Film details

Milk  2008

Film still

Cast

  • Josh Brolin
  • Emile Hirsch
  • Diego Luna
  • Alison Pill
  • Lucas Grabeel
  • Victor Garber
  • Denis O'Hare
  • Joseph Cross
  • Eric Stoltz
  • Kelvin Yu

Synopsis

Harvey Milk, a gay man living in New York City in 1970, becomes involved with a younger man, Scott Smith, and the pair soon settle down to becoming a couple in an America which is still intolerant of gay men, and where gay bars and establishments are regularly raided by riot police. Wanting to leave the city and his job in insurance, Harvey moves to San Francisco's Castro Street area in 1972, he and Scott setting up a camera shop, as the area becomes a gay locale and Harvey becomes involved in local activism. Becoming politically involved, he stands for a city supervisor post in 1972 but is defeated, having failed to convince with either the gay or straight communities that he is capable of doing the job. Realising his straggly hair, beard and habit of dressing in old denims may not be putting over the right impression, he has his hair cut and starts to wear three-piece suits, but still loses when he stands for a seat on the state assembly. When the SF city boundaries are redrawn, Milk stands again for a seat on the board of supervisors in 1977 and succeeds, his campaigns being powered by a team of young assistants including Cleve Jones and Anne Kronenberg. But the campaigning and politicking has taken its' toll on Harvey and Scott's relationship and they break up, Harvey soon becoming involved with the flirtatious and irresponsible Jack Lira. Harvey joins the board of supervisors, as does Dan White, a former fireman and policeman who seems uncomfortable around Harvey although he is willing to work with him for their mutual benefit and towards shared political goals. Jack starts to act erratically as Harvey becomes more influential on the board, spearheading the opposition to Senator John Briggs' forwarding of Proposition 6 which, if passed by voters, will bar any gays from teaching posts. Harvey finds his political alliance with Dan White starting to falter, and a piece of gay rights legislation he is backing starts to look as if it may not be passed. He receives a death threat, which is taken seriously, but speaks at a large rally, despite being advised not to. He confronts Senator Briggs, being aided by sympathetic Mayor George Moscone, but the fragile Jack cannot cope with what he sees as Harvey's neglect of him, and hangs himself. Despite predictions to the contrary, Proposition 6 is defeated. In protest Dan White, by now showing signs of neurosis and paranoia, resigns his seat, but soon asks to be reinstated. When this is refused he starts to form a plot against the man he believes is responsible for his dilemma - Harvey Milk.

Production

Director
Gus Van Sant
Producer
Bruce Cohen, Dan Jinks and Michael London
Art Director
Charley Beal
Editor
Elliot Graham
Music
Danny Elfman
Screenplay
Dustin Lance Black
Director of Photography
Harris Savides

Review

The subject matter of Milk and director Gus Van Sant would seem to be made for each other, since the story, the career of San Francisco's first openly gay politician and his murder by a deranged ex-colleague would seem to need a maverick director, since many others were attracted to the project over the last decade or so and eventually passed, although the story has been told before in the 1984 Oscar-winning documentary The Times Of Harvey Milk, directed by Rob Epstein. Van Sant of course has been making award-winning films such as Last Days, Elephant and Paranoid Park, which have won him accolades and festival prizes but certainly not audiences, with even his core fans finding some of his more recent work, frankly, a trial. Although not facially similar, Sean Penn (21 Grams) takes the role of Harvey Milk, an openly gay politician who was elected into a supervisory post in San Francisco in February 1978, only to be gunned down in November that year along with San Francisco Mayor George Moscone by Dan White, a city supervisor who had resigned his job at protest at Milk's appointment and wanted his job back. The charge was reduced to manslaughter at the trial when the 'Twinkie defence' was introduced, claiming that White was not in control of his actions through having an overdose of the sweet, sugary Twinkie cakes the night before, the case eventually leading to riots on the SF streets. Although pioneering, Milk also had a turbulent private life, with one lover, Jack Lira (played here by Diego Luna - Y Tu Mama Tambien / Open Range) being mentally unstable and eventually committing suicide, and Penn plays Milk as a sincere and sharp political operator, eventually ditching the denims and getting a more conventional haircut when he realises that it is his mode of dress rather than his sexuality which is putting some potential voters off. Van Sant manages to recreate the period details perfectly and Milk's appointment is seen as a major turning point in civil rights, Penn focusing on the man's affability which apparently often made opponents warm to him, and which, ironically, probably acted as a smokescreen which initially hid Dan White's collapsing mental state. Josh Brolin, so impressive in No Country For Old Men, plays White, and unfortunately as with some aspects of the director's other films, is portrayed a little too broad, too obvious a villain, gradually becoming more paranoid and unpredictable, and at certain points Van Sant and screenwriter Dustin Lance Black hint at White being a repressed gay man himself, despite there being no evidence to suggest this at all, but perpetuating the self-loathing gay stereotype. Van Sant, as usual, has tried to damage his film post-release, complaining that he could not get the backing to have a gay actor cast and being 'forced' to go with Sean Penn in the lead, but despite his rather tiresome complaints Milk is a perfectly judged bio-pic which tells the story of a fascinating man who met his end all too early. A film sticking closely to the version Van Sant now claims he originally wanted to make wouldn't have attracted a tenth of the audience, and further condemned Van Sant to festival and arthouse limbo.