an addition, the French version being far more ruthless in destroying not only its' characters mental states but also their relationship. Veber's droll and witty original, a subtle critique on social status as well as delivering some terrific laughs and brilliant performances has essentially being given the inflationary treatment, adding many more characters and largely expanding everything about it, whereas the original could almost have been kept in one location, the apartment where the dinner is to be held, most of the film taking place in the one night of the dinner, whereas this version unwinds over days and weeks. We wouldn't go so far as to call it Cinema For Schmucks, and a lot of people will enjoy the mayhem Carell, in a truly terrible dye-job and false gnashers, creates, but any similarity between this and the Veber film is by now almost coincidental.