Film details

Synecdoche, New York  2008

Film still

Cast

Synopsis

Caden Cotard, a forty-year-old theatre director, is staging Death Of A Salesman in his home town of Schenectady, New York, but his private life is in trouble, his marriage to Adele Lack, an artist, is collapsing and he has fears that his four-year-old daughter, Olive, has inherited his heightened hypochondria and body phobias. Adele travels to Berlin to mount an exhibition of her work, taking Olive with her but not Caden, a move encouraged by one of her friends, Maria. Adele repeatedly extends her stay in Germany, causing Caden to start an affair with Hazel, who works in the theatre box-office. Awarded a MacArthur 'Genius' fellowship, Caden takes the large cash prize and begins a hugely ambitious project, setting up in a vast abandoned warehouse in Manhattan. Assembling a large cast, he prepares them for the play he is still working on, telling them that the rehearsals are to be completely emersive, and they are to stay in the warehouse setting, in the rebuilt apartments and dwellings allocated to their characters, and to remain in character at all times. Caden leaves Hazel, becoming close with Claire, his lead actress, who eventually becomes his second wife. They have a daughter together, Ariel. Having not seen his wife or daughter for six years, Caden takes a brief break from the project to fly to Berlin, where Adele now lives, Olive now being ten years old and seeming to be heavily under the influence of Maria, and having several tattoos. Caden, infuriated at what Maria has done to his daughter, attacks Maria. Returning to New York, he finds Hazel is now happily married, and in despair attempts suicide, but is found and saved. He starts to replicate the city within the warehouse, and the cast are told they are to stay in the warehouse sets at all times, in the rebuilt apartments and dwellings allocated to their characters, even though Hazel's apartment is permanently on fire, and she feel uncomfortable about sleeping in a constantly burning building. The cast expands as the rehearsals continue, eventually stretching out over two decades. Wanting to add aspects of his own life to the play already written, he casts an actor, Sammy Barnathan, who has been pursuing him for years, as a version of himself, 'Caden', and another actress, Tammy as Hazel. Hazel herself becomes his assistant after the failure of her marriage. Wanting to take the concept further, he cast actors as Sammy and Tammy, the pair becoming involved with each other as a part of their characterisation. Olive comes over the project, but refuses to forgive Caden for what he has done to her mother. More time passes, and the young woman dies in Caden's arms, just as he himself starts to realise he is extremely ill, breaking out in pustules. The project, already insanely out of control, spirals on, into its' third decade, Caden still insisting that the actors are rehearsing for an ultimate performance, but knows that he will not live to see the final act.

Production

Director
Charlie Kaufman
Producer
Anthony Bregman, Spike Jonze, Charlie Kaufman and Sidney Kimmel
Art Director
Adam Stockhausen
Editor
Robert Frazen
Music
Jon Brion
Screenplay
Charlie Kaufman
Director of Photography
Frederick Elmes

Review

The first directorial feature from the remarkably innovative screenwriter Charlie Kaufman, responsible for such as Being John Malkovich, Eternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mind and Adaptation, Synecdoche, New York has truly divided critics remarkably, some saying that it is a fascinating if utterly over-reaching work of incredible imagination, and others saying it was irredeemably self-indulgent beyond belief, with more than a few accepting that it was probably a bit of both, but even Kaufman's devoted fans may have trouble getting their minds around the writer's huge ideas here. Even the briefest of plot synopsis is all over the place, with the excellent Philip Seymour Hoffman (Capote) playing Caden Cotard, a successful stage director who, armed with a huge arts grant, decides to move his latest piece of work to New York, hiring a massive warehouse off Broadway in which to stage it. His private life is falling apart as he starts suffering from escalating ailments, and his first wife Adele (Catherine Keener - Being JM) leaves him, moving to Berlin with their daughter Olive (played as a child by Robin Weigart - TV's Deadwood). As his project expands he becomes involved with stage assistant Hazel (Samantha Morton - River Queen), Caden building a lifesize replica of Manhattan in the warehouse, and as the weeks, months and eventually years pass (must have been quite some grant), Caden starts to cast 'doubles' for those in his real life to become part of the 'ensemble' who are now essentially living their lives in this Manhattan replica, and casts Tammy (Emily Watson - Breaking The Waves) as the 'stage' version of Hazel, although Caden himself is played in the parallel New York by Sammy Basnathan (Tom Noonan - Manhunter), amusingly a man as tall and lanky as Caden is squat and wide. As if this were not enough for the average viewer, Caden starts to become seriously ill, and as his basic functions start to shut down, the project gets bigger and bigger in an unsubtle parallel, and the lines between reality and fantasy start to blur yet further, as if this wasn't off the scale already. The film packs a quite incredible amount into the 123 minute running time, and some of it is so obviously Kaufman, such as the permanently burning apartment of Hazel, which does not actually endanger her for years, or the idea that within the hanger is another hanger in which much the same is going on, and much of the film is held together by another superb performance from Hoffman, his determination becoming all the more consuming the larger and more insane the project becomes. With a terrific cast, very heavy on female talent, including Hope Davis (The Weather Man), Jennifer Jason Leigh (Short Cuts), Michelle Williams (Brokeback Mountain) and Dianne Weist (Hannah And Her Sisters), Synecdoche, New York certainly isn't going to be for everybody, and may never find the audience such an ambitious film really deserves, with even some staunch Kaufman fans finding it challenging to say the least, and one trade paper noted it was as if the filmmaker was trying to cram everything into one film, as if he was never going to be allowed to make another one, which hopefully will not become a self-fulfilling prophecy. (The Synecdoche of the title is a pun on Caden's home town of Schenectady, as well as being a figure of speech, in which part of a phrase is meant to represent the whole item, in this case Caden's project representing his whole life, and that of everybody around him. Nope, doesn't really explain much, does it).