Film details

My Best Friend's Girl  2008

Cast

  • Dane Cook
  • Kate Hudson
  • Diora Baird
  • Izzy Caplan
  • Riki Lindhome
  • Mini Anden
  • Hilary Pindle
  • Faye Grant
  • Nate Torrance
  • Malcolm Barrett

Synopsis

Boston resident Sherman Turner, known to all as Tank, is on a date with the beautiful Rachel when he suddenly starts to act crudely and boorishly, much to Rachel's surprise. She is rescued by Josh, her ex-boyfriend, who takes her away from the crude and objectionable Tank, not knowing that Tank was actually employed by Josh in order to win his girlfriend back by making him look good compared to Tank. Rachel realising she would rather be with someone dependable rather than venturing into the dangerous world of dating once more. Tank makes a good living out of this talent, and has 'helped out' dozens of ex-boyfriends in the same predicament so when his roommate, Dustin, is suddenly dumped by Alexis, his girlfriend, and Dustin realises that she has never met Tank, he decides to use his friend's unique talents in order to win her back. Tank manages to wrangle a date with Alexis, but before she meets him she gets drunk with her roommate Ami, and when he tries to embarrass Alexis by taking her to a strip joint she acts almost outrageously as the strippers on the stage. When she makes advances towards Tank he is forced to resist because of his friendship with Dustin. Alexis contacts Dustin and tells him that she thinks she should go out with other men in order to discover what they are like, alarming him and forcing Tank to visit her in order to try to persuade her to go back to Dustin, but after a loud row they end up kissing. Keeping their relationship secret from Dustin, they are soon involved with each other, meeting regularly for secret carnal assignations but their plan goes wrong when Dustin arrives unexpectedly when they are together and he discovers them. Dustin refuses to speak to Tank ever again. Alexis is invited to the wedding of her sister Rachel, who is marrying Josh, and asks Tank to go with her. Plagued by what remains of his conscience and believing that Alexis deserves a better man than himself, Tank goes into his best obnoxious act at the reception, being utterly offensive to the guests and all but ruining the entire event, which is capped when Dustin arrives on the scene and explains to all what Tank's actual grubby specialist line of work is. Tank realises that he truly loves Alexis, and attempts to reconcile with her, but she refuses to see him. Months pass, and the pair have an unexpected meeting in a restaurant, and Tank is suddenly made aware of just how painfully embarassing his own tactics are when they are turned on himself....

Production

Director
Howard Deutch
Producer
Guymon Casady, Dane Cook, Adam Herz, Doug Johnson, Barry Katz, Gregory
Art Director
T.K. Kirkpatrick
Editor
Seth Flaum
Music
John Debney
Screenplay
Jordan Cahan
Director of Photography
Jack N. Green

Review

Director Howard Deutch was tipped for big things after such 80s hits as Pretty In Pink and Some Kind Of Wonderful, before largely spending the rest of his career in US TV and surfacing for such disappointments as The Replacements and The Whole Nine Yards, but distributors Lionsgate posted an early warning in the US by stating well before release date that it wouldn't be screening My Best Friend's Girl for any critics anywhere, which is almost a pre-emptive strike on their own product. A very direct and unfettered sex comedy, the plot is only just this side of logical, with Dustin (Jason Biggs - the American Pie series) wanting to get back with his ex-girlfriend Alexis (Kate Hudson - How To Lose A Guy In Ten Days / The Skeleton Key), so hires his friend, the charmingly nicknamed Tank (the quite charmless Dane Cook - Good Luck Chuck) to go on a date with her which he will deliberately sabotage, making it the worst night out Alexis has ever had and making her realise how much better off she was with Dustin, this actually being Tank's very profitable business line, making obviously shallow and gullible women run back to the men they have just dumped, no matter the reason. So far, so logical, yeh? The plot of course gets inverted, with Alexis proving to be unpredictable, and behaving worse than Tank, and he, in the most illogical and unbelievable plot turn, falling for her and trying to keep their relationship from the duped Dustin. The script, the first by Jordan Cahan to be produced, works on a quite insulting idea, that women will run back to their big, protective ex-boyfriends when they feel threatened or embarrassed, women of course being unable to survive without a man in their lives and equally unable to just walk away from obnoxious jerks like Tank. Even the simplistic plotting of something like Pretty in Pink, made back in 1986, shows far more emotional maturity than this. Cook, no matter how the script tries to show he has 'changed', remains a dislikable presence on screen, Biggs seems now to be completely stuck in the Pie rut, and Hudson once more agrees to take the 'silly girlfriend' role which now seems to be her default, but at least doesn't have to play alongside Matthew McConaughy this time. What is perhaps so surprising is that the script is actually so crude and the language so strong for what is essentially meant to be a romantic comedy, and the film was cut in the UK for a 15 cinema rating, the cuts being made for the excessive and very harsh language That such a vulgar piece of work would feature such capable actors as Hudson and, in a smaller role, Alec Baldwin, currently going through a career renaissance with the brilliant 30 Rock TV series, is something more surprising than any plot development in this grubby piece of work.