Film details

Mark of an Angel  2008

L'Empreinte De LAnge

Cast

  • Catherine Frot
  • Michel Aumont
  • Wladimir Yordanoff
  • Antoine Chappey
  • Michele Moretti
  • Sophie Quinton
  • Genevivre Rey-Penchenat
  • Heloise Cunin
  • Arthur Vaughan-Whitehead
  • Zacherie Chasseriaud
  • Jeremie Bebbou

Synopsis

Elsa Valentine, the mother of a young son, Thomas, is involved in a bitter divorce battle with her husband, Alain, which threatens to take her son away from her, Alain bringing up the thorny subjects of her painkiller addiction and a previous mental breakdown. Going to a child's birthday party with Thomas, she sees a seven year old girl, Lola, and rapidly becomes fascinated by her. Elsa starts to become obsessed with the child, who reminds her of Lucie, her own daughter who died in a hospital fire seven years earlier. Elsa's infatuation with Lola becomes overwhelming, forcing her to miss going to work, to forget to collect Thomas from school, and to lie to her friends about where she is going, spending time outside the school gates looking for any sight of the girl, going so far as to watch her through her bedroom window. Discovering that Lola's family, mother Claire Vigneaux and father Bernard, are planning to leave France for a new life in Canada, Elsa poses as a potential buyer of their house, and slowly becomes friends with them, spending time with them socially, although Claire becomes suspicious when Elsa seems overly protective and affectionate towards Lola during an ice-skating trip, resulting in an accident on the ice which injures the child. Claire starts to avoid Elsa, deliberately making arrangements which do not involve her, and is alarmed when Elsa arrives at a ballet performance to which she was not invited, and obsessively watches Lola dancing from the wings of the stage. Claire starts to reinforce the security arrangements in her house, but driven by what she sees as Claire's attempt to keep her away from Lola, she breaks into their house, but is discovered by Claire and causing the two women to fight viciously. With both women hurt and on the verge of hysteria, Elsa makes a demand, and in doing so brings back the memories which Claire has suppressed for so long, and which will reveal a long-held, agonising secret.

Production

Director
Safy Nebbou
Producer
Michel Saint-Jean
Art Director
Olivia Bloch-Laine
Editor
Bernard Sasia
Music
Hugues Tabar-Nouval
Screenplay
Cyril Gomez-Mathieu and Safy Nebbou
Director of Photography
Eric Guichard

Review

A drama / thriller from director and co-writer Safy Nebbou (The Giraffe's Neck), Mark Of An Angel deals with both a very alarming examination of a woman clearly on the verge of complete collapse, having had previous mental problems and a current painkiller addiction, and what seems to the latest manifestation of her mental state, her conviction that the child of another woman is in fact the child killed in a hospital fire seven years earlier, no matter how illogical this sounds. What turns it from a simple melodrama into something which is far more deeply and seriously disturbing is the excellent performances director Nebbou gets from his leads, both Catherine Frot (The Page Turner) and Sandrine Bonnaire (Rivette's two-part Jeanne La Pucelle), especially in the scenes the pair share together, as the plot starts to expose just how disturbed and determined the troubled Elsa (Frot) has become, before delivering the main thriller twist of the plot, which does seem a little far-fetched and which to some will be superfluous, Nebbou already having turned the film into an unsettling psycho-thriller even before Elsa's desperation has her break into the house on which Claire (Bonnaire) has had the security increased, she seeing just how possessive this woman is becoming of her daughter. Both women have terrific parts written for them by Nebbou, Frot's Elsa being both sympathetic and yet dangerous, as everything in her life, from her soon-to-be ex-husband to her young son, seems to turn against her, and Bonnaire, whose Claire is very much the victim, soon almost becoming besieged by the increasingly frantic Elsa. Where the film is at its' cleverest is toward the final quarter, where the actual balance starts to alter, the audience starting to believe that perhaps Elsa is not as deluded as it initially seems, and that Claire may be hiding something, although it has to be said that Nebbou's script actually comes to a rather unfeasibly comfortable accommodation at the ending, constructing a solution which seems a little too conventional for a film which has, up until this point, been extremely edgy and unsettling. The director's handling of the talent on screen, which includes brief but telling performances from Michel Aumont (The Closet / Tais-Toi!) as Elsa's determined and much older husband Alain, and Wladimir Yordanoff (I Do / L'Auberge Espagnole) as Claire's increasingly worried spouse, is exemplary, which covers up what some will see as a disappointing resolution after all which has gone before.