Film details

Creation  2009

Cast

  • Jeremy Northam
  • Toby Jones
  • Jim Carter
  • Benedict Cumberbatch
  • Teresa Churcher
  • Zak Davies
  • Bill Patterson
  • Harrison Sansostri
  • Pauline Stone

Synopsis

Scientist and writer Charles Darwin is living with his wife Emma in a quiet English village, working on the tome of what he believes is how mankind evolved from the apes, and how all species evolved from other forms, planning to call his publication, when it is finally finished, On The Origin Of The Species. There are difficulties in his marriage to Emma, who is strongly religious, and Darwin while working in his study often talks to his young daughter, Annie, telling her of his various projects and his future plans, and how both he and her mother miss her, Annie having in fact died some years earlier, in April 1851, aged only ten, possibly caused by the after-effects of a bout of scarlet fever she caught two years earlier. Although having other children, two of which died in infancy, Darwin feels Annie's absence acutely, and started to perhaps worry that her death was due to hereditary factors, Emma being his cousin, and worrying that his children may have inherited weaknesses and physical frailties due to genetic problems. A devoted and attentive father to all his children, he fantasises that she is still with him in spirit in order to try to cope with his grief and the feeling that he and his wife, who he loves with a passion, is drifting away from him, both due to the death of Annie but also because of the demands of his work, both of them seeming to blame the other for her death. He clashes with the local minister, Reverend Innes, over his belief in science rather than religion, with the churchman making veiled remarks which seems to blame his interest in science and his lack of faith for his daughter's death. Darwin travels to the spa in Malvern where he went for hydrotherapy treatment for his persistent ailments in 1849, and where Annie died, and starts to be able to come to terms with her death, returning to Emma and finding their relationship immediately approving when they realise they must help each other get over the loss rather than trying to apportion blame, and know that although Annie is gone, their other children will need their love and care more than ever. Hearing that another scientist, Alfred Russell Wallace, is about to publish his works, which is on very similar themes to Darwin's own, he knows he has to consider publication himself, or be beaten into print by his rival, and his own efforts negated. Preparing his manuscript, he tells Emma that he will leave the final decision whether to publish or not to publish to her, and vowing to abide by her decision.

Production

Director
Jon Amiel
Producer
Jeremy Thomas
Art Director
Bill Crutcher (supervisor)
Editor
Melanie Oliver
Music
Christopher Young
Screenplay
John Collee, based on the biography by Randal Keynes
Director of Photography
Jess Hall

Review

Bound to cause petitions of protest and picketed cinemas in some of the more - er - unspoiled parts of the US, Creation focuses on a fascinating period in the life of Charles Darwin, the loony Creationist's public enemy number one, when his Theory of Evolution had yet to be published, but he faced turmoil in his private life after the death of one of his children, Annie, who died when she was just ten years old, after visiting her father at the Malvern spa where he went to try to cure his own frequently poor health. The fascinating thing about Darwin, here portrayed by Paul Bettany (Master And Commander / The Da Vinci Code) was that his was a life of extreme contrasts, his devotion to science being at odds with having a wife, Emma (Bettany's real-life wife Jennifer Connelly, acting together on screen for the first time) who was deeply religious, and for his all devotion to his studies, was a totally devoted family man, he and Emma eventually having ten children, three of which died, which at the time was an acceptable mortality rate, as surprising as that sounds now. As if to almost defect criticism by the religious, Darwin is shown to be at times trepidatious about publishing his findings, clashing with the local minister (Jeremy Northam - Enigma) and eventually essentially putting the decision whether or not to publish, knowing that another scientist is about to publish a paper on a very similar theme, and which will essentially negate and make almost irrelevant Darwin's own work should it be published first, he puts the decision to publish into the hands of Emma, a plot pivot which cannot be proved but which works well in the context of the film giving his wife the crucial decision - to publish for the sake of science and her husband's career and standing, or to suppress it for the good of her own beliefs. One certainly feels for them both, even though, and it sounds uncharitable to say such, Annie was but one of ten, but it polarises the beliefs of both of them, and the resolution satisfies both of their agendas, if only partially. Directed by Jon Amiel (Sommersby / Entrapment), Creation bristles with impressive performances, and the supporting roles are filled with very impressive British actors including Toby Jones (Infamous) as the couple's good friend Thomas Huxley, himself a skeptic concerning Darwin's theory, Jim Carter (The Golden Compass), Benedict Cumberbatch (The Other Boelyn Girl) and Bill Paterson (Comfort And Joy). Amiel can certainly handle this sort of material, even if some of his more recent movies have been Hollywood multiplex fodder, and as if to add even more credibility to the project, the book on which it is based, Annie's Box: Darwin, His Daughter, And Human Evolution, is written by Randal Keynes, the great-great-grandson of Darwin himself. An intelligent and sober drama about one of the most truly important, and divisive, figures of the last two centuries.