Film details

Good  2007

Cast

  • Jason Isaacs
  • Jodie Whittaker
  • Steven Mackintosh
  • Gemma Jones
  • Gemma Jones
  • Anastasia Hille
  • Ruth Gemmell
  • Ralph Riach
  • Stephen Elder
  • David De Keyser
  • Adrian Schiller

Synopsis

Berlin scholar Professor John Halder is invited to the German Chancellery in the spring of 1937, and asked to draft for the Government a paper on the positive case for euthanasia, Halder being selected because of a novel he wrote four years earlier which reflected some of his down domestic circumstances, when he and his wife Helen had to deal with his increasingly senile mother as well as taking care of their two children. Halder, who teaches literature, finds himself having to do much of the domestic work as Helen, a composer, tried to work on her music. It was May 1933, and his father-in-law tried to get him to join the Nazi Party, saying it would be good for his career, but he declines. Meeting his good friend, Maurice, a Jewish psychiatrist, Halder tells him that Hitler cannot last, and will soon be swept out of office once the German people see through him. Nazi sympathising students at his college burn books in a bonfire, but Halder does nothing to stop it. Finally unable to take his domestic arrangements any longer, he leaves Helen, moving in with Anne Hartmann, one of his students. 1937, and, flattered by the authorities' interest in his work, he accepts an invitation to join the Party, taking a purely honorary post in the SS, which the Party officials insist is just a formality, and a titular position, Halder finds he is quickly appointed head of his department. Maurice is shocked, despite Halder's reassurances, and tells his friend he is worried, afraid of what the Nazis are going to do to people like him, but he will not leave Germany. Halder hears that his novel is going to be made into a film, with some famous stars in the cast. 1938, and with the position of Jews in Germany becoming more perilous, Maurice asks Halder for help in getting a ticket to Paris, which the Professor hesitates over before managing to secure one for his friend. On the night of 9th November, a night of violence which will come to be known as Kristellnacht, Halder is ordered to patrol the streets but, knowing Maurice will be coming to pick up the Paris ticket, he leaves it with Anne, tellng her Maurice is expected. When he finally returns home that night he finds the ticket still there, Maurice not having collected it. He receives another promotion, as the chief inspector in a hospital for the mentally handicapped. April 1942. The War is raging, and Halder is running what is being called a 'resettlement programme' for Eastern European Jews. Having impressed SS Oberstrumbannfuhrer Adolf Eichmann with his efficiency and clear mind, he meets the high-ranking Nazi, who shows him his clear and precise filing system. Wondering what happened to Maurice, whom he never saw again, he looks for his name, and discovers exactly what happened that night, and starts to see perhaps for the first time what he himself has become.

Production

Director
Vicente Amorim
Producer
Sarah Boote, Billy Dietrich, Kevin Loader, Dan Lupovitz and Miriam Segal
Art Director
Andreas Olshausen (supervisor)
Editor
John Wilson
Music
Simon Lacey
Screenplay
John Wrathall, based on the play by C.P. Taylor
Director of Photography
Andrew Dunn

Review

Starring one of the most interesting and surprisingly underrated actors currently working, Viggo Mortensen, and having an unusually intelligent screenplay by John Wrathall, Good has to very much expand the narrative from the original staging quite extensively. The set of Taylor's play, staged shortly before his death in 1981, consisting of a bare dark set, illuminated only three chairs by several spotlights, the small cast playing multiple roles in telling the story of a good man, the scholar John Halder, slowly being corrupted by a mixture of flattery, promises, praise, and outright deception, both by those who wish to manipulate and use him, and by himself. The central idea is how a perfectly good and decent man can become totally corrupted, in this case by fascism and the Nazis, while still believing himself to be virtuous and true, an allegory expanded by Taylor to encompass the entire nation, as millions of Germans found themselves becoming involved with the party while still believing themselves to be 'good' people. In opening up the script it is at times actually handled a little too delicately, and the final horrifying transformation is not as truly impactful as it should be, since we have seen Mortensen's transformation in stages. Halder is at first flattered to be hailed as a great mind by the party officials, despite the implorings of his Jewish friend Maurice (Jason Issacs - Black Hawk Down / the Harry Potter series) to see the truth of what they are planning and who they really are. Feted and offered ever more prestigious academic positions, Halder finds himself drawn further and further in, becoming willing to adapt his work to the party's ideals, even as the true violence of the ideology starts to become every more obvious. On stage one discovers what was happening to Halder purely by the script alone, instead of seeing him ushered into large gatherings with Nazi banners and swastikas everywhere, and meeting SS-garbed officers face to face, his indoctrination becoming clearer. The moral is obvious, and to the end Halder believes that what he is doing is good and justified, despite the warnings of both Maurice and the evidence of his own eyes. Getting uniformly excellent performances, from the always reliable Mortensen and Isaacs to Gemma Jones (TV's Spooks) as his senile mother, Mark Strong (Body Of Lies), and Anastasia Hille (The Hole) as his wife, soon dispensed with in favour of a young student (Jodie Whittaker - Venus), director Vincente Amorini (The Middle Of The World) is obviously trying to avoid any accusations of sensationalism, handling the drama at an even, measured tempo, when the film really needs a final, devastating punch in its' final scenes.