Film details

Robin Hood  2010

Nottingham / Lincoln Green

Cast

Synopsis

When everybody thinks about the partnership between Ridley Scott and Russell Crowe (Scott being one of the very few directors to ever work with him more than once, which may be an indicator or something or other), they tend to raise Gladiator rather than American Gangster, Body Of Lies or, Lord help us, A Good Year, and we have a terrible feeling that Robin Hood is going to be bracketed with the latter rather than the glory days of Maximus Decimus Meridius. Retelling the story in an apparently very traditional fashion, that of an archer in the army of Richard Coeur de Lion, who fights the Norman invaders and becomes the folk hero known as Robin Hood, there were originally rumours that the script would take some pretty wild diversions, such as Crowe playing both Hood and the Sheriff of Nottingham, or that the idea would be totally flipped, with the Sheriff being the good guy, a kind benefactor to his people, with Hood as basically a thieving, violent mercenary, in charge of a Dirty Dozen-style band of thugs and murderers, neither of which proved to be true. The pic has been a troubled production to say the very least, with extended production delays causing Sienna Miller to drop out of the role of Maid Marian, to be replaced by Cate Blanchett (Elizabeth), numerous script re-writes, with both Brian Helgeland and Sir Tom Stoppard turning in drafts of the original version by Ethan Reiff and Cyrus Voris, rumours of Crowe being less than popular in the various drinking establishments in and around the Farnham and Welsh locations, due to shall we say boisterous behaviour, and a budget rumoured to be well past $200m, not to mention a release date which has been changed more than once. As is usual with Scott's movies there is a terrific cast, including Mark Strong (Scott's Body Of Lies), Danny Huston (30 Days Of Night) as King Richard, William Hurt (Lost In Space) as William Marshall, Matthew Macfadyen (TV's Little Dorrit) as The Sheriff of Nottingham, Kevin Durand (X-Men Origins: Wolverine) as Little John, Lea Seydoux (The Last Mistress) as Princess Isabella and the superb Eileen Atkins as Eleanor of Aquataine. From what has been seen so far it looks excellent, as one expects since Scott is using his regular DoP, John Mathieson, and features top-rate production and design work, but somehow we don't think this will come even close to breaking the box-office records set by Robin Hood: Prince Of Thieves only eighteen years ago.

Production

Director
Ridley Scott
Producer
Ridley Scott, Brian Grazer and Russell Crowe
Art Director
David Allday and Ray Chan
Editor
Pietro Scalia
Music
Marc Streitenfeld
Screenplay
Brian Helgeland (uncredited - and Tom Stoppard), based on a story by Ethan Reiff and Cyrus Voris, and Brian Helgeland
Director of Photography
John Mathieson

Review

When anybody talks of the partnership between Ridley Scott and Russell Crowe (Scott being one of the very few directors to ever work with him more than once, which may be an indicator of something or other), they tend to raise Gladiator rather than American Gangster, Body Of Lies or, Lord help us, A Good Year, and Robin Hood is certainly more the story of Maximus Decimus Meridus, relocated to England and advanced some twelve hundred years, than any of the other collaborations. Retelling the story in a screenplay by Brian Helgeland (Payback), based on an original script by Ethan Reiff and Cyrus Voris which for some time was a very hot property in Hollywood, this version amalgamates a number of elements, including some of the very few known facts of the actual character on whom the legend of Robin Hood was based and embroidered, until the story, as it is now known, became so conflated and adapted until little of the truth remained. The pic was a troubled production to say the very least, with extended production delays causing Sienna Miller to drop out of the role of Maid Marion, to be replaced by Cate Blanchett (Elizabeth), numerous script re-writes, Tom Stoppard turning in an uncredited draft, rumours of Crowe being less than popular in the various drinking establishments in and around the Farnham and Welsh locations, due to shall we say some boisterous behaviour, and a budget rumoured to be well past $200m, not to mention a release date which was repeatedly changed. The original concept of the script, originally entitled Nottingham, had the Sheriff almost being the good guy, a reasonable benefactor to his people, with Hood as basically a thieving, violent mercenary, in charge of a Dirty Dozen-style band of thugs and murderers, concepts which have not made it through to Scott's version, with Crowe eventually reaching England after some complex identity-swapping, and only taking up arms when meeting the father and wife of the fallen Robert of Loxley (Douglas Hodge - The Descent Part 2), finding that the people are being oppressed by unfair taxation by the newly-ensconced King John (Oscar Isaac - Agora), which makes him turn into the folk figure who seeks justice for all, and the story largely adheres to the true history of the period, but Scott's film seems less concerned with establishing an alternate version of the Hood legend as with placing him in the context of the threatened French invasion of England, planned by King Philip (Jonathan Zaccai - The Beat That My Heart Skipped), with the Hood character becoming a rallying commander for the English troops against the potential invaders, and as can be guessed from Gladiator, the action scenes are very brutal and very skilful staged, the sheer close-quarters savagery of the combat of the times being very well and very believably. Scott is obviously taking a more reasoned historical approach to the material, and the film is more about the establishment of the various English charters of rights rather than a chap hiding in the woods in green tights, even if Crowe's accent, which seems to be Southern Irish, and which caused the well-known charmer to become very aggressive indeed when various interviewers commented on it, has less grounding in fact. As is usual with Scott's movies there is a terrific cast, including Mark Strong (Scott's Body Of Lies), Danny Huston (30 Days Of Night) as King Richard, William Hurt (Lost In Space), Matthew Macfadyen (TV's Little Dorrit) as The Sheriff of Nottingham, Kevin Durand (X-Men Origins: Wolverine) as Little John, Lea Seydoux (The Last Mistress) as Princess Isabella and the superb Eileen Atkins as Eleanor of Aquataine, and it is certainly a different interpretation to Kevin Costner's 1991 record-breaker. But although visually impressive and undeniably exciting, there's a strange confusion at the heart of the film as to what it really wants to be.