Film details

Beyond a Reasonable Doubt  2009

Cast

  • Jesse Metcalfe
  • Amber Tamblyn
  • Sewell Whitnay
  • Orlando Jones
  • Troy Bentley
  • Megan Brown
  • Joel Moore
  • Michele Williams
  • Meade Patton
  • Grant James
  • Sharon London

Synopsis

C.J. Nicholas, a journalist on a news station in Shreveport, Louisiana, writes an award-winning piece concerning a young homeless teenager in New York, who dies shortly after the piece starts attracting attention, and C.J. is made chief investigative reporter on the station. He believes D.A. Mark Hunter is fabricating evidence with which to convict suspects and keep up his extremely high conviction rate, and decides to try to expose him, beginning with dating his assistant, Ella Crystal, while working on his plan to frame Hunter by finding a murder case in which there are no leads or evidence, and forge evidence which points to himself as the main suspect. When C.J. is arrested, which he will also engineer, and Hunter produces faked DNA evidence to secure the conviction, the truth will be shown on a DVD which C.J. is working on with his assistant, Corey Finley. Their plan goes into action when the body of a local prostitute is found. C.J. gets himself arrested for drunk driving, and ensures that the arresting policeman, Officer Ben Nickerson, sees his trainers, which have the same sole pattern as those found near the body and which are believed to be the footprints of the killer. A search of his house provides more of his planted 'evidence', backed up with Officer Anthony merchant, a corrupt Policeman on Hunter's payroll, checks C.J.'s bank statements and bills and realises that C.J. is fabricating the incriminating evidence in order to frame Hunter. C.J. is sent for trial and Hunter produces the expected faked DNA evidence, Corey getting ready to produce the DVD revealing the set-up, but as he drives to the bank safe-deposit facility for the disc, retrieving a back-up copy made for safety, he is forced into a car accident by Merchant and killed. Without the evidence DVD, and unable to prove that this was all fabricated, C.J. is found guilty and sentenced to death. On Death Row he manages to convince Ella that he is genuine, and that her boss is crooked, managing to persuade her to try to help him prove he is actually an innocent man, Examining the crime scene photographs with the aid of a digital photography expert, Ella reluctantly is forced to concede that the DNA evidence Hunter provided is fake. Merchant realises that she is now about to expose Hunter's corruption, and knows that he will have to get rid of her also, but although Ella has the evidence against one man, there is another discovery she is going to make which she is not ready for....

Production

Director
Peter Hyams
Producer
Mark Damon, Limor Diamant, Moshe Diamant, Michael P. Flannigan, Ted Hartley and Peter Hyams
Art Director
Kevin Hardison
Editor
Jeff Gullo
Music
David Shire
Screenplay
Peter Hyams, based on the screenplay of the 1956 film by Douglas Morrow
Director of Photography
Peter Hyams

Review

One of the most needless remakes imaginable, Peter Hyams' Beyond A Reasonable Doubt is based on the superb 1956 Fritz Lang thriller, a film virtually perfect as it is, and the alterations and updatings in the new script by Hyams (2010 / Running Scared) himself, based on the original screenplay by Douglas Morrow, certainly add nothing to the concept. In the original, a truly brilliant nail-biter, a writer is determined to show how an innocent man could be sent to Death Row through miscarriage of justice, only to find himself being the victim of one when his plan goes wrong. The target was the system itself, which could condemn the innocent to death. Here Hyams, who as usual operates his own camera, changes the focus and makes the actual target one man, Michael Douglas as Mark Hunter, a well respected D.A. with an impeccable record of putting away the bad guys, and being the favourite for the upcoming state Governorship, who finds himself being investigated by reporter C.J. Nicholas (Jesse Metcalfe - TV's Desperate Housewives), who believes that a lot of his convictions have been secured through fabricated DNA evidence. C.J. sets himself up as a murder suspect in order to try to expose Hunter's corrupt dealings, but his plan goes radically wrong and he finds himself being prosecuted for real, with all his alibis and evidence proving his innocence unable to be presented. Amber Tamblyn (TV's Joan Of Arcadia) plays Ella Crystal, the assistant D.A. who is also involved with C.J. but is torn between proving his innocence and protecting her boss. Although the basis of the plot is essentially the same, Hyams seems to want to turn the film into a simple good guy / bad guy tale, with Douglas, a very talented actor who seems to have been purely going through the motions in recent years, being a credible but underused bad guy, even if seeming to be channelling Wall Street's Gordon Gekko yet again, while Jesse Metcalfe is oddly colourless and strangely dispassionate as the journalist whose crusading seems to come quite far down in his list of priorities considering the amount of time he spends romancing assistant D.A. Ella. Oddly Hyams seems to be almost disinterested in his own script, as the film chugs along with really little dramatic drive, moving on through various set-ups, made all the more complex through the needless additions of various henchmen working for Hunter, and while there was the possibility that there was no way of making or storing a back-up of the vital information in 1956, and that it could all be destroyed in an accident, in a 2009 which has everything from data DVDs and timed e-mails to memory sticks or even files stored on the Net, this is a massive plot flaw. By focusing on Hunter, who is so transparently obviously the baddie, the film's focus is immediately shifted towards him, so much so that the later various twists come across as utter disorienting. Shot in Shreveport, Louisiana, the location of the heinous Disaster Movie, seemingly only because of the state's much advertised colossal tax and benefits advantages, even the car chase, handled so well by Hyams in Running Scared, seems redundant. See the original, and marvel at a plot, performances and direction as perfectly in sync as a Swiss watch, and which is still watched and admired more than five decades after it was made.