Film details
All the Real Girls 2003
Still unavailable
Cast
-
Paul Schneider
-
-
-
Shea Whigham
-
-
Benjamin Mouton
-
Maurice Compte
-
John Kirkland
-
Maya Ling Pruitt
-
Heather McComb
-
James Marshall Case
-
Karey Williams
Synopsis
Asheville, North Carolina, was once a burgeoning mill town, but now the mill has closed, taking most of the life of the town with it. It is run-down and rambling, and Paul Fine, a young man in his early twenties, lives there with his mother Elvira and is just managing to make a living working for his Uncle Leland. Paul spends most of his spare time with the three friends he has known since childhood, Tip, Bo and Bust-Ass, and although the three chase women and make remarks at any passing girls, it is Paul who is the ladies' man of the trio, gaining a reputation for loving them and leaving them, never allowing them to enter his mind again once it's over. Most of the young women in the town have been the recipients of Paul's charm at one time or another. Tip introduces Paul to his eighteen year old sister Noel, who has returned to the town for the summer holidays from her boarding school, and privately Tip tells Paul to stay away. Noel is a virgin. Despite this she and Paul become interested in each other and start to spend more and more time with each other, something which angers Tip who worries for his sister, knowing how Paul uses women. Paul finds that Noel is different from all the other girls in the town, both deeper and more delicate. The two book a night in a nearby motel, wanting some privacy, but spend the night just talking, both eventually admitting their love for each other, emotions they both feel unable to deal with, and eventually not sleeping together. Paul tells Tip what he really feels about his sister and Tip realises that Paul is being serious. Their friendship is restored, Paul being surprised when Tip admits that he has found out he is going to be a father. Noel goes to a weekend party one of her school friends is throwing. When she comes back she tells Paul that she slept with a boy she met there, one of the guests. Paul is both shocked and furious, and breaks up with Noel, telling her he never wants to see her again, but changes his mind when, days later, he finds she has been seen with another of his friends, Bust-Ass. They meet once more, feeling awkward with each other and eventually go to bed together, but neither is completely comfortable with the other. Although seemingly reconciled, Paul is not totally convinced that their futures involve each other.
Production
- Director
- David Gordon Green
- Producer
- Jean Doumanian and Lisa Musket
- Art Director
- Richard Wright
- Editor
- Zane Baker and Steven Gonzales
- Music
- Michael Linnen and David Wingo
- Screenplay
- David Gordon Green, based on a story by David Gordon Green and Paul Schneider
- Director of Photography
- Tim Orr
Review
Sharing many of the same elements as his debut production George Washington, David Gordon Green's second film has the same slow, languid atmosphere and script longeurs, the silences between the main characters of Paul (co-scripter Paul Schneider) and Noel (Zooey Deschanel - The Good Girl / Elf) often saying more than the dialogue, emphasising the gap between them as well as the empathy. As with real love it doesn't run smooth, and one can see the characters changing from uncertainty to awareness, and as with so much in real life the pivotal moments, in this case Noel losing her virginity to a boy she met at a party rather than Paul, are inexplicable; they just happen. The setting of the real ex-mill town of Asheville is very well used, reflecting the general decay of everyone's spirit, including Paul's, who sees Noel as a chance to start again. Tim Orr, who also received praise for his work on George Washington, is impressive, but, like his previous movie, the slow pace of Gordon's film may try the patience of some.