Film details

Is Anybody There?  2008

Is There Anybody There?

Cast

  • David Morrissey
  • Anna-Marie Duff
  • Bill Milner
  • Rosemary Harris
  • Leslie Phillips
  • Peter Vaughan
  • Adam Drinkall
  • Elizabeth Spriggs
  • Sylvia Syms
  • Thelma Barlow
  • Angie Inwards

Synopsis

The late Eighties, and ten-year-old Edward lives with his parents, in the struggling retirement home they run in a depressed seaside town. Through his daily dealing with the elderly and the dying, he has become morbidly obsessed with death, and is determined to try to make contact with the souls of the residents who have recently passed on. He sees the arrival of a new resident, Clarence, a man with the first signs of dementia, which has shortened his already volatile tempter. Edward discovers he is a former magician, now widowed, but Clarence is initially dismissive of the young boy. Edward manages to stop Clarence's half-hearted suicide attempt, and covers up the evidence from his parents, knowing that it would mean Clarence being taken away, and the two start to become close. Edward finds his parent's becoming more and more preoccupied, his mother with trying to keep the retirement home afloat, while his father is in turmoil after becoming captivated by Tanya, a young nurse on the staff, which has made him worry about his marriage and his family. Realising Edward is deadly serious about trying to contact spirits, Clarence accompanies him on a trip to a graveyard, and also organises a phony seance. Feeling more confident through the old man's friendship, Edward asks his parents to throw him a birthday party, with Clarence offering to performing some magic tricks, but when the old man goes to the magic shop to stock up on cards and other equipment, he finds himself becoming confused and panicked. The party goes ahead, but ends disastrously when one of Clarence's riskier tricks goes horribly wrong. Edward, distressed, decides to ask his parents about their marriage and what is going on between them. His father walks out on them. Seeing that Clarence is deteriorating rapidly, he grants the old man's final wish, taking him out of the home for a special rendezvous, and realises that what people say is true, and that the dead are always with you.

Production

Director
John Crowley
Producer
David Heyman, Peter Saraf and Marc Turtletaub
Art Director
Lynne Huitson
Editor
Trevor Waite
Music
Joey Talbot
Screenplay
Peter Harness
Director of Photography
Rob Hardy

Review

There are three very distinct generations of British acting talent on display in Is Anybody There?, directed by John Crowley (the highly praised Boy A), beginning with the fine young actor Bill Milner (Son Of Rambow), through young(ish) leads David Morrissey (The Reaping) and Anne-Marie Duff (Garage) through to a truly excellent array of real veterans, including Leslie Phillips (Venus), Peter Vaughan (Face) and Sylvia Syms (Ice Cold In Alex), with Michael Caine taking another role which actually admits to his advancing years and which he is handling rather better than many of his generation. The setting is the old people's home where ten-year-old Edward (Bill Milner) is growing up, and the script by TV writer Peter Harkness actually draws a lot on his own upbringing in a similar establishment, although considering the extremely emotional events which occur one hopes it is not too auto-biographical. His parents (Morrissey and Duff) run the establishment, but his father is becoming more and more depressed as he tries to keep the business afloat. Edward becomes fascinated with the fact that the residents inevitably die and is determined to discover what happens afterwards, trying to cope with the idea of life after death and becoming obsessed with the idea of ghosts and the afterlife, ideas which are only piqued when a new resident arrives in the form of Clarence (Caine), a retired magician who retains a rebellious streak. Although the central core relationship of a young boy, essentially beginning in life, finding a common bond with someone who is on the verge of losing theirs is not new by any means, any false sentimentality is dispelled by some bracingly frank and decidedly black humour as Clarence tries to tell Edward, first gently and then in rather stronger terms, that there is nothing after death, and life is all there is. Much poignancy comes through Edward's belief that there has to be something more because, even at his young age, he sees little in life, from his unhappy parents, his gloomy home and constant reminders that life is only temporary and, crucially, he will not remain a ten-year-old forever. Although Caine, a remarkable 76 years old, is a little too robust as Clarence, his very obvious decline towards the end of the film is very believably portrayed by the actor, who is producing some very fine performances now, at this late stage in his career, arguably revitalisied by his collaborations with Christopher Nolan, and rather tighter quality control than during the Eighties. The film was also sadly the last made by the excellent stalwart Elizabeth Spriggs (Sense And Sensibility), who died during post-production. Quite refreshing in the way it faces death, and mining some very grim laughs out of the situation, Is Anybody There? takes an initially unpromising premise and through a combination of very fine writing and excellent performances makes a comedy / drama which works very well on both levels,