Film details

Brothers  2009

Cast

  • Jake Gyllenhaal
  • Natalie Portman
  • Mare Winningham
  • Sam Shepard
  • Bailee Madison
  • Taylor Geare
  • Patrick Flueger
  • Carey Mulligan
  • Omid Abtahi
  • Clifton Collins Jr.
  • Ethan Suplee

Synopsis

US Marine Sam Cahill, due to be deployed to Afghanistan in five days times, picks up his younger brother Tom from a prison in Minnesota, he being released after serving time for armed robbery. Taking him back to his parents, their reunion dinner ends badly when Tom and his father Hank argue bitterly. Sam goes to Afghanistan, but his plane is shot down on a mission and he is captured by the Taliban, being held along with another soldier, Private Joe Willis. Back in Minnesota, Sam's wife Grace is told that he has been killed in action. Stunned, and not knowing he is actually alive, the Cahill family try to cope with the loss and get on with their own lives. There is an awkwardness between Joe, still trying to settle into life outside prison, and Grace, but when he installs a new kitchen for her their relationship becomes closer, he starting to act as a surrogate father to Sam's daughters, Isabelle and Maggie, and although there is an obvious attraction between himself and grace, neither of them act upon it. Sam and Joe are repeatedly tortured by the Taliban for information as to their troop deployment and movements. Joe eventually cracks, telling his captors what they want to know, Since he is of no use to them any more they tell Sam to kill him, making him beat Joe to death with a metal pole. Soon after Sam is rescued when US troops storm the building where he is being held. Sent home, he is tortured by the memories of Joe's death at his hands, and when he returns to his family they immediately realise he is different - short-tempered, aggressive and suspicious. He is short and abrupt with his daughters, and accuses Grace and Tom of sleeping together, even though she insists they have not. After another uncomfortable family dinner, with everybody around the table being tense, Sam rips out the new fitted kitchen. When Tom attempts to stop him he pulls out a gun and levels it at his brother. Tom tries to negotiate with Sam, to get him to put the gun down, as the horrors and traumas of the past few months threaten to overwhelm him.

Production

Director
Jim Sheridan
Producer
Michael De Luca, Ryan Kavanaugh and Sigurjon Sighvatsson
Art Director
Guy Barnes
Editor
Jay Cassidy
Music
Thomas Newman
Screenplay
David Benioff, based on the screenplay of the 2004 Danish film Brodre, by Anders Thomas Jensen and Susanne Bier
Director of Photography
Frederick Elmes

Review

There are several interesting aspects to this American remake of the excellent Brodre, made in 2004 and directed by Susanne Bier, including the fact that it pairs Jake Gyllenhaal and Toby Maguire on screen, Gyllenhaal being heavily tipped to replace Maguire in the Spider-Man costume when it seemed the actor could not take part in the second film because of a back injury, and then would not reportely initially sign on for the third film in the series, and the two do indeed make convincing brothers, Maguire having a strange form of open-faced innocence as opposed to Gyllenhaal's darker, more brooding counternance. While the screenplay is by the acclaimed David Benioff (The 25th Hour / Troy), adapting the original script by Bier and Anders Thomas Jensen, the director is Jim Sheridan, maker of, among others, the hideously sentimental In America and the laughable Get Rich Or Die Trying, which quite seriously tried to cast Curtis Jackson, rapper 50 Cent, as some sort of tragically misunderstood renaissance man, and his thudding, clunking style of direction makes this version of Brothers a far more linear and conventional film than the Danish original, making the finale not only predictable but, when it finally arrives, oddly anti-climatic, since we know through the heavy-handed indicators what is coming. It is only a matter of when. Benioff keeps the basis of the original, with Maguire as Sam Cahill, a US Marine, first seen picking up his brother Tom (JG) who has just been released from prison, so the differences between them are clearly delineated from the start. When Sam goes missing while on operation in Afghanistan, he is believed dead, his wife Grace (Star Wars refugee Natalie Portman) not knowing that he has been captured by the Afghan insurgents, and faces raising their two young daughters alone. Tom tries to comfort his sister-in-law and the pair become close, eventually having a rather unconvincingly chaste relationship, but months later the news comes through that Sam has been rescued, and is on his way back to the US, and even before he arrives the audience knows that the happy smiling Sam of the opening reels will not be the one who returns. The shift to the US changes several aspects, but none to the advantage of the story or script. In the original the lead character, Michael, played by Ulrich Thomson (The Broken), was a UN peacekeeper, thus making his equally cruel imprisonment all the more skewed, and his moral dilemma at having to kill a man to save his own life all the more harrowing and damaging, whereas here Sam Cahill is only doing what he has been trained to do. Similarly it is not exactly dramatic to have Sam produce a gun at the end of the film when the Cahill household has them in abundance, the constant presence of weapons in the house inevitably lessening their shock value. The idea of adapting such a strong story as Brodre for an American audience, where the chances of the original being viewed were negligible, is a good one, but Sheridan's overkill takes away the nuances from what was a subtle and very tragic tale, and the casting actually makes the protagonists a little too young, mid-twenties compared with the mid-thirties of the original cast members including Connie Neilsen (Gladiator) and Nikolaj Lie Kaas (The Idiots). No offence meant to Gyllenhaal, Maguire et al, but stick with the original.