Film details

The Red Baron  2008

Der Rote Baron

Cast

  • Matthias Schweighofer
  • Lena Headey
  • Joseph Feinnes
  • Richard Krajco
  • Maxim Mehmet
  • Hanno Koffler
  • Jan Vlasak
  • Branislav Holicek
  • Ralph Missek
  • Tino Mewes
  • Volker Bruch

Synopsis

As the War in Europe rages in 1917, Baron Manfred Von Richthofen, a hugely decorated Prussian air ace, dubbed The Red Baron, is reprimanded by the German command for flying a mission in which he dropped a wreath behind enemy lines for the funeral of a British flier he shot down, the officers claiming he put himself in danger unnecessarily. The head of the Jagdstaffel 11 squadron, on his next mission, flying his own bright red Fokker Dr.1 tri-plane, he scores a victory over Lanoe Hawker, a noted British fighter pilot, for which he is awarded the 'Pour Le Merite' medal, also known as The Blue Max and Prussia's highest military honour. After an aerial skirmish during which he shoots down Captain Roy Brown, a Canadian flyer, he lands and helps the wounded man out of the plane, handing him over to a nurse, Kate Otersdorf, to tend to his injuries. His high level of kills makes him hugely popular in Germany, finding himself used for propaganda purposes, but he is worried about the high number of casualties in his own flying group, other flyers being unable to match his level of brilliance, and becomes worried when his younger brother, Lothar, joins his section. Finding themselves once more locked in combat, both Von Richthofen and Brown crash their planes in no-man's-land, which leads to a friendly meeting between them, both men recognising and acknowledging the other's talents. When an aerial clash results in Von Richthofen being wounded, and he is forced to crash land the plane, his wounds are tended by Nurse Kate, and they fall in love. With the Germans planning an infantry advance in early 1918 which they believe could turn the tide of the war, Von Richthofen and his airmen are enlisted to provide air cover, but he believes the war is already lost, and tries to persuade Kaiser Wilhelm and Marshal Von Hindenberg, who hold him in high regard, to surrender and make a negotiated settlement, which infuriates the German high command. In response they ask him to stand down from active flying and to take an organisational role in the Luftwaffe, but he refuses, and his veiled comments about dying in battle as a warning to others worry Kate. He takes to the air on another mission, leaving Kate to wait for the seemingly inevitable news.

Production

Director
Nikolai Müllerschön
Producer
Dan Maag, Roland Pellegrino and Thomas Reisser
Art Director
Thomas Molt (supervisor)
Editor
Emmelie Mansee, Olivia Retzer and Adam P. Scott
Music
Stefan Hansen and Dirk Reichardt
Screenplay
Nikolai Müllerschön
Director of Photography
Klaus Merkel

Review

Oddly, apart from Roger Corman's underrated The Red Baron (aka Von Richthofen And Brown) the life of one of the first true fighter pilots, Baron Manfred Albrecht Freiherr Von Richthofen (here played by Matthias Schweighofer - Valkyrie) has been surprisingly ignored by filmmakers, although the very successful The Blue Max (1966) was largely inspired by his exploits. Flying a tri-decked Fokker Dr.1, painted a vivid red, he was an incredibly gifted pilot, lethally accurate, and soon led his own fighter wing, known as The Flying Circus, but although writer and director Nikolai Mullerschon's film has been praised in some quarters for its' flying and combat sequences, entirely CGI unlike earlier air combat films which generally relied on a mix of real planes, mock-ups and models it flies into flak when it comes to authenticity, since large swathes of the flyer's life are largely fabricated, including a highly idealised meeting with Captain Roy Brown (Joseph Feinnes - TV's FlashForward), the Canadian who it is claimed eventually shot him down, and then tries to add an incongruous love story, he falling for a nurse, Kate Otersdorf (Lena Headey from TV's Terminator - The Sarah Connor Chronicles). In wanting to make Von Richthofen appear chivalrous, coming as he did from genuine Prussian nobility, Mullerschon burnishes his image considerably, adding levels of decency and aerial chivalry which were actually quite unknown in the man, who did not earn eighty acknowledged kills through being some sort of flying Good Samaritan as the film sometimes portrays him, and indeed he was known for his ruthlessness, going after planes which were already going down in order to make sure the pilot was killed. The film also tries to portray him as both a rationalist and a conciliator as he starts to realise he is being used for propaganda by the German authorities, even though he had written his autobiography which sold surprisingly well in Britain in translation, but refuses to leave the air force, saying the other pilots need him and even tries to persuade the Kaiser to accept a negotiated settlement, leading to the completely revisionist idea that he actually sacrificed himself in order to hasten the end of the War, which is an interesting new interpretation of the facts to say the very least. Having introduced Brown, and having the two have an almost genial rivalry, the film then rather cheats by avoiding Von Richthofen's death altogether, with many thinking that Brown was actually not responsible but that the Baron was downed by a lucky shot from an Australian unit on the ground, but having the ace shot down by one man, the photogenic Brown, made for better headlines. Mullerschoen's film is certainly ambitious, and clearly made with an eye to the international market, made in English, budgeted at 18 million Euros (@£15.4m), but unfortunately flopped badly in its' native country, dropping out of the German box-office charts after the first two weeks of release, with many reviewers complaining about the amazing level of historical inaccuracy, with the love story being largely fictional and Von Richthofen being portrayed as a man with a strong moral conscience about the ethics of what he is doing, when in reality he was utterly ruthless. If one can ignore this extreme tampering with the truth then the aerial scenes are extremely impressive, if slightly too clean and flawless in a video game style, but for a more accurate version of the tale, as well as a very fine performance from the late John Phillip Law as the aristocratic Baron, Corman's version is surprisingly the one to track down.