Film details

Chloe  2009

Cast

  • Amanda Seyfried
  • Laura DeCarteret
  • Max Thieriot
  • R.M. Thomson
  • Nina Dobrev
  • Mishu Vellani
  • Kathryn Krlitmaa

Synopsis

A remake of the 2003 French film Nathalie, with Liam Neeson (Taken), Julianne Moore (Saving Grace) and Amanda Seyfried (TV's Big Love) taking the roles played in the original by Fanny Ardant, Gerard Depardieu and Emmanuelle Beart, the very talented Atom Egoyan, director of such interesting and intelligent pieces of work as The Adjuster, Felicia's Journey and Where The Truth Lies, seems to come a cropper with this tale of suspected infidelity and marital trust, with some critics saying that what works so well in the French version just seems alternately silly and wildly overwrought in this English-language retelling. The couple at the heart of the matter are David and Catherine Stewart (Neeson and Moore), an affluent couple living in the upmarket Yorkville district of Toronto. Catherine believes that David may be being unfaithful, he being a college music professor with some obviously adoring female students. Wanting to know whether her husband is susceptible to the charms of other women, she encounters Chloe (Seyfried), an attractive young woman who seems to constantly be in the area, and employs her to find out if David will fall for her charms. But Catherine has perhaps picked the wrong woman, or perhaps the perfect one, since Chloe is actually a high-class call girl. The relationship between employer and employee gets more interesting, or less credible, depending on how one looks at it, when Catherine starts demanding to know what Chloe has discovered about David, which leads her to recount long stories of their encounters, which may or may not be true, and the film starts to concern whether Catherine really wants the truth, or some form of it for her own purposes, a recurrent theme in Egoyan's films. Catherine of course is quite aroused by all this herself, but the descriptions of what Chloe and David are doing, or at least supposed to be doing, pretty quickly get rather ludicrous, undermining the credibility of the story rather, a flaw the French version didn't suffer from, and the quickly spiralling climax (as it were) in the adaptation of the original script by Erin Cressida Wilson (Secretary / Fur), quickly becomes both dramatically very dubious and also strangely moralistic. Since the Stewarts seems to have a pretty comfortable life, and most of the major scenes are shot at some of the best restaurants in the city, the question remains why Catherine just doesn't ask David over her concerns, but then of course there would be no film. Chloe is the first time Egoyan has attempted a remake, or an adaptation of a foreign original, and that's out of his system now perhaps he should return to his own original, thought provoking scripts, which made him the respected director is undeniably is. On a rather sadder note, the film is what Liam Neeson was shooting when his wife Natasha Richardson was killed in a freak skiing accident in March 2009, resulting in shooting being rescheduled for several days while he was away from the set.

Production

Director
Atom Egoyan
Producer
Jeffrey Clifford, Joe Medluck and Ivan Reitman
Art Director
Kim M. McQuister
Editor
Susan Smith
Music
Mychael Danna
Screenplay
Erin Cressida Wilson, based on the film Nathalie, directed by Anne Fontaine and written by Philippe Blasbland, Anne Fontaine, Jacques Fiesclu and Francois-Olivier Rousseau
Director of Photography
Paul Sarossy

Review

A remake of the 2003 French film Nathalie, with Liam Neeson (Taken), Julianne Moore (Saving Grace) and Amanda Seyfried (Dear John / TV's Big Love) taking the roles played in the original by Fanny Ardant, Gerard Depardieu and Emmanuelle Beart, the very talented Atom Egoyan, director of such interesting and intelligent pieces of work as The Adjuster, Felicia's Journey and Where The Truth Lies, seems to be uncertain how to handle this tale of suspected infidelity and marital trust, with what works so well in the French version just seeming alternately silly and wildly overwrought in this English-language retelling, and interestingly it is not only the first time that Egoyan has attempted a remake or worked with previously produced material, but also that he has not handled the screenplay himself, helming from a script by Erin Cressida Wilson (Secretary / Fur) based on the original by Philippe Blasbland, Anne Fontaine, Jacques Fiesclu and Francois-Olivier Rousseau. The couple at the heart of the matter are David and Catherine Stewart (Neeson and Moore), an affluent couple living in the upmarket Yorkville district of Toronto. Catherine believes that David may be being unfaithful, he being a college music professor with some obviously adoring female students. Wanting to know whether her husband is susceptible to the charms of other women, she encounters Chloe (Seyfried), an attractive young woman who seems to constantly be in the area, and employs her to find out if David will fall for her charms. But Catherine has perhaps picked the wrong woman, or perhaps intentionally the perfect one, since Chloe is actually a high-class call girl. The relationship starts to get more complicated than Catherine had originally planned, and it soon becomes a question as to whether she truly wants to know what her husband is doing or, more interestingly, she merely wants to hear these increasingly salacious tales, which at points are slightly embarrassing, the audience being brought into the conversations as unwilling voyeurs, becoming aroused by all this herself, the descriptions of what Chloe and David are doing, or at least supposed to be doing, the tale taking another twist when it appears that Chloe indeed has become obsessed herself with Catherine in a strange Fatal Attraction twist, but the revised ending in the Wilson script, which does actually pivot on a very clever confrontational moment, at least makes it clear that this is a film by a respected director with a previously very clear vision and style rather then just a retread of a French adult drama re-tooled for an upmarket soft porn audience. Since Wilson was also responsible for the screenplays of both Secretary and Fur, both of which took a very offbeat look at aspects of both love and sexuality, it is obvious why she was chosen, but the situation seems to spiral out of control extremely quickly and obviously. Since the Stewarts seems to have a pretty comfortable life, and most of the major scenes are shot at some of the best restaurants in the city, the question remains why Catherine just doesn't ask David over her obvious concerns, but then of course there would be no film, and the chances of her employing Chloe (a well-cast Seyfried) who proves to be such a manipulative and sophisticated sex worker, would seem to defy all credible odds. Chloe is the first time Egoyan has attempted a remake, or an adaptation of a foreign original, and that's out of his system now perhaps he should return to his own original, thought provoking scripts, which made him the respected director is undeniably is. On a rather sadder note, the film is what Liam Neeson was shooting when his wife Natasha Richardson was killed in a freak skiing accident in March 2009, resulting in shooting being rescheduled for several days while he was away from the set.