Film details

City Island  2008

Cast

Synopsis

City Island, a part of the Bronx which more resembles New England than New York, with neighbourhoods of timbered houses and an almost genteel ambiance, is home to the Rizzo family, patriarch Vince being a corrections officer at a prison. Vince starts to realise that one of the young inmates, Tony Nardella, is actually his son from a brief relationship decades ago before he was married to his wife, Joyce. When Tony is given probation, Vince offers him the sue of a spare room in his house, but does not reveal their relationship. Vince also has another secret that he is keeping from his family, that he is taking acting lessons, hoping to become a professional actor, but to hide his embarrassment should he fail he tells Joyce that he plays poker with some of his work buddies, Joyce instead suspecting he is having an affair. The only one he tells of his ambition is fellow student Molly Charlesworth, with whom he starts to share all the little secrets he can share with no one else. His daughter Vivian returns home from college for spring break, not telling her parents that she has taken to working as a stripper in order to pay her fees, her scholarship having been revoked and the job being the only way to continue her studies. His son, Vince Jr, has yet another secret, scouring the internet for images and footage of severely obese women, visiting several specialist websites, finding to his amazement that one of the 'models' on a site which features footage of such women cooking, is actually their next-door neighbour, Denise. Convinced Vince is being unfaithful, Joyce finds herself admiring Tony as he does yard work, and is attracted to her, but Tony, when he makes advances on him, politely rebuffs her. Hearing there are to be auditions for a new Scorsese film, Molly persuades Vince to go along, but after a nervous, misjudged opening eh soon calms down and impresses the casting agents with a broadside about perceived Italian-American machismo and brutality. He wins the role, but when he meets Molly to tell her, she reveals a secret of her own, that she abandoned her own young children. He realises he wants to tell Joyce about the acting role, and persuades Molly to accompany him in order to tell Joyce, but once home she immediately jumps to the conclusions that they are involved with each other, and in retaliation lies about having seduced Tony, just as the young man returns home with Vivian, leading to more hurtful assumptions being made, and the Rizzo family becoming further confused, angry and entangled.

Production

Director
Raymond De Felitta
Producer
Raymond De Felitta, Andy Garcia and Zachery Matz
Art Director
Sorangel Forsobe
Editor
David Leonard
Music
Jan A.P. Kaczmarek
Screenplay
Raymond De Felitta
Director of Photography
Vanja Cernjul

Review

Similar in feel to indie breakout hit Little Miss Sunshine, City Island, written and directed by Raymond De Felitta (Tis' Autumn - The Search For Jackie Paris), won the Audience Award at the 2009 Tribeca Film Festival, leading to immediate distribution deals for several territories, although the very dry, very New York wit and surprisingly warm disposition towards its' characters may not necessarily translate. The family at the centre of De Felitta's comedy are the Rizzos, living in the City Island area of the Bronx, an oddly charming piece of NY real estate which, although genuine, seems utterly alien in such a setting,. Father Vince (Andy Garcia - Internal Affairs) is a frustrated prison office, living with his wife Joyce (E.R.'s Julianna Margulies), a secretary. Their daughter Vivian (Dominik Garcia-Lorido - The Lost City, and incidentally Andy Garcia's daughter) is living with them but not telling them that she is actually working as a stripper at the local pole-dancing club in order to continue to fund her studies, while their son, Vince Jr (Erza Miller - Afterschool) has a very bizarre fetish, being obsessed with websites featuring hugely obese women, which literally comes closer to home when he realises his neighbour is one of the 'models' on one of these sites. It all seems fairly predictably quirky, but Vince has the biggest secrets of the lot, not only bringing a parolee, Tony (Steven Strait - 10,000 B.C.) home, which would seem to be at least some form of breech of the prison rules, mostly because he realises the boy is his son from a previous tryst, but is also sneaking off to take acting classes in Manhattan, where for once in his life he receives encouragement from an English classmate (Emily Mortimer - Young Adam). He has to try to keep this from the rest of his family, and ironically it becomes all he enjoys and makes him start to wonder if indeed he could leave the prison system and become a professional, or should he just keep it furtive and not upset the status quo of the family. Although implausible, and slightly disturbing in parts when dealing with Vince Jr and his offbeat interests, De Felitta deals with all this with a surprising charm, making the Rizzos and their travails very watchable, and there is skill in the writing, such as Joyce's acceptance when she believes he is having an affair, willing to put up with it because of the love between them, and Vince being a generally decent character, just wanting to do the best for his family, even the members of it he has just recently discovered existed. A cameo from Alan Arkin, seemingly mandatory for an indie comedy since Sunshine, shows the audience De Felitta is aiming for, and like the earlier film one actually feels for the Rizzos and their problems, even though the family never seems to be on the verge of utter collapse as it does in Sunshine. Boasting fine performances and a surprisingly generous spirit, at 103 minutes the pic runs about ten minutes too long and could be tighter, but as a showcase for strong actors in a surprisingly enjoyable tale this is worth the trip.