Film details

Bottle Shock  2008

Cast

  • Rachael Taylor
  • Freddy Rodriguez
  • Dennis Farina
  • Eliza Dushku
  • Miguel Sandoval
  • Bradley Whitford
  • Joe Regalbuto
  • Hal B. Klein
  • Philippe Bergeron

Synopsis

1976, and Jim Barrett, the owner of the Napa Valley vineyard and winery Chateau Montelena in California is under pressure, from the bank, his creditors, and the effects his recent divorce has had on him. In Paris, British sommelier Steven Spurrier is running an unsuccessful wine shop, and decides to generate some custom by organising a blind tasting, comparing the long-established French vineyards with the wines now coming out of California. Travelling to Napa, he tries Jim's Chardonnay and is very impressed. When Jim finds that this trusted assistant Gustavo Brambilia has been making his own wines behind Jim's back, he fires him. In order to infuriate Bo, Jim's dissolute high school dropout son, Gustavo sleeps with Sam Fulton, an intern at the winery, knowing that Bo is secretly very taken with her. Jim discovers that Bo has used his mother's money to buy new barrels for the winery, replacing the aged casks, and is furious. Spurrier prepares to return to Paris and offers to include Jim's Chardonnay in his tasting panel, and is surprised when Jim refuses. Spurrier goes to the airport, rebuffed, but Bo follows him and gives him some of the wine as he prepares to check-in. When Jim discovers what he has done he fires Bo, incandescent that he should take such a decision upon himself against his father's express orders. Jim is stunned when he finds that the entire stock of Chardonnay has turned brown, believing it has been exposed to air or some other substance which has tainted it. He gives up, and returns to an office job. Sam suggests Bo consults a local wine expert, taking him a sample, who examines the Chardonnay and deduces that the discolouration is a pigment shift which is only temporary, and which only affects wines of a very high quality. Returning to the winery, Sam and Bo are stunned to find that Jim has already arranged for the entire quantity of the wine to be disposed of, and it has been poured away. Knowing a local bar has some bottles of the same batch, they go to the bar and manage to get them back, noticing that they are no longer discoloured. On hearing what Bo has done, seeing that he really has the best interests of the Montelena Winery at heart, he agrees to have the wine included in Spurrier's 'Judgement Of Paris' tasting, quitting his office job and sending Bo over as his representative. At the testing, some very sophisticated palates work their way through a number of wines, some world famous and others, such as Montelena, completely unknown, and Bo anxiously awaits the judge's decision.

Production

Director
Randall Miller
Producer
J. Todd Harris, Branda Lhormer, Marc Lhormer, Randall Miller, Jody Savin and Marc Toberoff
Art Director
Craig Sterns
Editor
Randall Miller and Dan O'Brien
Music
Mark Adler
Screenplay
Jody Savin, Randall Miller and Ross Schwartz, based on a story by Ross Schwartz, Janette Pabon, Jody Savin and Randall Miller
Director of Photography
Mark Ozier

Review

Very obviously trying to get on the maitre d's coat tails after the surprise success, financially and critically, of Sideways, director Randall Miller's Bottle Shock, a title which sounds like a medical syndrome more than a movie, weaves around a real event, the famous, at least in the vintning world, 'Judgement of Paris', a blind wine tasting held in 1976 by a British sommelier Stephen Spurrier (Alan Rickman - Sweeney Todd, and refining yet further his selection of sneers), who was trying to find an alternative to French vintages which were becoming ever more expensive year on year and wanted to see if the upcoming wines from California could match them for quality. Miller uses this as the framework for an underdog story, with a feisty American taking on and defeating the French wine industry, but is so relentlessly upbeat and packed with 'can-do' fervour that it positively hurts. Focusing on one Napa Valley winemaker, Jim Barrett (Bill Pullman - Lost Highway), an amalgam of several genuine Californian winemakers, producing a Chardonnay at his Chateau Montelena winery but who is facing hard times, and who desperately needs to get some sort of sales boost to keep his vineyard open. His situation is not helped by his son Bo (Chris Pike, the new Captain Kirk in the Star Trek reboot), who wants nothing to do with the wine business, and also has a rival in one of his own employees, Gustavo (Freddy Rodriguez - TV's Six Feet Under), who is also secretly making his own wine with the vineyard's grapes. Miller got noticed with his 1990 short, The Marilyn Hotchkiss Ballroom Dancing & Charm School, which was expanded into a feature in 2005 and garnered decent reviews but little in the way of box-office, and Miller again pulls together a fine cast, including Rachael Taylor (Transformers), Dennis Farina (TV's Law And Order), Eliza Dushku (TV's Tru Calling), Miguel Sandoval (Collateral Damage), Bradley Whitford (TV's The West Wing) and Joe Regalbuto (The Sicilian), but the screenplay by three writers, including the director, dwells for a long time on Jim's problems, where seemingly everything which could possibly go wrong with his wine, including a discolouration taint which is unbelievably rare, and conveniently only temporary, takes a very long time to get to the actual competition. Instead Miller tries to get the audience to worry if Jim is going to finally relent and let his Chardonnay be entered in Spurrier's competiton, and if he doesn't then why has the audience been watching? Essentially wanting to make a feelgood movie, Miller doesn't take the most interesting elements in the story, Jim's possible ruin and his darkening mood and mental state, to its' logical conclusions, with his abandonment of the vineyard he loves in order to go back into an office job, a momentous decision, being handled surprisingly flippantly, a pity since Pullman is a seriously underrated actor whom only David Lynch seems to give deeply serious roles. Miller isn't quite pouring out Thunderbird when Chateau-Lafitte had been promised, but he falls short of producing something vintage.