Film details

Law Abiding Citizen  2009

Cast

Synopsis

Clyde Shelton, an ordinary citizen, is forced to watch as his wife and daughter are murdered during a home invasion robbery by a pair of sadistic thugs, the leader of the gang and the man responsible for their death, Clarence Derby, being picked up by the Police shortly afterwards. Clyde goes to Nick Rick, known to be a prosecutor with a record of being ruthless against criminals, to represent him, but when Nick realises that some of the Police evidence is shaky, he agrees with Derby that he will get a lenient sentence if he will turn evidence against his accomplice, Rupert Ames, despite Clarence being the double murderer, since it will maintain his 96% conviction success rate. Clyde is appalled at this miscarriage of justice and swears revenge, Nick telling him that it is the only way they could get both men imprisoned. Ten years pass and Ames is executed after years of appeals. Clarence Derby is a free man, but he is kidnapped and tortured to death by a vengeful Clyde, who then surrenders to the Police. Although there is no hard evidence linking Clyde to Derby's murder, he confesses to Nick, now a hugely successful lawyer with his own large practise, seeming to want to be imprisoned. He tells Nick that the justice system is broken and has to be changed, to persecute the criminals rather than the victims, and then tells him that he has kidnapped Derby's defence lawyer, Bill Reynolds, and will reveal the man's location if a lavish gourmet meal from a five-star restaurant is delivered to his cell that evening at a time of his choosing. The meal arrives late, and Nick is given the location, but by the time he arrives the man, buried alive, has died, Clyde saying he would have survived had the meal arrived when he stipulated. Hiding a bone from the steak he had just eaten, Clyde then uses it to kill his cellmate, a gang killer, and is put into solitary confinement. Investigating his background, Nick finds that Clyde previously worked for the CIA in devising covert and concealed methods of assassination, being a skilled engineer, both mechanical and electronic. Nick goes to a Judge, Laura Burch, and tries to have Clyde placed in total isolation, not allowed any contact with any guards or access to any electronic equipment, believing he has set a series of traps and hidden killing devices before entering prison, but she is killed by a booby-trapped mobile phone Clyde has already rigged. Clyde tells Nick that unless he is released by 6pm then everybody in DA Jonas Cantrell's office will die. Nick evacuates the office but several of the staff are killed when car bombs destroy their vehicles. Nick attends one of the funerals, but this too is booby-trapped, a remote-controlled heavy machine-gun cutting down many of the mourners, killing several including Cantrell. Nick is made acting DA, and knows Clyde is running this campaign of revenge from his cell, but unable to prove it, none of the devices yielding any clues to when they were set or who was in control of them. Finding that Clyde owns a warehouse adjacent to the prison here he is being held, Nick investigates the building, only to find a series of tunnels leading between the two, allowing Clyde to leave his cell at night and work on his devices. Nick believes he can now stop him by preventing him getting access to his equipment, but Clyde is already at least one step ahead of the lawyer and is planning for his last act of revenge which, he has promised, is going to be Biblical....

Production

Director
F. Gary Gray
Producer
Gerald Butler, Lucas Foster, Mark Gill, Robert Katz, Alan Siegel and Kurt Wimmer
Art Director
Jesse Rosenthal
Editor
Tariq Anwar
Music
Brian Tyler
Screenplay
Kurt Wimmer, (uncredited) Frank Darabont, David Ayer and Sheldon Turner

Review

My, what a lot of Gerard Butler cinemagoers are having lately. Scripted by Kurt Wimmer (Equilibrium / Ultraviolet) and several other uncredited writers including Frank Darabont (The Shawshank Redemption), Law Abiding Citizen has an impressive director in the form of F. Gary Gray (The Negotiator / The Italian Job remake), and an undeniably top-flight cast, but it is really only a hi-tech Death Wish, with an outlandish plot which has the vigilante Clyde Shelton (Butler) operating his one-man campaign of revenge from his jail cell, the script obviously wanting to turn him into a technically gifted Hannibal Lecter, a man whose reach is far beyond the four walls he has deliberately imprisoned himself behind. Jamie Foxx, yet another actor who has found A-list roles hard to come across after his Oscar win, is the lawyer who Shelton believes has betrayed him, cutting a deal with the murderer who took his wife and child in a home invasion, lawyer Nick Rice claiming that it was the only way to secure the convictions of both men, when in actuality his ambition to keep his 96% conviction rate also rather coloured the deal. At the centre of the ironically-titled Law Abiding Citizen is an interesting idea, that a man should carry out his revenge campaign against the machinery of law itself, claiming it is corrupt and serves the criminals rather than the victims, Shelton's complex devices killing the lawyers and judiciary who he sees as pandering to a rotten system rather than the criminals themselves, an interesting theme which is soon lost between the killing devices which also suggest the various writers have seen at least one Saw movie before sitting at the laptop, and the final twist, as to how Shelton is able to carry out his campaign, is really surprisingly obvious, and raises more questions as to credibility than it answers. Most of the film totters on the knife-edge of ingenuity and absurdity, especially as with all their evidence the law cannot seem to connect Shelton to any of the increasingly elaborate killings, and quite a lot of the plot coasts along on the goodwill of the viewer once Shelton is locked up yet is seemingly able to carry out acts of sabotage it would take an entire Special Forces unit complete with sappers to arrange and implement. Foxx is trying to resuscitate his career after largely abandoning acting after winning the Oscar for Ray in 2004 to take up a career as an r'n'b singer, saying that singing was what he really wanted to do instead of act, while still taking the occasional gig such as Michael Mann's big screen version of Miami Vice but since his albums sold less than James Last Plays The Best Of Slipknot he's back in front of the cameras, and seems to be taking anything which will put his name above the title on the posters. Gray can certainly handle tension and action, and the supporting cast is quite superb, including Colm Meaney (Layer Cake / The Damned United) and Bruce McGill (Collateral, which also starred Foxx), heavyweights all in all sorts of ways, but Butler makes for an uninteresting leading man, not letting the audience believe at any point that he is intelligent or devious enough to carry out this magnitude of plan, well executed though the set-pieces are. Law Abiding Citizen has a fascinating idea at its' heart, a man wanting to bring down the system of law simply because too often it seems to be on the wrong side, but turning Butler's Shelton into Hannibal the Mechanical isn't the best way to go.