Film details

Diminished Capacity  2009

Cast

Synopsis

Cooper, a Chicago newspaper columnist, is involved in an accident and suffers severe concussion, which causes him memory lapses. Given a leave of absence on health grounds, he is asked by his mother to return home to help with his Uncle Rollie, who he loves, who has been behaving bizarrely and showing signs of memory loss and possible dementia. She wants him to consider moving into a care home, thinking he will soon be unable to look after himself. A fiercely independent man, he considers the move to the home, and Cooper finds that he has an extremely rare baseball trading card, showing Frank Schulte, a player for the Chicago Cubs from the early 1900s, and which is possibly worth a six-figure sum. Rollie wants to sell it, and is scared of it being stolen, so when Cooper discovers that there is to be a sports memorabilia convention held nearby, he persuades Rollie to come with him, Cooper's ex-girlfriend Charlotte coming along with them. After a phone call to his editor, he having heard about the card and tried to get Cooper to part with it for far less than it is worth, Cooper is fired. At the convention, with word spreading about the Frank Schulte card, he realises that there are some very serious buyers, and some totally obsessive fans, including Lee Vivyan, a thuggish baseball-obsessive, willing to do anything, and hurt anyone, to get the card, and Mad Dog McClure, a surprisingly gentle man, despite his nickname, but who is equally intent on securing the rare card. Realising what he feels for Charlotte, and confessing that he still has feelings for her, he realises that he has let Rollie out of his sight, and finds him at one of the trading tables, having already sold the card to an unscrupulous dealer, having taken advantage of one of Rollie's brief lapses. This, for Cooper, is the last straw....

Production

Director
Terry Kinney
Producer
Tim Evans, Galt Niederhoffer, Celine Rattray and Daniela Lundberg Taplin
Art Director
Matthew Munn
Editor
Tim Streeto
Music
Robert Burger
Screenplay
Sherwood Kiraly, based on his own novel
Director of Photography
Vanja Cernjul

Review

Bearing an extremely unpromising title, Diminished Capacity is an odd and not entirely successful comedy which deals with an awkward topic in the form of Alzheimer's Disease, and the terrible legacy which comes with it. Sherwood Kiraly adapts his own novel for the screen, with uneven results, the tragedy of the situation, and the humour which comes from the discovery of a valuable trading card, coming across as broader and more obvious when transferred to the screen. Central character is Cooper (Matthew Broderick - The Producers), a Chicago journalist suffering post-concussion memory loss after an accident, and who returns to his Missouri home town, La Porte, to recuperate. Once there he meets an old flame, Charlotte (Virginia Madsen - Sideways) and his elderly uncle Rollie (Alan Alda - TV's M*A*S*H), now suffering from Alzheimer's and who is about to be moved into a rest home. Both Cooper and Charlotte feel bad about this, and while they are clearing out his house in preparation for his move discover a vintage baseball trading card, showing a member of the 1908 Chicago Cubs. The card is of course the McGuffin on which to hang the fates of Rollie, Cooper and Charlotte, with Cooper trying to protect Rollie from those at the memorabilia fair who would cheat him out of what the card is really worth, but how can he protect him when Rollie's biggest enemy is largely himself. Its' a difficult subject, although Alda has shown himself to be an actor with a surprising range, and turns in a performance as good and endearing as anything he has done as Rollie, a man who sees his future all too clearly, clarity being a condition he may find himself losing as time passes. The potentially interesting connections between Rollie's long-term state and Cooper's short-term condition are largely ignored. Actor turned director Terry Kinney (TV's Oz), making his feature directing debut, keeps the audience guessing by constantly varying the tone, upbeat one moment and dark and ominous the next, with Rollie's mental condition being variable depending on the effect required, but brings in two very interesting peripheral characters at the convention, with Bobby Cannavale (Snakes On A Plane) alarming as a fan literally willing to kill for the all-important card, while Dylan Baker (Changing Lanes / Revolutionary Road) is equally dedicated but has at least achieved some sort of equilibrium, balancing his obsession with something at least resembling a normal life. Willing to ruthlessly manipulate the plot, and Rollie's condition, in order to achieve a happy ending for all concerned, Kinney's film is enjoyable enough, even if Broderick and Madsen are hardly stretched, but one wonders what could have been if the script and direction had taken a darker, more realistic approach to Rollie and his impending fate.