Film details

Broken Embraces  2009

Los Abrazos Rotos

Cast

Synopsis

There was widespread surprise when Broken Embraces, the latest from Spanish doyen Pedro Almodóvar, opened in his native Spain, and the almost unthinkable happened - reviews were lukewarm and box-office business only average, something unthinkable in a country where Almodovar is venerated not only as a filmmaker but a general well-loved celebrity. Some opined that unlike his previous rapturously received Volver, which was rather warmer, gentler and more heartfelt than a lot of his often vicious comedies and simmering melodramas, Almodovar is very much back to formula with this one, meaning the brief flashes of humour are grim, most characters are doomed, the atmosphere is heavy and the melodrama bubbling away on the back burner, as well as using his biggest budget ever. Almost more than ever this seems to be an Almodovar film in love with film itself, as so many of his early efforts were, being packed with references and asides all dealing with the cinema of the 40s and 50s. Central character is Harry Caine (Luis Homar - Bad Education), a blind screenwriter who changed his name from Mateo Blanco after the incident which took his sight. Hearing that corrupt stockbroker Ernesto Martel (Jose Luis Gomez - Goya's Ghosts) has died, he is glad, despite the man bankrolling his film Girls & Suitcases. When a young man called Roy X (Ruben Ochandiano - Che: Part Two) arrives, claiming to be Martel's illegitimate son and wanting Caine / Blanco to work with him on a script exposing his father for the evil swine he was, Blanco thinks back to the making of the film in 1992, where Martel was involved with Lena (Almodovar's current muse Penelope Cruz), a part-time secretary, actress and hooker, who Blanco auditions for Girls & Suitcases. They become involved with each other, causing her to leave Martel, and starting the events which bring Caine / Blanco to where he is today. Some reviews say that although the film looks stunning, as is expected, and Penelope Cruz rarely so glamourous, the dramatic part of the mystery fails because the audience is very much ahead of most aspects of the script, and can pretty much work out the events of the fourteen year interval. It may look immaculate but there is actually very little heart under the gloss. The director packs the cast with his regulars, including Bianca Portillo, Angela Molina and Rossy De Palma, and even gives his producer brother Agustin a cameo, but some reviewers have mentioned that this almost looks like a parody of an Almodovar movie, and is a step backwards after the delightful Volver.

Production

Director
Pedro Almodóvar
Producer
Agustín Almodóvar
Art Director
Victor Molero
Editor
Jose Salcedo
Music
Alberto Iglesias
Screenplay
Pedro Almodóvar
Director of Photography
Rodrigo Prieto

Review

There was widespread surprise when Broken Embraces, from Spanish doyen Pedro Almodóvar, opened in his native Spain and the almost unthinkable happened - reviews were lukewarm at best and box-office business only average, something unthinkable in a country where Almodovar is venerated not only as a director but a general well-loved celebrity, to a degree no equivalent UK filmmaker could match. Some opined that unlike his previous rapturously received Volver, which was rather warmer, gentler and more heartfelt than a lot of his often vicious comedies and simmering melodramas, Almodovar is very much back to formula with this one, meaning the brief flashes of humour are grim, most characters are doomed or damaged in some way, the atmosphere is heavy and the contrived and obvious melodrama is always bubbling away on the back burner. Given his biggest budget ever, almost more than ever this seems to be an Almodovar film in love with film itself, as so many of his early, more amateurish efforts were, being packed with references and asides all dealing with the cinema of the 40s and 50s, his pet period. Central character is Harry Caine (Luis Homar - Bad Education), a blind screenwriter who changed his name from Mateo Blanco after the incident which took his sight. Hearing that corrupt stockbroker Ernesto Martelo (Jose Luis Gomez - Goya's Ghosts) has died, he is glad, despite the man bankrolling his film Girls & Suitcases. When a young man called Roy X (Ruben Ochandiano - Che: Part Two) arrives, claiming to be Martelo's son, Blanco thinks back to the making of the film in 1994, where Martelo was involved with Lena (Almodovar's current muse Penelope Cruz). Almodovar is constantly peppering his film with references from everything from Golden Age Hollywood to Luis Brunel, and even his own back catalogue, Girls & Suitcases, the film Mateo is working on being a brazen reworking of his own 1988 film Women On The Verge of A Nervous Breakdown, arguably, to many, his masterpiece, and the treatment it is given by Martelo, being re-cut from a great piece of work into an incoherent mish-mash may seem to be a comment on the handling of art films by insensitive producers, but since Almodovar has always worked with is own brother Augustin as his producer, one wonders where the barbs are being aimed, especially since Augustin has a cameo here. The film looks stunning in parts, as is expected, the director using DoP Rodrigo Prieto (21 Grams / Brokeback Mountain), and Penelope Cruz rarely looked so glamorous or alluring, but the dramatic part of the mystery fails because the audience is very much ahead of some aspects of the script, and can pretty much work out the events of the years inbetween, while other plot points require such long monologues from the characters involved that the film slows up in several points where it should be motoring along. It may look immaculate but, for once, there is actually very little heart under the gloss. The director packs the cast with his regulars, including Bianca Portillo, Angela Molina and Rossy De Palma, but ironically for a film which stresses the importance editing can have on a great film, or any piece of visual work, his own editing here is lax, and the film cannot sustain itself as it moves on past the two hour mark, Although it will certainly draw his devoted audience, some of which will be loathe to say anything bad about the director's work, at times this almost looks like a parody of an Almodovar movie, indeed more like Girls & Suitcases than Broken Embraces, and is a surprising step backwards after the delightful Volver.