Film details

Dear John  2010

Cast

  • Amanda Seyfried
  • Henry Thomas
  • Richard Jenkins
  • Luke Benward
  • Scott Porter
  • David Andrews
  • Keith Robinson
  • D.J. Cotrona
  • Cullen Moss
  • Leslea Fisher
  • Maxx Hannard

Synopsis

Despite receiving a raft of pretty terrible reviews in the US, Dear John is liable to be a microscopic footnote in the history of film simply through being the pic which displacedAvatar at the top of the US box-office after seven straight weeks, in which it became the top-grossing film ever, with a contributing factor in that it was taken from a novel by Nicholas Sparks and was also aimed at a completely different demographic, women 15-30, than Avatar, giving cinemagoers something utterly different from ten-foot tall blue aliens in 3D. Since Sparks is responsible for the bestsellers which became films such as Message In A Bottle, Nights In Rodanthe and The Notebook, one knows exactly what to expect, a finely-tuned weepie in which loss and grief weigh heavily, but critics in the States were surprised quite how solemnly and faithfully director Lasse Hallström (What's Eating Gilbert Grape / The Cider House Rules) approaches the material, making a painfully earnest and sombre romance, in which any happiness in a love affair is swift, fleeting and doomed to end in tears and pain. Some have accused both Sparks and the film of rather tasteless opportunism, having the film begin in the spring of 2001, as soldier John Tyree (Channing Tatum - G.I. Joe) falls for a college student, Savannah Curtis (Amanda Seyfried - Mamma Mia / TV's Big Love) while on leave, and after a whirlwind love affair they part, she going to college while he is getting ready to leave the Army, but then 9-11 happens and he wants to re-enlist, as he tells her in the letters they obsessively write each other. Amid other complains is that the structure of the plot largely keeps the protagonists apart for most of the film, cranking up the emotions until the manipulative twist in the middle, and unlike other Sparks adaptations this is about younger people than his normal characters, who usually find love later in life and which transforms them, and although Channing Tatum can strike poses in the likes of Step Up and G.I. Joe, giving him yards of emotional romantic dialogue really isn't his forte, especially when so much of the film consists of the correspondence being read out over particularly drippy musical montages. Of course those who know Sparks' work will know that he is determined that the path of love will not run smooth, even when its' as homogenised as this, and will probably be expecting the big twist thrown in towards the end. There's certainly an audience for this sort of thing, and one which rarely ventures outside the very strictly defined demographic, but reviewers have said that even those who know the author and his works may find this a bit heavy-going if only through the sheer earnestness of it all.

Production

Director
Lasse Hallström
Producer
Marty Bowen and Wyck Godfrey
Art Director
Mark Garner
Editor
Kristina Boden
Music
Deborah Lurie
Screenplay
Jamie Linden, based on the novel by Nicholas Sparks
Director of Photography
Terry Stacey

Review

Dear John is liable to be a microscopic footnote in the history of film simply through being the pic which displaced Avatar at the top of the US box-office after seven straight weeks, a contributing factor in Dear John's success is that it was taken from a novel by Nicholas Sparks and was aimed at a completely different demographic, women 15-30, than Avatar, giving cinemagoers something utterly different from ten-foot tall blue aliens in 3D. Since Sparks is responsible for the bestsellers which became films such as Message In A Bottle, Nights In Rodanthe and The Notebook among others, six of his books being filmed in the past decade, one knows exactly what to expect, a finely-tuned weepie, ruthlessly engineered, in which loss and grief weigh heavily, but director Lasse Hallström (What's Eating Gilbert Grape / The Cider House Rules) approaches the material unbelievably solemnly, making a painfully earnest and sombre romance, any happiness in a Sparks-penned love affair being swift, fleeting and doomed to end in tears and pain. Although this is pretty de rigeur for this author, some have accused both Sparks and the film of rather tasteless opportunism, having the film begin in the spring of 2001, as soldier John Tyree (Channing Tatum - G.I. Joe) falls for a college student, Savannah Curtis (Amanda Seyfried - Mamma Mia / TV's Big Love) while on leave, and after a whirlwind love affair they part, she going to college while he is getting ready to leave the Army, but then 9-11 happens and he re-enlists, as he tells her in the letters they obsessively write each other, most of Sparks stories having long, long scenes of characters essentially reading letters from each other, featuring most heavily in The Notebook and Message In A Bottle, and this choice of structure for the plot largely keeps the protagonists apart for most of the film, cranking up the emotions until the manipulative twist in the middle, and unlike other Sparks adaptations this is about younger people than his normal characters, who usually find love later in life and which transforms them. Where Sparks and the film truly pushes its' luck is introducing such elements as terminal cancer and autism, both in children and adults, which ramps up the emotional weight but to absurd degrees. Although Channing Tatum can strike poses in the likes of Step Up, giving him yards of emotional romantic dialogue really isn't his forte, especially when so much of the film consists of the correspondence being read out over particularly drippy musical montages, and he's also a member of the cleanest and most pure-hearted US soldiers ever, with barely the mildest of curses or violent epithet passing their lips. Of course those who know Sparks' work will know that he is determined that the path of love will not run smooth, even when its' as homogenised as this, but others may think that here he starts to revel in his characters' pain, and it truly seems as if they are merely conduits to get maximum misery and grief on the screen, or utter virtuous saintliness in the case of Amanda Seyfried's Savannah, even more than usual.