Film details

Fighting  2009

Cast

Synopsis

Shawn MacArthur arrives in New York from Alabama, believing he will be able to make a living in the city as a street peddler, planning to mark out a pitch and start selling counterfeit goods. As he tries to stake a piece of sidewalk as his own, he gets involved in a brawl over territory, and Shawn brutally disposes of the opposition. He is approached by Harvey Boarden, a ticket tout, who saw him fighting and believes he can get him onto the underground fighting circuit, illegal, dangerous and unlicensed bouts which attract huge amounts of money in illegal bets. Harvey becomes his agent, and quickly finds him opponents on the underground circuit. Shawn first fights a Russian boxer, and shiftly deals with him. Later celebrating at a club, Shawn runs into Zulay Velez, a barmaid who was one of his customers during his brief spell selling bootleg merchandise. Having nowhere to stay, Shawn accepts Harvey's offer to move in with him, and finds him more fights, Shawn defeating a skilled martial-artist, and becoming involved in an out-of-ring skirmish with Evan Hailey, a rival who was trained by Shawn's estranged father. Shawn and Zulay start dating, and he is introduced to her grandparents, who raised her after the death of her parents. Caught up in a brawl in a back alley in the Bronx, the crowd and fighters scatter when one of them produces a gun. Telling Shawn he has arranged a big money showdown with Evan, Harvey stuns Shawn by asking him to take a dive and throw the fight. Shawn initially refuses point-blank, but realises he is in Harvey's debt, and reluctantly agrees to Harvey's request, the fight being arranged for a penthouse rooftop with an audience of high rollers. Knowing Zulay is short of money and in financial trouble, she refuses when Shawn offers to help, and they begin to sleep together. He is shocked when he arrives at her apartment to see Harvey leaving, and she confesses that she places bets for Harvey, and that half a million dollars is going to be placed on the upcoming fight by various investors and gamblers. Shawn prepares for the fight, knowing that he has agreed to throw the bout, but also knowing that he is in a very dangerous business, and is in far too deep.

Production

Director
Dito Montiel
Producer
Kevin Misher
Art Director
Randall Richards
Editor
Saar Klein and Jake Pushinsky
Music
Jonathan Elias and David Wittman
Screenplay
Dito Montiel and Robert Munic
Director of Photography
Stefan Czapsky

Review

Written and directed by Dito Montiel, whose debut A Guide To Recognising Your Saints, adapted from his own memoir, very much divided the critics a couple of years back, Fighting, a title which largely sums up its' contents, seems to be a rather straight-faced version of a very, very old plot, despite the writer / director's claims that this is a 'new' story, claiming he has found evidence of illegal underground fighting networks happening in modern US cities today. Really, you don't say. Despite the documented evidence of such a world going back centuries, one of the films Fighting so obviously is inspired by, the superb Charles Bronson drama Hard Times, shares virtually the same plot and is set in the days of the American Depression of the 1920s. Channing Tatum (better known for dance movies such as Step Up as well as appearing in Saints) plays Shawn MacArthur, a young counterfeiter who arrives in New York City and is befriended by a 'scalper', or ticket tout, Harvey Boarden (Terrence Howard - Iron Man), after he sees Shawn dispatch a couple of thugs in an attempted mugging. Harvey gets him into the underground fighting circuit, taking on mixed martial-arts fighters in all styles, as well as plain old rock-hard bruisers. But, wouldn't you know it, its' all rigged, with a Russian mob organising the events and fixing the fights, and Shawn finds himself having to make that old moral decision, to take the money as well as the fall or stand up for what he believes in. Unfortunately Channing Tatum, although obviously fit, is obviously no match for the hugely-muscled behemoths he is matched against, from solid, lithe Harlem fighters to granite-hewn Russians, yet manages to defeat men twice his size and weight, not through any devastating technique but, the audience is meant to believe, by strength, power and skill, in a sport he has been involved in for mere days. Even odder, what should be the real core of the story, the relationship between himself and rival Evan Hailey (Brian White - Stomp The Yard / 12 Rounds), who was trained by Shawn's estranged father, is barely dealt with, their obvious past involvement, or any other mentions of his parent and their own relationship, is just ignored by Montiel, meaning the final confrontation carries very little weight. The fight choreography, which many will be purely interested in, is effective with little in the way of original staging, although the soundtrack is ramped up to HK movie levels, meaning every blow strikes with the accompanying sound of a dropping stack of plates, or small stun grenade. The list of films which use virtually an identical plot would run off the bottom of this page, with Ong-Bak, Fatal Impact, Never Back Down, Death Strike, Underground and even David Mamet's Redbelt being just a few of the more recent ones that come to mind immediately, and it is also a list on which Fighting would come fairly low down, and takes itself remarkably seriously, obviously believing itself to be gravely important drama rather than a slick-looking action film. The dependable Luis Guzman is about the only other recognisable name in the cast, albeit in a wasted supporting role, and the truth of the eccentric casting is that as an underground bare-knuckle fighter Channing Tatum is one hell of a dancer.