Film details
The Invention of Lying 2009
This Side of the Truth
Still unavailable
Cast
-
Ricky Gervais
-
Jennifer Garner
-
-
Jason Bateman
-
Tina Fey
-
-
Christopher Guest
-
-
-
Jeffrey Tambor
-
Jimmi Simpson
-
Martin Starr
Synopsis
Somewhere in an alternate reality, the human race has developed in the normal way, but has not developed the ability to lie. Dates are conducted with brutal truths being told on both sides, products advertise themselves purely for what they are or what they do rather than with glossy images or false expectations. The average workplace resentments and feuds are completely out in the open, and films, since fiction is not known, consist of men in easy chairs reading history books. Mark Bellison, an Englishman living in a typical American town goes on a date with the attractive and intelligent Anna Douglas, their opening conversations being about their respective expectations of the evening ahead, and their mutual doubts as to the success of what is to come. Mark has a job as a screenwriter, essentially turning historical events into a condensed form for a narrator to read, but when he loses his job his more handsome and more successful colleague Brad Kessler is naturally unable to hide his delight. Facing eviction from his apartment, and realising he is running low on funds, a misunderstanding at the bank accidentally has the bank crediting him with more money than he actually had, Mark realising his completely unwitting collusion with the mistake has invented a new and remarkable concept - that of deception, and by actively controlling it, also the concept of deliberate lying. Being the only human with this power, Mark soon uses it for his own ends, managing to manipulate a casino into paying him huge amounts simply by lying about what he has placed on the roulette table, no one even comprehending that he could not be telling the truth, and also using this new found power to help out a suicidal friend by simply reassuring him that everything will be alright, something Mark knows is a lie but which gives his friend great comfort. Writing an expansive and wildly imaginative fictional story, Mark regains his job by persuading the producers that it is historical fact, newly discovered, and a follow-up date with Anna, who was not keen on him initially, comes along with his new-found success. She finds him interesting, but also tells him that she finds him physically unappealing, so still will not be sleeping with him. Visiting his dying mother Martha, who is scared of what is to come, he invents various stories about life after death, with eternal happiness and how the entire human race is looked after by an all-powerful benevolent overseer, but when his tales are overheard Mark finds himself being taken up as a form of guru, who seems to have secret knowledge about the 'Man in the sky', since nobody disbelieves him. He rapidly becomes hugely rich and powerful as his fledgling belief system starts to take root in society, and he continues to pursue Anna, the one person he does not lie to, but is distraught when she takes up with Brad instead, telling Mark she suspects he has better genes than him. When the pair announce their engagement, he dives into depression, but decides that telling the truth is still for some things, such as love, the best policy, and plans one last meeting with Anna....
Production
- Director
- Ricky Gervais and Matthew Robinson
- Producer
- Dan Lin, Lynda Obst and Oly Obst
- Art Director
- Priscilla Elliott
- Editor
- Chris Gill
- Music
- Tim Atack
- Screenplay
- Ricky Gervais and Matthew Robinson
- Director of Photography
- Tim Suhrstedt
Review
With Ricky Gervais becoming more and more a totally divisive performer, divided between those who think he can do no wrong and those who totally loathe him, one has to remember that he is actually, underneath it all, a very talented writer, and the script for The Invention Of Lying, co-written with the debuting Matthew Robinson, has a brilliant and adventurous idea at its' core, even if it initially seems an obverse parallel to the Jim Carrey starrer Liar Liar. The setting is an alternative world, where everybody always speaks the truth, simply because they cannot lie, so any enquires such as 'How are you?' gets a long rambling answer about the subject's state of health, and the question 'Does my bum look big in this' always threatens to instigate divorce. This is where the film, co-directed by Gervais and Robinson, is at its' strongest, showing just how this has affected the development of this world, and since how fiction (i.e. not the truth) is unknown, there can be no fictional narratives, so films are just static shots of men in comfy armchairs reading historical events out of books. The natural balance of things is totally upset when one man, Mark (Gervais), a screenwriter, accidentally discovers he has the power to do the unthinkable, to actually lie and deceive, which gives him incredible powers in this mirror world, and also allows him to use this new found skill to pursue the woman of his dreams, Anna (Jennifer Garner - Daredevil / Elektra), although paradoxically this seems to be the one situation in which his skill is of no use. Although the film loses steam after he develops this secret skill, becoming surprisingly conventional in its' romantic sub-plot, the script still comes out with some concepts which, for a largely studio-backed US film, are really quite radical, not only by Mark comforting a suicidal friend by telling him that everything will be alright, an idea his friend accepts, while Mark knows the truth, and in a truly brave move, essentially inventing religion by trying to offer comfort to his dying mother, making up stories about a benevolent man in the sky in order to offer some solace to her, Gervais himself being a well-known atheist, and becoming amazed when this load of invented twaddle, as he sees it, suddenly becomes enormously popular, seeming to fill a void in these purely rational, imagination-free people's lives. These are not only remarkable ideas for a mass-market comedy, but in a high-profile US film aimed at the multiplexes it is incredible that they ever got through the script stage. Unfortunately although having the basis of a truly innovative piece of work, the film loses conviction halfway through, and despite such brilliant concepts, with the added possibility that Mark himself could literally make himself a God on earth through his powers, he decides to play it very safe, as if making up for the imaginative excesses of the first half, as Mark almost inexplicably decides not to lie to Anna, emphasising that he is a nice guy at heart, which makes the eventual disappointingly conventionally happy ending all the more disappointing given the possibilities. Having the Gervais character abuse his powers yet more would have made the film far more interesting as it progressed rather than less. Gervais has his detractors but it must be must be admitted that he has put together a simply brilliant cast for his film, drawing in such comedy talents as Tina Fey (TV's 30 Rock), Jason Bateman and Jeffrey Tambor, both from TV's Arrested Development, and the brilliant actor / director Christopher Guest, as well as Jonah Hill (Superbad, okay so they're not all that talented), and his oppos Steven Merchant and Shaun Williamson, showing his loyalty to his BBC repertory company, although brief cameos from the likes of Philip Seymour Hoffman and Edward Norton are needlessly distracting. Gervais and Robinson keep the visuals on the bland side, making some of the compositions and sets quite oddly uninteresting, insisting that in a world essentially without imagination this is how it would live, The Invention Of Lying, although not entirely successful, not being able to live up to its' superb set-up, still manages to be a truly surprising script which posits some terrific questions about society and relationships and that most taboo of subjects, religion, but there are those who will not see anything Gervais is in at any price, which in this case is their loss.